This article contains spoilers for season 4 of You. The upcoming season 5 will see the return of one of Joe's previous adversaries. The series follows Joe Goldberg, played by Penn Badgley, as he stalks different women in a new location each season, ultimately leading him to commit multiple murders. The fourth season concluded with Joe abandoning his fake identity and returning to New York City with his new partner, Kate Galvin-Lockwood, portrayed by Charlotte Ritchie. As part of Netflix's Tudum fan event, a video message from Penn Badgley was shared, giving a glimpse into the highly anticipated season 5 of You.
In the video, Badgley hints at the unresolved matters from Joe's history, but remains secretive about the potential return of certain characters for the show's concluding season. Nevertheless, the video offers glimpses of several individuals who have managed to survive Joe's destructive spree in previous seasons.
What Characters Will Be Returning in You Season 5?
As shown in the accompanying video, despite Joe's killing spree, there are still several loose ends left alive. Now that he has once again emerged as Joe Goldberg and his reported death has been proven false, it is inevitable that people from his past life will become aware of his presence. The video hints at the possibility of certain characters making a return, such as the wrongly accused therapist Dr. Nicky (John Stamos), the influential suburban couple Sherry (Shalita Grant) and Cary Conrad (Travis Van Winkle), as well as Joe's former young companions Paco (Luca Padovan) and Ellie (Jenna Ortega).
It is possible that some of these characters could make a return, but due to their busy schedules, particularly Ortega's involvement in other projects like Netflix's Wednesday and the Scream franchise after her appearance in You season 2, it may be difficult for them to appear for more than one episode. Furthermore, considering Marienne's perspective as a character, it is unlikely that she would want to attract Joe's attention now that he believes she is dead.
Based on Badgley's hint, it appears that the new antagonist for Joe in this season will likely be a recurring character from season 4, such as his student Nadia or Lady Phoebe. It is worth mentioning that not all potential suspects from the You cast were shown in the video, adding to the mystery. One example is Theo Engler, a former lover of Joe's wife Love Quinn, who could potentially arrive seeking revenge for her murder.
Source: Netflix