Summary
The real-life bank robber criticizes the bank robbery scene in The Dark Knight, saying the safe, school bus crash, and more are unrealistic.
The reviewer recognizes that the film is intentionally exaggerated and not focused on being realistic.
The initial bank robbery scene effectively introduces the Joker's character and establishes the grim and disorderly atmosphere of Gotham City.
Real-life bank robber Cain Vincent Dyer, who carried out over 100 bank robberies before surrendering to the authorities, was enlisted by Insider to evaluate the bank robbery scene featuring Heath Ledger's Joker in The Dark Knight.
According to the expert, the complex and secure vault encountered by the Joker's gang poses a challenge. Dyer suggests that even the US military might struggle to infiltrate it. Dyer also comments on the undamaged school bus that crashes into the bank, among other things. These aspects prompt a harsh criticism of The Dark Knight's bank robbery scene from a real-life bank robber, who rates it a mere "1." Read the complete quote below:
"This vault appears impregnable, potentially only accessible by the US military. We should remember that this movie aims to be larger than life in every way. While it is true that they portray intricate and time-locked safes that are difficult to penetrate, it is not uncommon for certain safes to remain open during business hours for employee convenience."
I acquired extensive knowledge about bank security measures. I could easily determine whether a bank had a secure vault like the one depicted in this scene or if it simply had regular open doors. If it lacked proper security measures, I would move on unless I discovered information in their manuals or had prior knowledge that they kept a certain door open during specific times. In those times, I could potentially exploit this vulnerability. In the past, when manual operations were more prevalent, breaking into such a vault would have been a time-consuming task, far from a quick three or four-minute job.
You wouldn't typically find a weapon like that inside unless there was an armed security guard present. It's important to consider the consequences of firing a shotgun in that scenario. If a security guard were to shoot at a bank robbery suspect, the projectiles could potentially go through the suspect and hit innocent bank customers or employees.
Why It Doesn't Matter Joker's Bank Robbery Isn't Accurate
: The school bus remains untarnished despite its collision with a sturdy cement and stone structure. It is worth recalling that the perpetrators of the building robbery ascended the steps, adding a touch of Hollywood-esque excitement. This remarkable incident warrants a mere 1 out of 10 on the intensity scale."The Dark Knight's portrayal of Joker's bank robbery may not be grounded in reality, but that doesn't diminish the exhilarating nature of the movie's opening sequence. Even real-life bank robber Dyer acknowledges that the film was not aiming for accuracy in depicting a bank heist. In fact, Dyer's review begins by emphasizing, "We must remember that this movie, everything about this movie, is meant to be extravagant and exaggerated."
The Dark Knight's bank robbery effectively introduces Ledger's Joker and showcases his brutality. Only the Joker survives the heist, highlighting his masterful planning. The chaotic sequence also demonstrates the grim state of Gotham City, with crew members turning on each other and the bank manager resorting to violence. This exaggerated portrayal offers a contrast to the realistic tone of Nolan's trilogy and adds excitement to the scene.
Source: Insider