Summary
The addition of James T. Kirk in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds offers a chance to reintroduce significant female characters from his past, such as his mother Winona and his former romantic partner Dr. Carol Marcus.
With little known about Winona Kirk, the characters of James and Lt. Sam Kirk's mother, Strange New Worlds has an opportunity to develop them from scratch.
Considering the timeframe of Carol Marcus' involvement with James, it is plausible for her to appear in Strange New Worlds, allowing fans to witness the beginnings of their relationship.
After being introduced on Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, James T. Kirk (played by Paul Wesley) now has the chance to have two significant women from his life revealed on the show. These women are his mother, Winona, and his future love interest, Dr. Carol Marcus. In the movie Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan, Carol Marcus (portrayed by Bibi Besch) was introduced as Kirk's estranged lover and the mother of his son, David (played by Merritt Butrick). Kirk's mother, on the other hand, has only been seen in J.J. Abrams' Star Trek (2009), with Jennifer Morrison playing the role.
Carrying on with J.J. Abrams's Star Trek Into Darkness, Carol Marcus (played by Alice Eve) made an appearance in the alternate Kelvin Timeline. Although she and Captain James T. Kirk (portrayed by Chris Pine) engaged in some flirtation throughout the film, they never pursued a relationship, and Carol Marcus was absent from Star Trek Beyond. Since Strange New Worlds takes place approximately seven years before Star Trek: The Original Series, it has the chance to reintroduce Carol Marcus in a more compelling manner. Winona Kirk, James and Lt. Sam Kirk's (portrayed by Dan Jeannotte) mother, is a relatively unknown character, offering Strange New Worlds the opportunity to develop her character freely.
Will Carol Marcus Appear In Strange New Worlds?
Dr. Carol Marcus, a prominent scientist in the United Federation of Planets, was introduced in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan. Despite knowing that Captain Kirk prioritized his Starfleet career over romantic relationships and was always on the move, Carol made the decision to raise their son David on her own, keeping Kirk's influence at bay. Carol was highly intelligent and spearheaded Project Genesis, an ambitious venture aimed at rapidly transforming uninhabitable planets. However, the project ultimately failed and was abandoned when Khan Noonien Singh stole the Genesis Device, turning it into a devastating weapon.
Although the details of James and Carol's relationship are scarce, it is believed that they became involved sometime between the late 2250s and early 2260s. As Strange New Worlds is set during this period, it is plausible for Carol Marcus to make an appearance. Taking into account that David is in his twenties during Star Trek II, it is likely that he has already been born or that Carol is pregnant with him within the timeframe of Strange New Worlds. Since Wrath of Khan only depicted the aftermath of their relationship, exploring how James and Carol first met and fell in love would be intriguing. Notably, Strange New Worlds has already introduced Kirk's initial encounters with iconic characters such as Nyota Uhura and Spock, making Carol Marcus a logical addition to that roster.
Kirk’s Mother Winona Should Appear In Strange New Worlds
Little is known about Winona Kirk beyond her family ties. She was married to Lt. Commander George Kirk, portrayed by Chris Hemsworth in J.J. Abrams' Star Trek 2009, and together they raised two sons - George Samuel Kirk and James Tiberius Kirk. During James' childhood, Winona and her sons frequently relocated as they followed George Sr. on various assignments. While Star Trek: Strange New Worlds has shed light on the character of Sam Kirk, Kirk's parents have yet to be introduced.
It is surprising that James Kirk, a prominent Star Trek figure, has not had his parents featured in the Prime timeline. Spock's parents, on the other hand, made their debut in 1967 on Star Trek: The Original Series, with Spock's mother Amanda portrayed by Mia Kirshner appearing in Strange New Worlds. It would only be fair for Kirk's mother to receive similar attention, as fans undoubtedly yearn to delve deeper into the background of the woman who brought James T. Kirk into the world. Star Trek: Strange New Worlds has excelled at reimagining established characters, and it is only fitting that Kirk's mother be given the same treatment.
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds streams Thursdays on Paramount+.