Apple's Loyalty and Government Concerns
The ongoing legal battle between Apple and the Justice Department is centered around the tech giant's dominance in the smartphone market. The lawsuit aims to challenge Apple's stronghold on the iPhone, a key factor in the company's immense success and global popularity.
Don't miss out on more stories like this - sign up for free to receive the Nightcap newsletter from CNN Business in your inbox.
The Justice Department is taking legal action against Apple in an effort to loosen the firm's control over the iPhone, the product that has contributed to its massive success and profitability.
The case is already bringing attention to the dual nature of Apple: the beloved tech brand that customers admire, and the powerful entity that developers resent.
The Federal authorities claim that Apple's monopoly restricts competition, limits consumer options, and leads to higher prices for consumers.
Apple’s response to the allegations is, more or less, a) no we don’t, and b) good luck proving customer harm when everybody loves us.
People walk past the Apple store in the Americana at Brand shopping center on the day after Christmas on December 26, 2023 in Glendale, California. U.S. retail sales rose 3.1 percent year over year this holiday season, based on in-store and online purchases, according to Mastercard SpendingPulse.
On December 26, 2023, in Glendale, California, people were seen walking by the Apple store at the Americana at Brand shopping center. According to Mastercard SpendingPulse, U.S. retail sales saw a 3.1 percent increase compared to the previous year during this holiday season, including both in-store and online purchases.
Image Source: Mario Tama/Getty Images
Related article
Apple sued in a landmark iPhone monopoly lawsuit
And that's when things start to get really interesting in this big battle between two giants.
People are big fans of Apple products. We enjoy using their phones, watches, laptops, and AirPods that keep us company and entertained. Personally, I'm currently typing this article on an Apple keyboard connected to a MacBook linked to iCloud. I would not be happy if I had to switch to a PC.
Apple acknowledged this in a statement to the media on Thursday. They mentioned their commitment to innovation, designing products that are user-friendly, prioritize privacy and security, and provide a magical experience for their users.
Magical!
The company added: “This lawsuit threatens who we are and the principles that set Apple products apart in fiercely competitive markets.”
Steve Jobs and Jony Ive, the renowned product designer of Apple's biggest hits, were brought together by fate. Their collaboration changed the world forever.
Their creations combined sleek design with top-notch software. Though not budget-friendly, Apple products were known for their user-friendliness and stunning aesthetics. Alongside Silicon Valley's top marketing team, Apple rose to become a tech giant with a billion loyal followers.
The darker side of Apple
But on the business side, Apple is not so beloved.
The company is known for stifling competition and imposing high fees on developers. Many smaller tech companies both despise Apple and fear its legal team.
According to Adam Wolfson, an antitrust lawyer at Quinn Emanuel, Apple has a habit of observing innovations by others for the phone, replicating them, and then preventing those others from competing. This practice is so common that there is even a term in the industry for when Apple adopts a third party's technology, known as "Sherlocking." This term pays homage to one of Apple's search products that made its non-Apple competitor, Watson, obsolete.
"They have a very aggressive approach," said Wolfson, who has experience with Apple disputes. "Apple is known for being extremely litigious and will fight until the end."
Apple iPhone 15 phones are displayed for sale at The Grove Apple store on launch day in Los Angeles, California on September 22, 2023.
Apple iPhone 15 phones are displayed for sale at The Grove Apple store on launch day in Los Angeles, California on September 22, 2023.
Patrick T. Fallon/AFP/Getty Images
Related article
Green bubbles, Apple Pay and other reasons why America says Apple is breaking the law
The Department of Justice (DOJ) lawsuit claims that Apple has unlawfully dominated smartphone markets by preventing new and innovative apps and services.
If you own an iPhone and have ever exchanged texts with someone using an Android device, you are likely familiar with the green-bubble problem and how frustrating it can be. The DOJ argues that Apple could improve this experience, but chooses not to in order to maintain the perception that using Android is socially undesirable. This behavior fosters a sense of loyalty among Apple users, creating a form of tech tribalism.
The lawsuit claims that the green bubble problem is just one example of Apple using its dominant position in an unfair way. If the Justice Department wins the case, Apple may be required to relax some of the restrictions it has imposed on its "walled garden" strategy, which is designed to provide users with a smooth experience and protect them from viruses.
Investors are worried about the lawsuit targeting the most profitable aspect of Apple's business, according to Gene Muster, managing partner at Deepwater Asset Management. However, Muster remains optimistic and doesn't think the lawsuit will significantly impact the company. He believes that consumers will continue to be drawn to Apple products.
Customer satisfaction is a complex issue for the DOJ. Many people are happy with their iPhones. But could more competition lead to even greater satisfaction? The DOJ faces a challenge in proving this. Ultimately, according to Wolfson, the law aims to ensure that consumers receive the very best, not just what Apple believes we want.
Editor's P/S:
The Justice Department's lawsuit against Apple highlights the complex duality of the tech giant. While Apple is beloved by many for its innovative products and user
