Former 'American Idol' Champion Abi Carter Advocates for Lady Gaga to Take Over Katy Perry's Spot as Judge (Exclusive)

Abi Carter, the winner of American Idol season 22, is still excited about her recent victory. However, she is already thinking about who she would like to see take Katy Perry's place as a judge next season.

In an exclusive interview with We after her win on Sunday, May 19, the 21-year-old singer shared her thoughts. Abi believes that Lady Gaga would be perfect for the role. While she acknowledges Katy Perry's contribution to the show and the legacy she has left behind, Abi feels that Lady Gaga would bring a fresh and cool energy to the judging panel.

Carter won the finale, defeating Will Moseley and Jack Blocker. He also mentioned that Meghan Trainor would be a great full-time judge. Trainor, who is 30 years old, was a mentor this season.

American Idol Winner Abi Carter Wants Lady Gaga or Meghan Trainor to Take Katy Perrys Judging Spot

Carter shared her admiration for Trainor, describing her as the sweetest person. She recalled a moment backstage when Trainor was mentoring and performing despite having the flu. Carter initially did not recognize Trainor due to her blonde and blue hair and mask. Trainor greeted her as a queen, leading Carter to realize her identity a few seconds later.

American Idol Winner Abi Carter Wants Lady Gaga or Meghan Trainor to Take Katy Perrys Judging Spot

Katy Perry Disney/Eric McCandless

Carter mentioned that there are many qualified people who could be good judges. However, she firmly stated that Katy Perry is irreplaceable.

Sunday's episode was a special moment for Carter as it marked her successful run on the series. It was also a bittersweet farewell for Perry, who has been a judge alongside Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie for seven seasons. Her departure was emotional for everyone involved.

"Every time Katy cries, I cry. I am a contagious crier for sure,” Carter shared with Us. The night featured the contestants performing a medley of songs in honor of Perry. “Honestly, I feel so honored to be part of Katy’s last season. Winning the show still hasn’t sunk in for me. It’s just incredible to win Katy’s final season. What can you even say to that?”

Carter expressed her admiration for the “Roar” singer, describing her as a “wonderful” mentor throughout the season. “All three judges have been amazing. They encouraged me to break out of my comfort zone and strive for greatness,” she reminisced. “Seeing their emotional reactions last night was truly heartwarming.”

Perry documented her final episode on social media by sharing a video of herself throwing pizza into the audience during the show. She expressed her sentiment by writing, “A pizza my heart will always be on the #idol stage.”

Reported by Mandie DeCamp

Editor's P/S:

Abi Carter's suggestion of Lady Gaga as a replacement for Katy Perry on American Idol is an intriguing one. Gaga's experience as a performer and her unique style would undoubtedly bring a fresh perspective to the judging panel. Furthermore, her passion for music and her ability to connect with contestants could make her a valuable asset to the show.

Carter's admiration for Meghan Trainor is also noteworthy. Trainor's experience as a mentor this season has demonstrated her ability to provide constructive criticism and support to contestants. Her warm and encouraging demeanor would make her a natural fit as a full-time judge. However, it remains to be seen whether Trainor would be interested in such a commitment, given her busy schedule and other projects.