Highlights
Some fans were divided on Resident Evil 5's more action-oriented direction, but a potential remake could rework moments to please a wider audience.
A fresh approach to Sheva's introduction as a secondary protagonist could enhance her character development and emotional intricacies.
To align the infamous boulder punch moment in the game with the series' overall tone, it may require either a modification or a deeper exploration in a remake.
Capcom may be considering remaking Resident Evil 5, the next installment in the iconic horror franchise. Following the success of the Resident Evil 4 remake, it is likely that this game will receive a modern upgrade.
Resident Evil 5 marked a slight departure from the series' previous games, which resulted in mixed reactions from fans. While some appreciated the more action-focused direction, others believed it lost the elements that made the series renowned. The reception of this game, as well as its sequel Resident Evil 6, influenced the new approach taken with Resident Evil 7. Despite personal opinions, there are certainly opportunities to improve upon certain moments in a potential remake, ensuring that Resident Evil 5 pleases an even larger audience.
Sheva's Introduction to Resident Evil
Sheva's inclusion in Resident Evil 5 reflects the gaming trends of the 2000s, where female characters were often objectified, prioritizing their physical attributes over their personalities. Despite this, Sheva stands out as a compelling secondary protagonist, especially as a new addition to the franchise alongside its well-established legacy character.
However, critics argue that Sheva could have been developed more fully, as she appears somewhat one-dimensional. A modern approach to the game would benefit from providing players with a stronger emotional connection to Sheva, and it is hoped that she will make future appearances in the Resident Evil series beyond this particular installment.
The Notorious Redfield Boulder Punch
Mentioning Resident Evil 5 often prompts discussion about the boulder punch, a wildly odd and out-of-place event in a franchise that, until Resident Evil 4, featured protagonists who were vulnerable humans barely capable of facing the horrifying threats ahead. This game elevates a character who previously struggled to deal with a few mutant dogs outside the Spencer Mansion, providing little explanation for his newfound herculean strength. The boulder punch stands out as one of the most memorable moments in the Resident Evil series, although not necessarily for the right reasons. Consequently, the remake could benefit from either altering this moment in some way or embracing it further, especially considering Heisenberg's reference to it in Resident Evil Village.
A Different Approach To Jill Valentine
Even the most dedicated supporters of Resident Evil 5 can acknowledge that the treatment of Jill Valentine in this game is unnecessary. Jill, a beloved and iconic video game heroine, is essentially disregarded in favor of a cheap plot twist.
Similar to the Chris Redfield moment, the revelation surrounding Jill Valentine in this game is such a drastic departure from her character in the first game and subsequent appearances between RE1 and RE5, that it almost feels like an entirely different character. It may be beneficial for a potential remake of Resident Evil 5 to remove this moment altogether or provide more screen time for Jill after her rehabilitation. Either option would also create more opportunities for future appearances of Jill Valentine in Resident Evil 9 or beyond.
A Resident Evil 5 remake is rumored to be in development.