Sizzling Casting Choices: 10 Actors Perfect for a Modern Reboot of Supernatural!

Supernatural had a successful 15-season run and spawned multiple spinoffs, making it highly possible for a contemporary reboot that would feature different actors in the leading roles. Initially aired in 2005, Supernatural centered around the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean (portrayed by Jared Padalecki and Jensen Ackles), as they followed their father's footsteps to combat demons and rid the world of dark supernatural beings. The bond between the Winchester brothers played a pivotal role in Supernatural; however, despite their best efforts, they often grappled with maintaining their closeness from their youth.

Although Supernatural concluded as recently as 2020, it is increasingly common for popular TV shows to be promptly revived after their original conclusion. A prime example of this is the Gossip Girl reboot, which, despite its poor reception and swift cancellation, targeted the Generation Z audience. The prequel series of Supernatural, titled The Winchesters, met its demise in 2023 after a single season, possibly signaling the end of the franchise. However, if Supernatural desires to continue with further narratives, rebooting the original show with a fresh ensemble cast might prove to be the most prosperous endeavor.

10 Benjamin Wadsworth As Sam

9 Taylor Zakhar Perez As Dean

Benjamin Wadsworth has gained familiarity with the realm of supernatural TV shows through his previous appearances in Teen Wolf and Unhuman. However, it is his notable role in the sci-fi series Deadly Class that has truly placed him in the spotlight. In this series, Wadsworth portrays Marcus, a teenager who grapples with the challenges of integrating into Deadly Arts - a school catering to the world's most lethal individuals. Through his compelling portrayal of Marcus, Wadsworth has accumulated substantial experience in delving into sinister supernatural themes and embodying characters who strive to better the world, even if it means occasionally bending the rules. As such, he would be an ideal choice to portray Sam Winchester in a revitalized version of Supernatural.

Taylor Zakhar Perez, known for his breakout role as Marco in the Kissing Booth franchise, would be a fitting choice to portray the older Winchester brother, Dean. With his previous on-screen experience showcasing a wide array of emotions, including his convincing portrayal of a protective character in The Kissing Booth, Perez possesses the necessary range to seamlessly transition into the world of supernatural acting. Furthermore, his recent appearance in Red, White & Royal Blue highlights his continued growth as an actor.

8 Mark Consuelos As John

Mark Consuelos' portrayal of the dark and conniving Hiram Lodge in the long-running TV show Riverdale for four seasons showcases his talent for playing complex characters. Despite appearing to care only for his daughter Veronica, Hiram proves to be a terrible parent. Given Consuelos' ability to capture the essence of layered characters with hidden depths, he would be an excellent choice to portray John Winchester in a Supernatural reboot. Consuelos' experience as Hiram would undoubtedly serve him well in embodying John's strong and fearless demeanor.

7 Billy Burke As Bobby

Bobby Singer is an incredibly compelling character in Supernatural, embodying both the qualities of a devoted father figure and a brash alcoholic. Billy Burke is no stranger to portraying strong and devoted characters, as evidenced by his notable role as Bella's father Charlie in the Twilight movies, where he also sports plenty of flannel. Additionally, Burke has showcased his aptitude for supernatural tales in the horror film Lights Out, and his previous portrayals of morally upright characters would lend themselves well to his depiction of Bobby, who often demonstrated mercy towards monsters unless compelled to eliminate them.

6 Aja Naomi King As Castiel

5 D.B. Woodside As Crowley

Not only is D.B. Woodside well-versed in dealing with the supernatural, his portrayal of Amenadiel in Lucifer has also familiarized him with the art of acting alongside angels and demons. Woodside's versatile performances in Lucifer, The Night Agent, and Suits have clearly demonstrated his ability to embody the character of Supernatural's Crowley. With his equally charismatic portrayal of Amenadiel, and his past roles grappling with complex moral dilemmas, Woodside possesses the perfect skill set to convincingly portray the morally ambiguous Crowley in a Supernatural reboot.

4 Hong Chau As Lucifer

Another potential candidate for a character in a Supernatural reboot is Hong Chau, an actor known for her impressive filmography that includes notable roles in The Whale, The Menu, and Asteroid City. Chau's diverse range as an actress would make her an ideal candidate for portraying the complex and multi-dimensional character of Lucifer. Additionally, her previous role as Diane Farr on The Night Agent demonstrated her capability of embodying characters with sinister intentions. Lucifer, a character known for his anger, jealousy, and immense power, would undoubtedly benefit from the disconcerting portrayal that Chau could bring to the table, utilizing her adeptness at portraying both powerful and meek characters.

3 Elizabeth Gillies As Ruby

Elizabeth Gillies, known for her roles as Jade West in Victorious and Fallon Carrington in Dynasty, is the perfect choice to embody the sinister character of Ruby in a Supernatural reboot. With her portrayal of these dark, manipulative, and powerful characters, Gillies has proven her ability to bring depth and intensity to her roles. Her experience in playing characters who revel in their dark personalities aligns seamlessly with Ruby's mysterious and dedicated persona. Gillies is a natural fit for the role of Ruby and would bring a captivating energy to the character.

2 Eamon Farren As Azazel

Azazel, the demonic character in Supernatural, derives pleasure from inflicting agony onto others, relishing in sadistic tendencies. Unrestrained by morality, he readily resorts to torture as a means of tormenting his victims. Eamon Farren's exceptional acting prowess makes him the ideal choice to portray this malevolent being. With his vast repertoire spanning multiple genres, including the supernatural and romance, Farren's recent depiction of Cahir in The Witcher demonstrates his aptitude in embodying the essence of Azazel. In The Witcher, he skillfully portrays a character involved in a multitude of somber actions, well-acquainted with the supernatural realm. Farren's ability to expertly portray a stoic, enigmatic warrior, who unleashes his emotions with great impact, further solidifies his suitability for the role of Azazel.

1 1968 Chevrolet Camaro Z/28 As The Impala

Dean’s Chevrolet Impala is just as crucial as the other characters in Supernatural. His father bestowed it upon him, making it an essential symbol in the show. A reboot should pay tribute to the original by retaining the classic car style, albeit with subtle updates. The perfect choice would be the 1968 Chevrolet Camaro Z/28, which exudes a slightly sportier appearance, featuring the iconic two lines along the hood and a more compact body. Despite the slight modifications, this timeless vehicle would still exemplify the sentimental value of a car passed down from father to son. Additionally, the Camaro offers ample space to conceal Dean and Sam’s arsenal, mirroring the original Supernatural series.