After the surprising conclusion of The Curious Case of Natalia Grace: Natalia Speaks, Cynthia and Antwon Mans, Natalia's current adoptive parents, have finally spoken out and provided an update on the situation.
In early 2024, the highly awaited sequel documentary series The Curious Case of Natalia Grace: Natalia Speaks aired, delving deep into the intricate details of the unbelievable case and allowing Natalia to tell her side of the story. This includes revealing what happened with her previous adoptive parents, Michael and Kristine Barnett.
Natalia appeared prepared to embrace her new life with her new family, Cynthia and Antwon Mans, but a radical turn of events emerged during the last scene. Six months following their formal adoption of Natalia, the couple contacted the producers, alleging that Natalia had betrayed them and declared they were finished with her.
There remain many unresolved questions surrounding the situation, along with the assurance that "Natalia's story will live on," stirring debate about what transpired between Natalia and the Mans. But Cynthia has now provided some insight into the situation.
Natalia Grace’s adoptive parents break silence after documentary shock
Speaking to The US Sun, Cynthia Mans broke their silence, saying she and Antwon are sorting through their issues with Natalia and that they are “absolutely perfect.”
“We are absolutely perfect,” she told the outlet, before confirming, “No, she doesn’t live with us but we are fine.” Cynthia went on to say Natalia is currently “living with friends,” but that she and Antwon are in regular contact with their adopted daughter, sharing a screenshot of them FaceTiming together.
IDCynthia and Antwon Mans are now Natalia’s legal adoptive parents
“We’re going through a tough time, but with God's help, we'll get through it. I am praying,” she added. The publication mentioned that Cynthia couldn't provide more details about the rift because they are currently “filming for a future installment,” hinting that ID may release another follow-up docu-series soon.
Last week, Natalia reassured her supporters on her Instagram account: “I’m okay and doing well, and thank you all for your support and prayers. I wish I could share more about the show, but I've signed an agreement to keep things confidential for now. I'll let you know when I can, but just know that I’m okay. Love you all.”
Why did Natalia Grace fall out with the Mans?
The reasons behind Natalia Grace's falling out with Cynthia and Antwon Mans are currently unclear. However, more information will be revealed in the planned follow-up docu-series. In the meantime, speculation among followers of the case abounds, with some speculating that the falling out may be related to money.
Before the final episode of Natalia Speaks aired, a YouTube viewer left a comment speculating about the possible motivation behind a phone call in the show. The comment suggested that Natalia's new family had learned that she was going to be paid after filming and believed that the money should be shared with them, indicating that Natalia may not have disclosed this information to them.
The Mans family adopted Natalia when she was 8-9 years old and has been lovingly caring for her ever since. Natalia has generously signed over all of her disability checks to the family. It is likely that the Mans family is not only receiving Natalia's disability money of $1,800 or more per month, but they are also eligible for and likely receiving additional monies as her caretakers.
This dispute seems to be centered around money. The Mans family initially took Natalia in for altruistic reasons, as she was just a child when they adopted her and faced a high risk of danger due to her disability. It is likely that Natalia was offered a significant amount of money for the mini series. As an adult in need of caregivers, it is disheartening that the Mans family may feel entitled to a portion of her earnings. They have accused her of being selfish and a backstabber, which is distressing.
"Imagine living your whole life with those who support you expecting a portion of your earnings. This series doesn't focus on The Mans, but on Natalia's story. Manipulating her with guilt and informing the producers that The Mans are finished with her is a deeply tragic tale of greed. It's also quite shameful, especially considering that Antwon is a respected member of the clergy. However, this is all speculative for now. We will keep you updated with any new information on the next installment of the Natalia Grace series."
You can watch The Curious Case of Natalia Grace and Natalia Speaks on Discovery Plus and Max. Sign up to stream them here. Explore more of our coverage below. Keep in mind that we may earn a small affiliate commission if you click on a product link on this page.
Editor's P/S
As a Gen Z netizen, I find the situation involving Natalia Grace and her adoptive parents, Cynthia and Antwon Mans, to be quite concerning. It is disheartening to hear about the falling out between Natalia and her new family, especially after the Mans initially took her in with seemingly good intentions. The allegations of betrayal and financial disputes raise questions about the true motives behind their adoption and care for Natalia. It is important to prioritize the well-being and best interests of Natalia, ensuring that she receives the love, support, and care she deserves.
Furthermore, the suggestion that Natalia's disability checks and potential earnings from the documentary series may be a source of conflict is deeply troubling. It is essential that Natalia has control over her own finances and is able to make decisions about her life and future. Exploiting her vulnerability and financial situation is not only unfair but also unethical. I hope that Natalia receives the support she needs and that any disputes can be resolved in a way that prioritizes her well-being and happiness.