Why Carlton Banks from Bel-Air: The Evolution of a Controversial Character

Summary

Bel-Air takes a darker and more dramatic approach than The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, exploring themes of racial tension and the wealth gap among Black Americans.

In Bel-Air, Carlton's character is depicted as considerably harsher compared to his portrayal in the original series. He perceives Will as posing a threat to his social standing and reputation. Nonetheless, as Bel-Air season 2 progresses, Carlton and Will form a stronger, more fraternal connection, reminiscent of their relationship in The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air.

When Peacock premiered its reimagining of the beloved Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, one of the most noticeable changes was the portrayal of Carlton in the Bel-Air series. Bel-Air, a dramatic retelling of the original '90s sitcom, follows a similar storyline wherein both shows revolve around a young Black teenager named Will Smith (played by Will Smith in Fresh Prince and Jabari Banks in Bel-Air) who relocates from West Philadelphia to the affluent neighborhood of Bel-Air in Los Angeles, California, to live with his wealthy extended family. However, the similarities end there.

While The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air fearlessly tackled serious matters, such as when Will approached Uncle Phil (James Avery) to understand why his father "didn't want him," it always maintained its priority as a lighthearted and entertaining sitcom filled with amusing jokes and comedic moments. On the other hand, Bel-Air takes a much darker and more dramatic approach, delving deep into themes of racial tension and the stark divide between economically disadvantaged and affluent Black Americans. Although the characters in Bel-Air differ from their Fresh Prince counterparts in various ways, the most striking difference lies in the portrayal of Carlton.

Carlton Is A Villain In Bel-Air Season 1

In The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air, Carlton Banks (Alfonso Ribeiro) develops a close bond with Will despite their initial differences, making him a likable character. While his arrogance and preppiness can be irritating, his lovable nature and humor make him a fan-favorite. However, in Bel-Air, Carlton Banks (Olly Sholotan) is portrayed as a much meaner character. He displays the same arrogance, preppiness, and insecurity, but lacks the charm and humor of Ribeiro's portrayal. The reason for Carlton's animosity towards Will is his belief that Will poses a threat to his status and reputation.

Throughout the show, Carlton actively tries to make Will's life miserable. In the first episode, he even pushes his cousin into the pool. It is later revealed that Carlton develops a Xanax addiction, using the drug to cope with his insecurities. This drastic change in Carlton's character from the original Fresh Prince led fans to dislike him, a reaction that both the creators and Sholotan anticipated. Sholotan explains, "I believe that apathy hinders greatness... it would have been worse if people were just indifferent towards the new Carlton character." (via Insider)

Bel-Air Season 2 Sees Carlton & Will As Friends

Fortunately, in the second season of Bel-Air, Carlton undergoes a transformation, becoming a much more likable and redeemable character. This change is primarily due to his victory over his Xanax addiction and the subsequent reconciliation with Will. Their newfound closeness is evident in various instances, such as Carlton and Will driving together to school and exchanging humorous banter. The show emphasizes that their relationship has evolved into a brotherly bond similar to their counterparts in Fresh Prince. Although occasional tension may still arise between Will and Carlton in Bel-Air, particularly concerning Carlton's ongoing struggle with anxiety and insecurity, they have at least reached a better place in their relationship.