Brian Cox Criticizes Joaquin Phoenix's Eccentric Performance in 'Napoleon': Harsh Review

Brian Cox Says Joaquin Phoenix Was Truly Terrible in Napoleon

Brian Cox and Joaquin Phoenix Alan Chapman/Dave Benett/Getty Images; Borja B. Hojas/WireImage

Brian Cox, 77, didn't mince words when discussing the 2023 film Napoleon at London's HistFest on April 14. According to The Standard, he described it as "terrible" and criticized Joaquin Phoenix's performance as "appalling." Cox felt that Phoenix's portrayal was lacking and noted that he didn't believe director Ridley Scott provided much support.

Cox expressed his belief that he could have portrayed the titular role better than Phoenix, 49, stating, "I would have played it a lot better." He humorously commented on Phoenix's name, saying, "I think he’s well-named. Joaquin, wackeen, wacky. It’s sort of a wacky performance."

This is not the first instance of the Succession alum criticizing another actor. In his 2021 memoir, Putting the Rabbit in the Hat, Cox referred to Johnny Depp as "so overblown" and "overrated," specifically mentioning Depp's performance in the 1990 film Edward Scissorhands.

In the book, Cox commented on Johnny Depp's performance in a Tim Burton movie. He mentioned that Depp didn't have to do much with his hands and pale, scarred-face make-up. Cox also noted that Depp has done even less in his subsequent performances.

In another part of the book, Cox shared his thoughts on Steven Seagal, whom he acted alongside in The Glimmer Man. Cox described Seagal as being just as ridiculous in real life as he appears on screen.

"He mentioned that the man exudes a calm aura, almost like he is on a different level than the rest of us. Although he is indeed on a different level, it may not necessarily be a higher one."

Brian Cox Says Joaquin Phoenix Was Truly Terrible in Napoleon

Joaquin Phoenix in “Napoleon” AppleTV

Cox has also criticized his Succession costar Jeremy Strong’s use of method acting.

During a February interview with Town & Country, he expressed his frustration, saying, "It’s really annoying. I could go on and on about it." Despite his straightforward comments about Strong’s creative process, Cox made sure to highlight that Strong, 45, is incredibly talented as an actor.

"He’s a very skilled actor, and the rest of the cast is fine with it. However, understanding a character and their actions is just one aspect of the skill set," he explained. "He sticks to his routine because he believes he would lose his touch if he changed it. But he shouldn’t worry! Strong is truly gifted. … When you have a talent, embrace it. Go back to your trailer and relax with some marijuana, you know?"

Strong, who portrayed Cox’s son in Succession, responded to the remarks in a GQ profile from February 2023.

He mentioned, “It’s okay for everyone to have their own opinions. I believe that Brian Cox, for instance, has the privilege to express himself however he wants.”

Cox reiterated his criticism of method acting at HistFest on Sunday. He expressed his opinion by saying, "That’s all bollocks. It’s a kind of nonsense." According to him, actors are transmitters who transmit energy.

Editor's P/S:

Brian Cox's candid remarks about the 2023 film "Napoleon" have sparked a stir in the entertainment industry. His scathing criticism of Joaquin Phoenix's performance, describing it as "terrible" and "appalling," has raised eyebrows and reignited the debate surrounding method acting. Cox's belief that he could have portrayed the titular role better highlights his confidence in his own abilities and raises questions about the casting choices for the film. His comments have also drawn attention to the varying perspectives on acting techniques, with Cox advocating for a more naturalistic approach that focuses on transmitting energy rather than relying solely on external characterizations.

Furthermore, Cox's previous criticisms of Johnny Depp, Steven Seagal, and Jeremy Strong demonstrate his willingness to voice his opinions on the performances of other actors. While his criticisms may be seen as harsh or subjective, they reflect his strong beliefs about the craft of acting and his belief that actors should strive for excellence. Cox's candor and willingness to engage in open dialogue contribute to the ongoing discussions and debates within the entertainment industry, challenging conventional approaches and fostering a critical examination of acting methods.