Star Trek: Voyager's pilot episode was a direct response to the previous Star Trek series, specifically Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and Star Trek: The Next Generation. As the fourth installment in the Star Trek franchise, Voyager was developed with the influence of its predecessors, particularly Deep Space Nine and The Next Generation. When Voyager's pilot episode, "Caretaker," premiered, The Next Generation had only recently concluded, while Deep Space Nine was in its fourth season. Consequently, Voyager drew inspiration from the successes and failures of both shows to establish its unique foundation.
Right from the beginning, Star Trek: Voyager aimed to set itself apart from the rest of the franchise in evident ways. It became the first Star Trek series to feature a female lead, with Captain Kathryn Janeway (portrayed by Kate Mulgrew) leading the USS Voyager. Moreover, Voyager's setting in the Delta Quadrant, separated by 70,000 light years from Federation space, provided the opportunity for the exploration of new alien species and groundbreaking science fiction concepts untouched by any preceding Star Trek series. Although there were these notable distinctions, Voyager's pilot episode also intentionally incorporated specific elements as responses to The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine.
4 Voyager's "Action-Packed" Pilot Was Because Of DS9's Low Ratings
The pilot episode of Star Trek: Voyager is a thrilling action-adventure filled with intense events, daring fights, and unexpected twists. The opening sequence of "Caretaker" perfectly sets the tone for the episode, showcasing an intense battle between Chakotay's Maquis ship and a Cardassian crew in the treacherous Badlands, a violent and stormy region of space. From there, the pace of Voyager's pilot never lets up as both the Maquis and Starfleet crews are catapulted to the other side of the galaxy and find themselves in a constant struggle for survival.
This deliberate increase in drama was a direct response to the less successful pilot episode of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, which focused more on intellectual themes. Although Deep Space Nine has now become a beloved part of the Star Trek franchise, at the time, it faced challenges in living up to the immense popularity of Star Trek: The Next Generation. The creators of Voyager, many of whom had worked on Deep Space Nine, were determined to revitalize the franchise by incorporating more action and adventure to captivate audiences.
3 Voyager Returned To A Ship Instead Of DS9's Space Station
Star Trek: Deep Space Nine's departure from the traditional starship setting prompted Star Trek: Voyager to return to its roots. While DS9 opted for a Cardassian space station as its main location, Voyager saw the return of a starship as its primary setting. Although DS9's alternative setting was not directly criticized, the lower ratings of the show led Voyager to revert to the established model of the franchise. It made sense for Voyager to stick to the familiar starship setting, considering both shows were airing simultaneously. In an effort to capture the essence of Star Trek: The Next Generation's success, returning to a starship was the logical choice for Voyager to effectively execute its central plot.
2 Voyager's Initial Character Development Is Better Than TNG's
Despite Star Trek: The Next Generation's eventual success and adoration, it initially struggled to captivate viewers, especially in its pilot episode "Encounter at Farpoint." This can be attributed, in part, to the somewhat stiff portrayal of the characters and their interactions at the start of the series. Captain Jean-Luc Picard (Patrick Stewart) and Commander Data (Brent Spiner) had to undergo a gradual development process before becoming the beloved characters they eventually became.
In contrast, Star Trek: Voyager introduces a cast of characters in its pilot who, although not fully fleshed out, possess a greater sense of depth compared to TNG's cast. The viewer gains a clearer understanding of each character's background, and the pilot presents intriguing hints of the interpersonal relationships that will develop throughout the series. For example, the friendship between Tom Paris (Robert Duncan McNeill) and Harry Kim (Garrett Wang) or the bond shared by Captain Janeway and Tuvok (Tim Russ). The "Caretaker" pilot succeeds in providing a solid character backstory, which adds a sense of grounding to the show.
1 Voyager Had A Clear Goal - Unlike TNG's Mission
Star Trek: Voyager differentiated itself from Star Trek: The Next Generation (TNG) in several ways. Firstly, it introduced a clear mission for the crew, which was to find a way back home while exploring new worlds and encountering alien species in the Delta Quadrant. This focused objective provided a driving force for the show, even when individual episodes deviated from the main plot.
In contrast, TNG followed the general exploration mission established in the original Star Trek series (TOS). While this initially served to connect the show to its predecessor and provide familiarity for viewers, relying on the same concept repeatedly throughout the franchise would have become monotonous. Star Trek: Deep Space Nine eventually developed its distinctive mission with the Dominion War, but it took some time to establish this direction. In contrast, Star Trek: Voyager began with a well-conceived mission from the pilot episode and maintained it throughout the series, effectively setting it apart from the other two series.