Peter Weber's Mix-Up: Confusing Ekin-Su with Ex Kelley Flanagan on 'The Traitors' Set

Peter Weber Mistook Ekin-Su for Kelley Flanagan on the Traitors

Peter Weber, Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu, and Kelley Flanagan. Getty Images; WireImage; Getty Images

Peter Weber got a big scare when he mistakenly thought his ex Kelley Flanagan was on the second season of The Traitors.

During a podcast called "Trading Secrets", the 32-year-old former Bachelor shared that on the first day of filming, he believed Kelley was part of the show. Weber remembered, "I thought Kelley was there the first day. First day we were driving to the castle and we were all in these landrovers and there was four [of us] in each car. You only met three people at first before everyone shows up to the castle."

While driving around to capture some tracking shots, I found myself in the front right seat of the car. At the same time, Ekin-Su was in the front right seat of her car, and we ended up passing each other.

My heart skipped a beat when I thought I saw my ex-girlfriend. I was taken aback, thinking, "They brought Kelley onto the show." I felt a rush of panic as I hadn't seen her since we parted ways. However, when we got out of the car, I realized it was actually Ekin-Su. I let out a sigh of relief and could finally breathe again.

Flanagan, who was 32 years old, appeared on The Bachelor during her season. Although the pilot eliminated her before hometown dates, they later started a romantic relationship after the show ended. After being together for a few months, the couple publicly announced their breakup on New Year's Eve in December 2020. They then reconciled in early 2021 but unfortunately ended their relationship again in February.

Peter Weber Mistook Ekin-Su for Kelley Flanagan on the Traitors 2

Kelley Flanagan and Peter Weber had a great Valentine's Day together. However, things took a turn for the worse. Flanagan shared on the "Chicks in the Office" podcast in May 2021 that their relationship ended badly. She expressed that she became upset with Weber, left New York, and went to stay with a friend. Despite his attempts to contact her, she ignored him. Eventually, she learned something that made her unhappy. They still had each other on Find My Friends, but Flanagan decided to cut ties with Weber by telling him to leave her life.

Peter Weber Mistook Ekin-Su for Kelley Flanagan on the Traitors 3

Peter Weber and Ekin-Su Cülcüloğlu Chris Haston/PEACOCK

Weber described his relationship with Flanagan as "amazing" during an August 2021 episode of the "Tea With Publyssity" podcast. Despite their breakup, he emphasized that his feelings towards her remain unchanged.

After a brief reconciliation, the couple ultimately decided to part ways for good in early 2023.

After breaking up, Flanagan started dating Ari Raptis, whom she introduced on Instagram in June 2023 by posting a photo of them smiling in formal attire. Interestingly, Weber is now rumored to be romantically involved with Ekin-Su, as seen in a cozy Instagram photo with other cast members on Thursday, February 29. However, the former Bachelor star dismissed the rumors during an interview, stating that they are simply "really good friends."

Weber further explained, "We have a great bond, we really connect well. We have a lot in common. It's truly one of the most wonderful friendships to have evolved from that experience, I can honestly say. She's currently in London filming Big Brother, and I'm cheering her on from here."

Editor's P/S:

Peter Weber's initial confusion on "The Traitors" highlights the lingering impact of past relationships. His panic upon mistaking Ekin-Su for his ex, Kelley Flanagan, demonstrates the emotional baggage he carries from their tumultuous romance. The incident serves as a reminder of the complexities of navigating post-breakup encounters and the challenges of moving on.

Weber's complicated history with Flanagan is further explored in the article. Despite their initial chemistry, their relationship was marked by breakups, reconciliations, and ultimately a bitter end. Flanagan's decision to cut ties with Weber via "Find My Friends" suggests a profound hurt that lingers. Weber, however, still holds positive feelings towards his former partner, expressing his admiration for the "amazing" connection they once shared. The article also reveals Weber's rumored romance with Ekin-Su, which he has denied, highlighting the fluidity of relationships in the public eye.