Ranking Robert Redford's Directorial Contributions: A Comprehensive List

Robert Redford is widely recognized for his significant contributions as an actor throughout his illustrious career. Achieving stardom in the 1960s with acclaimed films like "Barefoot in the Park" (1967) and "Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" (1969), he consistently delivered remarkable performances, both in leading and supporting roles, spanning several decades until his appearance in "The Old Man & the Gun" in 2018.

However, it is worth noting that Redford has also made notable strides as a filmmaker, demonstrating his versatility by juggling both directing and acting responsibilities in certain films. From 1980 to 2012, he directed a total of nine movies. The following list showcases the range of his directorial ventures, ranked according to their overall reception, with the lesser-rated films appearing first and the more acclaimed works towards the end.

9. 'The Company You Keep' (2012)

A stellar cast mostly wasted

Image via Sony Pictures Classics

During the 1970s, Robert Redford starred in notable political drama/thriller movies that continue to be highly regarded, including All the President's Men from 1976 and Three Days of the Condor from 1975. Perhaps it is appropriate, then, that at least one of the films he directed can also be classified in a similar genre. This holds true for The Company You Keep, which stands as Redford's most recent directorial effort to date.

8. 'Lions For Lambs' (2007)

Despite the impressive cast assembled here, there is little else to be excited about in The Company You Keep. Robert Redford movies have always managed to attract notable stars, and this one is no exception. With talents like Julie Christie, Brendan Gleeson, Susan Sarandon, Stanley Tucci, and Nick Nolte, the acting prowess is undeniable. However, the film itself is a typical by-the-numbers drama/thriller centered around journalism and risky activism.

Streep plus Redford deserved better

Image via 20th Century Fox

The 2007 film, Lions For Lambs, boasts an impressive ensemble cast including Meryl Streep, Tom Cruise, Andrew Garfield, and Michael Peña. Despite its runtime of just over 90 minutes, the film manages to accommodate these talented actors by intertwining three simultaneous stories that unfold in real time. While this ambitious approach may seem intriguing, the execution falls short, leaving the audience wanting more from the writing. Nevertheless, the film deserves credit for its willingness to take risks, even if it doesn't quite succeed in the end.

7. 'The Legend of Bagger Vance' (2000)

Much-hyped sports movie disappointment

Image via Twentieth Century Fox Film Corporation

Yet again, The Legend of Bagger Vance portrays Robert Redford attempting to tackle more than he could handle as a director. Released in 2000, this film merges a typical narrative about an underdog in a sports genre with a touch of fantasy. The sport at the center of this tale is golf, and the backdrop is the state of Georgia.

6. 'The Conspirator' (2010)

Despite its lack of cinematic appeal, The Legend of Bagger Vance does strive to incorporate golf into a larger narrative. Despite Robert Redford's earnest efforts and commendable performances from Will Smith, Matt Damon, and Charlize Theron, the film unfortunately failed to attract audiences and has faded from memory in recent times.

A middling historical drama

Image via Lionsgate

In 2012, Daniel Day-Lewis won an Oscar for his portrayal of Abraham Lincoln in the movie "Lincoln." Two years prior to that, Robert Redford directed a film that focuses on the aftermath of Lincoln's assassination. The film centers around Mary Surratt, who was tried in court for being a co-conspirator in his killing, despite maintaining her innocence.

Although a legal drama with a high-profile trial seems intriguing, "The Conspirator" falls short of being outstanding. While it is well-made overall, Robin Wright delivers a solid performance as Surratt. However, it does not rank among Redford's best works as a filmmaker, although it is not considered one of his worst efforts either.

5. 'The Milagro Beanfield War' (1988)

Unusual and underrated Oscar winner

Image via Universal Pictures

The Milagro Beanfield War may be one of Robert Redford's lesser-known directorial works, partly due to its rather conspicuous title. However, it should not be underestimated, as it presents a compelling narrative centered around an engaging conflict between a community of Latino farmers and indifferent property developers aiming to construct a golf resort.

Like many of Redford's films,

4. 'The Horse Whisperer' (1998)

is expertly filmed and features a memorable score. The film's music, composed by Dave Grusin, even received an Oscar. It ambitiously combines elements of comedy, drama, and a touch of fantasy, creating an interesting and captivating cinematic experience. Fans of Redford's notable directorial works will find

4. 'The Horse Whisperer' (1998)

well worth watching.

Uneven but enchanting bestseller adaptation

Image via Buena Vista Pictures Distribution

Before their roles in one of the MCU's finest films, Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Robert Redford and Scarlett Johansson shared the screen in The Horse Whisperer. Directed by Redford himself, the movie primarily revolves around Johansson's character, who takes center stage as she strives to recover from a traumatic accident that has affected her and her horse.

Redford portrays the titular horse whisperer, stepping in to assist Johansson's character. Alongside this journey, a romantic subplot develops between Redford's character and Johansson's mother, played by Kristin Scott Thomas. The film's attempt to balance the recovery narrative with the added element of romance may seem challenging, especially considering its lengthy runtime of nearly three hours. Nevertheless, The Horse Whisperer manages to present some commendable elements, including stellar performances, captivating visuals, memorable music, and breathtaking outdoor settings.

3. 'A River Runs Through It' (1992)

Appealing, stodgy period family saga

Image via Colombia Pictures

From the early 1990s onwards, Brad Pitt's career gained momentum, highlighted by his standout performance in A River Runs Through It. In this film, Pitt portrays the character Paul Maclean, appearing prominently throughout, although Craig Sheffer's portrayal of Norman Maclean may be considered the central role.

The

2. 'Quiz Show' (1994)

spans a significant number of years, primarily from the conclusion of World War I until the early days of The Great Depression. This film delves into the dynamics of a family, portraying a rather subdued drama. While it may not be the most thrilling or plot-driven movie available, it effectively delves into the lives of its characters and showcases compelling performances from the cast members. Ultimately, it stands as a commendable exploration of the bonds between brothers and how families navigate through challenging and turbulent times.

Flawlessly acted genre hybrid

Quiz Show might have achieved greater recognition if it had been released in a year other than 1994, which is renowned for its outstanding movies. Despite facing competition from more sensational films like Pulp Fiction, The Shawshank Redemption, and Forrest Gump, Quiz Show should not be overlooked. Its captivating storyline delves into the investigation of the rigged quiz show Twenty-One. While unfolding more as a drama than a thriller, the film remains engrossing and well-paced, thanks to Redford's skillful direction and the stellar performances from Ralph Fiennes, John Turturro, and Paul Scofield.

1. 'Ordinary People' (1980)

Groundbreaking, timeless drama masterwork

Surprisingly, Robert Redford's directorial debut, Ordinary People, turned out to be not only his most critically acclaimed film but also arguably his finest work overall. This poignant family drama delicately explores the aftermath of a devastating loss, revealing the profound impact it has on every member of the family, leaving behind a permanent void within their tightly-knit unit.

The family depicted in the film is remarkably ordinary, facing the same everyday hardships that people all over the world encounter. Redford's direction exudes sensitivity and an understated style, combined with exceptional performances, elevating the film to a tremendous Oscar triumph. It clinched the coveted Best Picture award, and Redford himself was honored with the Best Director accolade.

Editor's P/S

As a Gen Z fan, I have a unique perspective on Robert Redford's directorial contributions. While he is primarily known for his acting career, his work behind the camera is equally impressive. Redford's films often explore important social and political issues, and he has a knack for eliciting powerful performances from his actors.

One of my favorite Redford-directed films is Quiz Show (1994), which tells the true story of the 1950s television quiz show scandals. The film is a fascinating look at the dark side of human nature, and it features excellent performances from John Turturro, Rob Morrow, and Ralph Fiennes.

Another standout is Ordinary People (1980), which follows a family struggling to cope with the death of their eldest son. The film is a powerful and moving drama, and it earned Redford an Academy Award for Best Director.

Overall, I am impressed by Robert Redford's directorial work. His films are thought-provoking, well-crafted, and often feature strong performances from his actors. I look forward to seeing what he does next.