In Madden NFL 24, the safeties serve as the final barrier of defense. When the ball carriers manage to surpass the initial defensive lines, it falls upon the safeties to prevent the opposing team from scoring a touchdown. Therefore, safeties need to excel in tackling and possess exceptional speed.
The elite safeties go beyond their tackling abilities and possess the skill of ball-hawking. They are capable of intercepting or deflecting passes that even cornerbacks struggle to reach. Having a top-notch safety in Madden NFL 24 allows players to have more opportunities on offense since the defense will consistently generate turnovers.
10 Micah Hyde - FS - 89 OVR
The fact that the Bills have two safeties in the top ten demonstrates the team's emphasis on this position. Regrettably, Hyde's season was cut short due to a severe injury in the second game of the previous season, preventing him from accumulating significant statistics. Nevertheless, this former Pro Bowler has consistently performed well with two different teams, consistently showcasing why he is among the elite. Two years ago, he matched his personal record for interceptions, hinting that he could surpass it if both safeties remain injury-free throughout the year.
9 Jordan Poyer - SS - 90 OVR
Jordan Poyer's remarkable performance in 2022 earned him his first Pro Bowl selection, although his rating was slightly lower than expected. While being in the 90s is still impressive, Poyer's outstanding play throughout the season warranted a higher position on this list. Despite overcoming injury setbacks, he managed to amass impressive statistics.
Poyer now has an opportunity to demonstrate that the rating adjusters underestimated his abilities. With a season free of injuries, Poyer has the potential to elevate his game even further. The Buffalo team is determined to attain a championship victory, and Poyer's defensive prowess plays a vital role in their plans.
8 Harrison Smith - SS - 90 OVR
Harrison Smith, who has spent his entire eleven-year career in Minnesota, boasts an impressive record of six Pro Bowl selections. Notably, he continues to perform at an exceptional level, matching his career-best interceptions tally in the previous season. Over the span of the past decade, the Vikings have consistently posed a formidable challenge in the passing game, largely due to Smith's exceptional skills.
Adhering to comprehensive analytics, Smith's excellence transcends mere statistical analysis, solidifying his position as one of the league's top players across all positions. Even the most highly regarded wide receivers in the game often find themselves unprepared for the forceful impact of Smith's tackles.
7 Budda Baker - SS - 90 OVR
Budda Baker has the potential to be remembered as one of the greatest defenders in the history of the Cardinals. Despite playing on a struggling Arizona team, Baker has managed to earn Pro Bowl honors five times in a row. While the spotlight often shines on the team's frontmen, it is Baker who plays a pivotal role in anchoring the defense.
Baker's expertise in deflecting passes is undeniable. However, his reputation for delivering bone-jarring hits is equally noteworthy. If the team can establish some stability, Baker is ready to lead them on a successful playoff run.
6 Tyrann Mathieu - FS - 91 OVR
The Saints experienced significant disorganization throughout the previous season. However, the acquisition of Tyrann Mathieu played a crucial role in salvaging the season from complete failure. Mathieu displayed exceptional performance, achieving a career-high in combined tackles while striving to bring stability to New Orleans.
With the unveiling of Madden NFL 24, gamers have the opportunity to witness new athletes making their mark in the sport. Nevertheless, this does not diminish the achievements of past athletes. Mathieu, a three-time Pro Bowler and Super Bowl champion, continues to be recognized for his remarkable contributions.
5 Jessie Bates III - FS - 91 OVR
Madden contemplating sitting out a season, the Bengals may regret not securing Jessie Bates III. Widely regarded as one of the league's most underrated players, the Falcons managed to acquire Bates from Cincinnati, aiming to maximize his skills.
Having achieved a personal best in interceptions last year, Bates is poised for even greater improvement. Should he continue to progress, Atlanta will have made a shrewd investment in a player highly regarded by analysts. Despite being one of the rare standout performers on his team's defense, Bates has yet to receive a Pro Bowl nod.
4 Kevin Byard - FS - 92 OVR
Starting in 2017, Kevin Byard has been a constant presence in every game for the Titans. Maintaining good health requires effort and self-control. In addition to his reliability, Byard has earned the title of a two-time Pro Bowler and achieved a career-best number of tackles in the previous season, demonstrating his continuous improvement.
In the past year, the Titans experienced a disappointing downfall, starting with a promising 7-3 record but ultimately finishing at 7-10. However, it is important to note that Byard cannot be held accountable for this collapse as he consistently held his own in the team's defense. With a focus on preventing costly injuries, Tennessee is committed to providing Byard with the support he rightfully deserves.
3 Justin Simmons - FS - 92 OVR
Surprisingly, Justin Simmons, despite missing the first five games of the season, managed to tie for the league's highest number of interceptions with six. While the Broncos had little to be happy about last year, with their offense proving to be a significant weakness, Simmons showcased immense strength when he was on the field, bolstering the team's defense.
With the Broncos now turning to Sean Payton as their new coach, they hope to rectify their offensive struggles. If they are successful in doing so, combined with Simmons' ongoing growth, Denver has the potential to become one of the top teams in the league.
2 Minkah Fitzpatrick - FS - 93 OVR
With his exceptional interception record last year, Minkah Fitzpatrick has solidified his position as the game's top free safety. Throughout his journey to his third Pro Bowl, Fitzpatrick consistently disrupted opposing offenses, leaving them puzzled on how to safely execute their passing plays in his presence.
While it is uncommon for a safety to be considered for the coveted cover star role, Fitzpatrick presents a compelling argument. In a time that prioritizes offense, he brings back a level of confidence reminiscent of the legendary Steel Curtain, resonating with traditional football enthusiasts.
1 Derwin James Jr. - SS - 95 OVR
Despite missing a few games last year, Derwin James Jr. established himself as one of the premier safeties in the industry, earning his second consecutive Pro Bowl selection and third overall appearance. With fans eagerly anticipating the ratings of the highest-ranked players, James was undoubtedly expected to be among them.
In addition to possessing the qualities that make most safeties exceptional, James possesses the capability to dislodge the ball during tackles, adding to his repertoire of skills in generating turnovers as a formidable safety. The San Diego team is fortunate to have him as the stalwart of the Chargers' defense.
Madden NFL 24 will be released on August 18th, 2023 for PC, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, and Xbox Series X/S.