Unveiling the Untold: Director's Candid Account of Ben Affleck's Infamous Bomb Leaves Audiences in Awe
A critical analysis of the impact of Gigli on the esteemed director Martin Brest's career, revealing the disastrous aftermath of the notorious film that led to its scathing criticism and the lasting repercussions faced by the filmmaker
Gigli director Martin Brest recently discussed his notorious career setback and the impact of the film's failure. Released in 2003, this romantic crime comedy features Ben Affleck as an inept, low-level mobster and Jennifer Lopez as a fierce, alluring enforcer. They are given the task of abducting the mentally disabled brother of a federal prosecutor. Gigli faced harsh criticism from reviewers, became one of the biggest financial flops in history, and is widely regarded as one of the worst films ever made.
In a recent interview with Variety, Brest reflects on his infamous box office failure, Gigli, two decades after its release. The film remains a sensitive subject for the director, who still struggles to utter its title and refers to it only as "the G movie." Brest also shares his frustrations about the extensive involvement of the studio in the film, resulting in a final product that he found unrecognizable. However, he acknowledges his own responsibility in the debacle, admitting that Gigli was "a chaotic disaster that rightfully faced harsh criticism." Read his complete remarks below.
Having worked on numerous movies, I am intimately familiar with each one. However, when it comes to a particular film, I can't even visualize it because of the significant changes it underwent. I simply refer to it as 'the G movie' and prefer not to dwell on it.
The initial version of the movie was vastly different from what it eventually became. It's quite possible that other films in Hollywood history have undergone similar transformations, but the changes in this case were exceptionally drastic. As we were reaching the completion of the film, the composer presented a piece of music and eagerly awaited my reaction. Sadly, I couldn't comprehend why that scene was included anymore, as its original purpose had been altered. Everything about the movie, from its themes to its plot, had taken a completely different direction. However, I must also take some responsibility for this outcome. Strangely enough, I have such a vague recollection of the final version that was released, because I didn't have the same level of involvement as I did with my other movies. Consequently, it became a chaotic mess that rightfully received criticism.
The Effect Gigli Had On Martin Brest's Career Explained
The extensive disagreements between the studio and myself reached a point where post-production was halted for eight months as we engaged in a fierce battle. Ultimately, I found myself faced with two options: either resign or be complicit in the mutilation of the film. Regrettably, I chose not to resign, thus shouldering the responsibility for an abominable corpse of a movie. Once crucial scenes were removed, the film lost its essence, resembling a joke without its punchline. No amount of contortion could create the illusion that what remained was intentionally crafted. The extensive reshoots and re-editing only further inverted the characters, scenes, story, and tone, resulting in a futile attempt to salvage the growing catastrophe and shape it into a coherent film. This marked the first time in my career that I became a true collaborator, not in the positive, creative sense, but rather as someone who compromised their true convictions and cooperated with occupying forces. The self-castigations resulting from this compromise far surpass any public criticisms.
Gigli remains the final film directed by Martin Brest, widely considered to be the downfall of his career and his subsequent exile from Hollywood. Prior to Gigli, Brest was highly regarded for helming a variety of acclaimed movies, such as Beverly Hills Cop, Midnight Run, Scent of a Woman, and Meet Joe Black. His work on Scent of a Woman even earned him an Academy Award nomination, with the film receiving a total of four Oscar nominations, including Best Picture, and securing a win for Al Pacino's remarkable performance.
Brest's career came to a halt after the failure of Gigli, which is even more surprising considering his previous successes. Many renowned directors have also experienced critical or commercial failures, but they were given another chance to prove themselves and often went on to create some of their most successful films. It remains unclear why Brest has not been given the same opportunity in Hollywood, particularly since many of the issues with Gigli were beyond his control. If he is willing, it is high time for Brest to return to directing.
