Marvel Studios' Disney Plus series Secret Invasion faced criticism for a bold creative decision. Nonetheless, the director sought to justify their controversial choice.
Secret Invasion centers around Nick Fury, portrayed by Samuel L. Jackson, who joins forces with MCU figures Everett Ross, Maria Hill, and the amiable Skrull Talos. Each character displayed on screen could potentially belong to the malevolent faction of Skrulls attempting to conquer Earth. The show's tagline, "Who do you trust?", extends its uncertainty not only to the characters depicted but also to the series' creators themselves.
The opening credits of Secret Invasion were created by Method Studios using AI technology, giving it a distinct resemblance to other viral AI-generated videos. The director and executive producer, Ali Selim, explained that this choice was influenced by one of the show's central themes, the concept of shape-shifting and the Skrull world identity. The decision, however, received significant backlash on Twitter, with users expressing disappointment in Marvel Studios and labeling the opening sequence of Secret Invasion as "gross." Despite Selim's artistic reasoning, critics on Twitter argued that there was no valid justification for such a decision.
The use of AI in generating art has sparked controversy due to its ability to draw inspiration from various source images. Critics argue that AI can infringe upon artists' intellectual property rights by reproducing their work or imitating their style. Moreover, the ongoing strike by the Writers Guild of America has brought up the issue of whether studios should be permitted to use AI to replace human jobs.
AI-generated art has gained significant popularity on the internet, ranging from memes to recreating The Last of Us series as a video game. Some proponents even claim that AI can be beneficial for independent artists who require assistance in completing their projects. However, considering the extensive backlash, it remains to be seen whether Disney will make any alterations to the Secret Invasion opening credits.
Secret Invasion episode 1 is streaming now on Disney Plus.
Source: Polygon