Red Dead Redemption is set in a dangerous world where death can strike unexpectedly. Within this lawless Wild West era, people lived in constant fear for their lives due to various pressing concerns. Consequently, it is understandable why the stories in both Red Dead Redemption games often delve into dark territory. The characters in these games navigate the morally corrupt nature of their surroundings, facing the choice to either conform to the darkness or hold onto their values and moral compass. This struggle between good and evil is beautifully captured through memorable yet haunting quotes, showcasing the exceptional writing within the series.
7 "You Don’t Get To Live A Bad Life And Have Good Things Happen To You." — Arthur Morgan
Arthur Morgan stands out as a profoundly wise character within the game, particularly when players choose the path of high honor. With a deep understanding of life's true essence, he never deceives himself by claiming to be virtuous.
Despite his genuine efforts to do good, Arthur acknowledges the multitude of crimes he has committed and recognizes the need to face the consequences. Having engaged in acts of robbery, murder, and theft throughout his existence, he harbors no illusions of a favorable outcome.
6 "People Don't Forget. Nothing Gets Forgiven." — John Marston
John Marston, a wise character, serves as the protagonist in the first game and the epilogue of the second. Many players adore him for his tough yet understanding demeanor. Similar to Arthur, John recognizes the importance of accountability for one's actions, including his own.
During a conversation with Bonnie, John shares a detailed account of his father's animosity towards the English due to his Scottish heritage, despite never having visited his ancestral land. This illustrates the powerful impact of negative memories on individuals' thoughts and beliefs.
5 "This Place... Ain't No Such Thing As Civilized. It's Man, So In Love With Greed... He Has Forgotten Himself And Found Only Appetites." — Dutch Van Der Linde
Once upon a time, Dutch was an effective and conscientious leader who prioritized the collective well-being. However, a series of personal misfortunes compelled him to heed the deceptive counsel of Micah Bell, ultimately eroding the trust of the camp.
It is truly regrettable, considering Dutch's inherent wisdom, that he tragically lost his path within the events of Red Dead Redemption 2. His relentless rebellion against civilization can be interpreted as a critique of capitalism, wherein the pervasive avarice of individuals becomes increasingly apparent in the midst of the industrial revolution.
4 "If We Have To Fight, We Fight. If We Have To Run, We’ll Run. If We Must Die, We’ll Die. But... We’ll Stay Free." — Javier Escuella
Javier's descent into the wrong side of history was regrettable considering the enjoyment players experienced when they got to know his lively character. While he possessed admirable traits, his unwavering loyalty to Dutch caused him to gradually lose his direction.
Above all else, Javier cherished the notion of freedom and detested any societal constraints. He embraced this mindset from Dutch, and witnessing the downfall of his revered mentor shattered him, propelling him towards a path of darkness beyond redemption.
3 "We're All Doomed, Reverend." — Arthur Morgan
Reverend Swanson, despite his hypocritical nature, is a captivating character who presents himself as a man of god while indulging in numerous sins. Interacting with him is truly enjoyable due to the intricate complexity that shines through in every conversation.
Having offered Javier Escuella guidance in hopes of redeeming him, the Reverend pessimistically declares that his friend is bound for doom. However, the protagonist, aware of the harsh realities of the world, responds by pointing out that everyone in the gang is destined for a similar fate. This statement carries a sense of foreboding, considering the events that unfold in the game.
2 "We Die Alone, But Live Amongst Men." — John Marston
John's straightforward demeanor endeared him to fans, as he never hesitated to speak the truth. His undeniable authenticity made him a remarkable protagonist.
Although John had companions within his gang, he harbored no illusions about their loyalty in the event of his demise. Aware that he was merely an outlaw, he acknowledged that ultimately, one would face solitude in death irrespective of the presence of friends.
1 "Sure, Civilization May Be Dull, But The Alternative, Mr. Marston, Is Hell." — Edgar Ross
The Pinkertons are notorious video game villains, but their motivations are undeniably logical. The Van der Linde gang's actions, including the harm they caused and lives they took, made it inevitable for the government to relentlessly pursue them.
During his coercion of Marston into hunting down his gang, Edgar Ross emphasizes the significance of civilization. This insight into his character showcases his unwavering determination and unwillingness to overlook any detail in achieving his objective.