The Epic Showdown: Why Disney's Percy Jackson Series Outshines HBO's Harry Potter Reboot

The original book series of Percy Jackson and Harry Potter were released around the same time. Now, their television adaptations are generating a long-debated question: which one is more thrilling? Percy Jackson and the Olympians centers around Percy, a young boy who discovers he is a demigod and attends a camp for children of Greek gods. Similarly, Harry Potter is a book series featuring a young boy who discovers his wizarding abilities and attends a magical school.

The competition between Percy Jackson and Harry Potter is intense due to their notable similarities. Both series focus on "chosen ones" fighting against evil alongside their two best friends. Additionally, both series have been adapted into movies, spinoff series, and more. As the two series are now being transformed into television adaptations, it appears that Percy Jackson, despite being less popular and aimed at a younger audience, could overcome its Harry Potter competition.

7 Percy Jackson Still Needs A Good Adaptation (Harry Potter Doesn't)

6 JK Rowling's Controversial Involvement Sours The Harry Potter TV Show

The Percy Jackson television series surpasses the excitement of Harry Potter's HBO reboot due to its lack of a complete on-screen adaptation. While Harry Potter enjoyed a total of eight films spanning seven books, along with successful spinoff franchises like Fantastic Beasts, the Percy Jackson movies faltered and were ultimately canceled. As a result, Percy Jackson deserves a television adaptation more than ever. Not only does it warrant a faithful adaptation of its entire five-book series, but it also offers audiences a fresh and unexplored on-screen experience. This sets it apart from the immensely popular Harry Potter franchise.

The involvement of J.K. Rowling, the author of the Harry Potter series, in its reboot has been widely criticized. Despite once being praised for creating the globally popular franchise, Rowling's controversial anti-trans comments on social media have tarnished her reputation. As a result, fans of Harry Potter have turned against both Rowling and the franchise as a whole, choosing to distance themselves from her divisive views. Consequently, the HBO Harry Potter reboot is facing widespread boycotts due to Rowling's role as executive producer. Some even suggest that instead of watching Harry Potter, audiences should consider watching Percy Jackson.

5 Percy Jackson Deserves A Larger Fanbase Like Harry Potter

Although Harry Potter and Percy Jackson came out around the same time and share similar concepts, there is no denying that Harry Potter has achieved significantly greater success. While Percy Jackson does have a considerable fan base, Harry Potter has become a household name and its franchise has consistently remained popular since the 1990s. This reality actually adds to the excitement of the Percy Jackson show, as it is hoped that the series will be able to attain the same level of fame and success that Harry Potter has already attained. By transitioning into the realm of on-screen entertainment, Percy Jackson will become more accessible and is likely to attract a larger fan base.

4 Percy Jackson Has A Vast Universe That Hasn't Appeared On-Screen Yet

Compared to the Harry Potter universe, which audiences are already familiar with, the world of Percy Jackson is much larger and still untapped. This makes the upcoming television series even more thrilling. While Harry Potter has the Fantastic Beasts franchise, Percy Jackson has a variety of spinoff series that delve into different mythologies, such as Egyptian and Norse. As a result, the television adaptation of Percy Jackson holds more excitement as it not only brings the original story to life but also offers the potential for numerous other interconnected franchises that are just as captivating. The unseen properties of Percy Jackson make it a highly anticipated series.

3 Harry Potter Fans Are Too Attached To The Original Cast To Entirely Enjoy A Reboot

Another drawback of the Harry Potter reboot is the strong emotional attachment that fans have to the original adaptation. The audience has grown alongside the actors, namely Daniel Radcliffe, Emma Watson, and Rupert Grint, who portrayed the beloved characters from the beginning. Accepting a completely new cast presents a difficult hurdle to overcome for fans. In contrast, Percy Jackson doesn't face this issue as the majority of fans are embracing the new cast members. This gives Percy Jackson a distinct advantage over Harry Potter. While Harry Potter is accompanied by nostalgia and therefore some baggage, Percy Jackson enters the television realm with a relatively clean slate.

2 Percy Jackson Comes Out Before Harry Potter

When it comes to the race between Percy Jackson and Harry Potter, Percy Jackson has a clear advantage due to its earlier release date. While Percy Jackson is scheduled to hit the screens in early 2024, the release date for Harry Potter is more uncertain, set for either 2025 or 2026. This gives Percy Jackson a significant amount of time to establish itself, possibly even film an entire second season, before Harry Potter becomes available on television. As a result, Percy Jackson has a greater opportunity to attract and build a new fan base, ultimately gaining popularity. Overall, the proximity of Percy Jackson's release makes it more thrilling than Harry Potter's indefinite launch date.

1 Percy Jackson Finally Has The Chance To Outshine Harry Potter

The Percy Jackson television series surpasses Harry Potter's in terms of excitement, granting Percy Jackson the opportunity to shine brighter than ever before. Despite Harry Potter's historical dominance in terms of success and popularity, the controversies surrounding it and its delayed release provide the ideal circumstances for Percy Jackson to finally emerge victorious. This would undoubtedly bring great satisfaction to Percy Jackson fans who have long engaged in debates with the Harry Potter fan base regarding significance and popularity. Overall, the Percy Jackson series presents a new, invigorating show that lacks the controversy associated with Harry Potter and offers a heightened level of excitement.

Although both television series are likely to find success upon their respective releases, the anticipation is particularly high for Percy Jackson's chance to bask in the limelight. After years of existing in the shadow of Harry Potter, it is now time for Percy Jackson to claim the dedicated fan base and well-deserved success it has always yearned for. However, only time will reveal the ultimate winner of the enduring popularity contest between Percy Jackson and Harry Potter.