Spider-Man 2 vs Across the Spider-Verse: A Divisive Showdown Dividing Fans!

Spider-Man fans have been delighted with two remarkable milestones in the hero's journey: Spider-Man 2 on PS5 and Across the Spider-Verse. Now the question arises, which one is superior?

With Into the Spider-Verse, it felt like a turning point not only for superhero films but also for animation itself: its dazzling utilization of vibrant colors and explosive comic book visuals was ground-breaking, rightly deserving the prestigious Oscar for Best Animated Feature.

Five years later, the trilogy presented us with its second installment: Across the Spider-Verse, to which we awarded four stars. "We are fortunate to be witnessing the realization of animated superhero films' potential in this day and age. And as they say, with great power comes great responsibility. Therefore, fulfill your duty and make sure to watch it as soon as possible," we expressed.

In a different year, it would unquestionably dominate as the pinnacle of superhero entertainment. However, Spider-Man 2 has proven to be a formidable contender, leaving fans undecided on which is truly superior.

Fans debate Spider-Man 2 vs Across the Spider-Verse

We provided Spider-Man 2 with high praise, stating: "Assuming the role of a friendly neighborhood Spider-Man is captivating. The game skillfully grasps the significance of being able to save the world as well as assist an individual in crossing the street, effectively showcasing this contrasting concept."

Inevitably, the constant comparison between the two titles arises. It brings to mind the memorable phrase from the Old El Paso commercial, where a little girl asks, "Why not have both?" Nevertheless, fandoms thrive on the habit of quarreling and using one thing to gain an advantage over the other.

One user in the movie's corner confidently argues that "Across The Spider Verse will be considered one of the greatest achievements in filmmaking in the years to come."

"Without a doubt, Across the Spider-Verse is the clear winner. The characters are engaging, the art direction is impeccable, the soundtrack is fantastic, and the narrative is incredibly interesting. It is easily one of the best movies of the year, and quite possibly the best Spider-Man story ever brought to the screen," another comment states.

"The story in Spider-Man 2 doesn't even come close to comparing with ASTV. While Spider-Man 2 is well-made, it doesn't offer anything new. ASTV, on the other hand, is an original story that succeeds on every level. It is unquestionably the best film of the year so far, with Oppenheimer and Flower Moon taking second and third place respectively," a third tweet reads.

Going to bat for Spider-Man 2, some users have even cited specific side missions; for example, when you’re tasked with finding Grandpa Earl.

One participant expressed their difficulty in choosing, ultimately favoring Spider-Man 2 due to the incomplete nature of Across the Spider-Verse's story. They praised the exceptional execution of the Venom narrative and their enjoyment of playing it, even sacrificing sleep on school nights. Another participant unequivocally declared Spider-Man 2 for the PS5 as their top choice, highlighting the unparalleled skill of the Insomniac writers. Although they appreciated Spider-Verse and its sequel, the participant felt unsettled by its perceived lack of completion, with scenes constantly being edited, cut, or added. Conversely, they hailed Spider-Man 2 on PS5 as one of the finest renditions of a Spider-Man story ever told.

Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse is now streaming on Amazon Prime. Sign up here to watch it. Additionally, Spider-Man 2 is currently available on PlayStation 5.

Learn more about Beyond the Spider-Verse here, and explore our other game coverage below.

Rewritten content:

Discover all the outfits available for Peter Parker and Miles Morales in Marvel's Spider-Man 2. Explore the exciting Spider-Man 2 Photo Mode and embark on the thrilling Main Story missions. Are you curious about playing as Venom? Find out if it's possible. Learn how to unlock the mesmerizing Webbed Suits and dive into Marko's Memories. Explore different editions of Marvel's Spider-Man 2 and strive to achieve all the trophies and achievements. Customize your gaming experience with the extensive range of Accessibility settings. Enhance your gameplay by increasing your health and damage. Uncover hidden Spider-Man 2 Photo Ops locations and become familiar with the vast Marvel's Spider-Man 2 map. Keep in mind that by clicking on any product link on this page, we might earn a small affiliate commission.