Do we really need another musical biopic? The public reaction to the trailer for the Amy Winehouse movie suggests it's already receiving a lot of criticism.
Musical biopics are often uncertain in terms of their success. In recent years, Elvis and Priscilla Presley, Elton John, Freddie Mercury, and soon Bob Marley have all been brought to the big screen.
The upcoming Amy Winehouse biopic, officially titled Back to Black, has already stirred up controversy with the release of its first official trailer. Fans have been quick to share their negative reactions, labeling the sneak preview as "hated."
Amy Winehouse movie already “hated” by fans after first trailer
Fans have reacted to the first trailer for Back to Black on social media, with many claiming to “hate” it.
One X/Twitter fan expressed, "RIP Amy Winehouse, you would have despised this," in reaction to the trailer's debut. The synopsis for Back to Black, directed by Sam Taylor-Johnson and starring Marisa Abela as Amy, chronicles the singer's turbulent relationship with Blake Fielder-Civil, which fueled the creation of her groundbreaking album.
"I'm getting really nervous about this. The trailer seems to just be a bunch of reenactments of her most popular performances and moments that are already on YouTube..." another fan added.
"It's disappointing to see someone with such a genuine and down-to-earth vibe being reduced to a cliché biopic trailer. I hope this isn't a reflection of the final product, but I'm not feeling optimistic," a third fan commented.
Considering how much of Winehouse's life was consumed by evading the problems and public scrutiny that ultimately led to her declining health, some fans are worried that the film should not have been produced at all. "Let Amy Winehouse finally rest in peace. We all know how her story concluded, so why make a movie about it? It's just another form of the media exploitation she endured in life. In my opinion, her father should be ashamed of himself," read one comment.
A second user expressed, "I'm not convinced that this was necessary. We each have our own way of remembering her; there's no need for this depiction of her when the documentary was sufficient." A third user shared, "I'm not entirely sold on this!! There are so many aspects of Amy's life that weren't in the media, and I hope they portrayed her accurately. They could have also found someone who resembled her more."
A fourth user concluded, "This movie is destined to fail. Instead of casting someone who doesn't resemble Amy at all, they could have made a legendary biopic with Gaga or Lauren Jauregui. It's disheartening to see her legacy exploited without the creation of a great movie."
Editor's P/S
As a dedicated fan of Amy Winehouse, I can't help but feel a sense of disappointment and frustration with the first trailer of the upcoming biopic, "Back to Black." The negative reactions from fellow fans are understandable and reflect the concerns we have about the necessity and authenticity of this movie.
It's disheartening to see that the trailer seems to focus on reenacting Amy's most popular performances and moments that are already widely available on YouTube. This approach feels unoriginal and fails to capture the essence of what made Amy such a unique and beloved artist. Moreover, the casting choice of Marisa Abela as Amy has raised eyebrows, with many fans questioning the resemblance and ability to portray the depth and complexity of Amy's personality.