The 10 Biggest Pirates Of The Caribbean Plot Holes Across All 5 Movies

Introduction

The Pirates of the Caribbean franchise, known for its swashbuckling adventures and supernatural elements, has captured the imaginations of audiences worldwide. However, as the franchise expanded with each new sequel, it became increasingly plagued by inconsistencies and plot holes. In this article, we delve into the ten most perplexing plot holes across all five movies, shedding light on the narrative inconsistencies that have left fans scratching their heads.

Young Will in POTC Curse of the Black Pearl

From unexplained character behaviors to inexplicable story developments, the Pirates of the Caribbean series is riddled with narrative gaps that have challenged the suspension of disbelief. Join us as we uncover the mysteries behind these plot holes and embark on a journey through the enigmatic world of the Pirates of the Caribbean.

Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides

10. Will's Medallion Does Not 'Call' To The Black Pearl Crew

One of the earliest plot holes that puzzled fans occurs in the opening scene of Pirates of the Caribbean: Curse of the Black Pearl, where Elizabeth Swann discovers Will Turner wearing an Aztec medallion. Years later, when the medallion reacts to the ocean water and emits a large pulse, it is revealed that 'the gold calls' to the cursed crew of the Black Pearl. However, the medallion notably did not exhibit the same behavior when Will survived the shipwreck, raising questions about its inconsistent effects and the crew's awareness of its presence. This perplexing inconsistency challenges the logic of the narrative and has left fans searching for answers.

Aztec medallion underwater in POTC Curse of the Black Pearl

The unexplained nature of the medallion's behavior and its selective 'calling' to the cursed crew presents a glaring plot hole that undermines the coherence of the story. The lack of consistency in the medallion's effect on the crew's actions raises significant questions about the narrative's internal logic and the portrayal of supernatural elements within the franchise.

Young Elizabeth in POTC Curse of the Black Pearl

9. Ragetti Reacts To Hot Coals When He Should Not Feel Anything

In another puzzling development, the character Ragetti, a member of the cursed crew, reacts to hot coals during an attack on the governor's mansion. Despite being cursed to feel nothing, Ragetti's surprising reaction to the coals raises continuity issues and challenges the established rules of the curse. This inconsistency in the portrayal of the cursed crew's immunity to physical sensations introduces a baffling narrative gap that detracts from the coherence of the story.

The cursed crew of the Black Pearl in Pirates Of The Caribbean Curse Of The Black Pearl

The unexpected deviation from the established rules of the curse creates a jarring discontinuity in the narrative and undermines the credibility of the supernatural elements within the Pirates of the Caribbean universe. Fans have been perplexed by this inconsistency, which stands out as a significant plot hole in the franchise's storytelling.

Barbossa in Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides

8. Will Is Covered In Barnacles Despite His Role

A notable inconsistency arises in Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Men Tell No Tales, where the character Will Turner, tasked with ferrying souls to the next world, inexplicably appears covered in barnacles. This development contradicts the implication that only those who deviate from their true purpose undergo a transformation, raising questions about the narrative's internal coherence and the portrayal of character transformations.

Will Turner in close up in Pirates of the Caribbean Dead Men Tell No Tales

The unexplained presence of barnacles on Will Turner challenges the established rules of the franchise's supernatural elements and introduces a puzzling narrative inconsistency that has left fans bewildered. The lack of clarity surrounding Will's transformation raises significant questions about the franchise's storytelling and the portrayal of character destinies.

Will and Henry on the Dutchman in Dead Men Tell No Tales