Why '2024's The Idea of You' is Revolutionizing Romance Movies

The Idea of You is already outshining the After franchise in one key aspect. Both projects draw inspiration from Harry Styles in some way. The After film series, starring Josephine Langford and Hero Fiennes Tiffin, is adapted from a book series by Anna Todd. Originally shared as fanfiction on Wattpad in 2013, the first book was published in 2014 and gained popularity among readers.

Similarly, The Idea of You is also based on a book written by Robinne Lee, known for her role in Fifty Shades Darker. Published in 2017, the book takes heavy inspiration from Harry Styles but tells a fictionalized story without the origins in fanfiction. The movie stars established actors like Anne Hathaway and Nicholas Galitzine in the lead roles, setting it apart from After.

The Idea Of You Is Much Closer to Reality Than After

Hayes Campbell is much more Harry Styles than Hardin Scott

Ultimately, The Idea of You, inspired by Harry Styles, offers a more true-to-life portrayal of the pop star. The original fanfiction that inspired After portrayed a college-aged bad boy version of Styles who was not a singer or part of a boy band. By renaming the character as Hardin Scott, any ties to the real-life singer and his place in pop culture were removed.

By showcasing a more authentic depiction of the Harry Styles character, the film is able to also present a less exaggerated version of the woman who becomes involved with him.

The Idea Of You Adds Depth to the Harry Styles Storyline

While the romance at the center of the 2024 Anne Hathaway movie is still a wish-fulfillment fantasy, it takes a new path by grounding its world and romantic lead Hayes Campbell in reality. This allows for a more realistic exploration of the Harry Styles character and a less embellished portrayal of the woman who falls for him. Hathaway's character Solène faces real issues alongside her fantasy love affair, such as media scrutiny and a 16-year age gap.

The romance is more complex and engaging due to a variety of factors

Anne Hathaway as Solene Staring Into the Eyes of Nicholas Galitzine as Hayes Campbell in The Idea of You - The romance is more complex and engaging due to a variety of factors - The Idea Of You Adds Depth to the Harry Styles Storyline

The Idea of You offers a unique take on romance with its Harry Styles-inspired storyline, focusing on the realistic portrayal of its two romantic leads. This sets it apart from the After movies, adding layers of depth to the story beyond typical romantic melodrama. The presence of an Oscar-winning star in a lead role adds a touch of prestige to the film. These elements make it worth exploring this narrative territory again, especially after the conclusion of the main After franchise in 2023.

Editor's P/S:

The article highlights the distinct characteristics of "The Idea of You" compared to the "After" franchise. While both draw inspiration from Harry Styles, "The Idea of You" presents a more authentic portrayal of the pop star, offering a more realistic portrayal of the relationship between the fictionalized Harry Styles and his love interest. By showcasing a grounded and relatable protagonist, the film adds depth to the storyline, exploring the complexities of fame, age gaps, and media scrutiny. This sets it apart from "After," which depicted a more exaggerated and fantasy-driven narrative.

Overall, "The Idea of You" promises a more nuanced and engaging exploration of the Harry Styles-inspired storyline, with its realistic portrayal of the characters and complex romantic dynamics. The presence of established actors like Anne Hathaway adds an element of prestige to the film, making it an intriguing prospect for audiences who are looking for a unique take on the genre.