Unveiling the Similarities and Differences: One Piece Vice-Captains and Their Captains

The character dynamics in One Piece, particularly between the captains and vice-captains of each crew, are incredibly interesting. These leaders not only maintain order but also tend to be the strongest fighters, often seen at the forefront of battles in the series.

While there are numerous examples of captain and vice-captain dynamics throughout One Piece, what is particularly intriguing is the varying similarities and differences between each crew. Whether it's the Straw Hats, the Whitebeard Pirates, or the Donquixote Family, each captain and vice-captain duo has their own unique elements. This list, presented in no particular order, offers a captivating analysis of these dynamics.

Disclaimer: This article contains spoilers for One Piece.

5 One Piece vice-captains who are just like their captains

1) Crocodile and Mr. 1/Daz Bones

One Piece has an underrated duo with Crocodile and Mr. 1 (Image via Toei Animation).

Crocodile, a seasoned pirate in the One Piece universe, values loyalty and trust, rare qualities in this world. This is why his connection with Mr. 1 is highly infamous. Despite not holding an official position as vice-captain in Baroque Works, Mr. 1's devotion to Crocodile is evident. He even rejoined him after their escape from Impel Down, showcasing his unwavering loyalty.

Both Crocodile and Mr. 1 possess similar personalities - stoic and deadly fighters with a pessimistic view of life. They are individuals of few words, making their understanding of each other effortless. Although the series has yet to delve deeper into Crocodile's character, which many fans eagerly anticipate, their dynamic remains captivating.

2) Whitebeard and Marco

Very similar duo in One Piece (Image via Toei Animation).

The Whitebeard Pirates exemplified the concept of a crew being like a close-knit family to many individuals. The relationship between Marco and Edward Newgate can be likened to that of a father and son. Serving as Whitebeard's right-hand man, Marco was deeply connected to his captain's ideals. It is truly unfortunate that he had to witness the tragic demise of his former leader during the events of Marineford.

While Whitebeard may possess a tougher exterior, both individuals possess a calm demeanor and prioritize their crew above all else. They share a common desire to assist others. It can be argued that Marco absorbed the most valuable teachings from Newgate, evident in his actions and character.

3) Jinbe and Fisher Tiger

Another underrated One Piece duo (Image via Toei Animation).

Jinbe's Fisher Tiger flashback in One Piece history stands out as one of the best, showcasing the intriguing dynamic between Luffy's friend and the legendary captain of the Sun Pirates. This immersive dive delves into the lore of the Fishmen, shedding light on Jinbe's character and emphasizing the significance of his eventual joining of the Straw Hats. Both Jinbe and Fisher Tiger, being quiet and reserved individuals, have faced personal struggles with humans but strive to bridge the gap and promote harmony between the two races. Additionally, their formidable strength as Fishmen further adds to their compelling presence in the series.

4) Shanks and Benn Beckman

A duo people would like to see more of in One Piece (Image via Toei Animation).

The Red Hair Pirates are relatively obscure in the series, igniting curiosity among fans who are eager to learn more about them. However, it is noteworthy that Benn Beckman and Shanks share several notable similarities. Not only are they the senior-most members of the Red Hair Pirates, occupying the highest positions within the hierarchy, but they also possess a calm, reserved, and stoic demeanor. It should be acknowledged that this characterization may evolve as further insights into Shanks and Benn's personalities are revealed.

5) Rayleigh and Roger

The two individuals who achieved dominance over the seas emerged as the most influential pirate duo in the series' narrative. They share qualities of optimism, strength, and an insatiable drive for success, commencing their journey from humble beginnings and permanently altering the pirate realm.

While it can be argued that Rayleigh possesses a slightly more serious demeanor compared to Roger, both men exhibit a fondness for risk-taking and a zest for life. This characteristic is exemplified by Rayleigh's present-day actions within the series, displaying no hesitation in traversing from one island to another through swimming and engaging in battles against any obstacle in his path, mirroring Roger's personality during his lifetime.

5 One Piece vice-captains who couldn't be more different from their captains

1) Luffy and Zoro

The primary protagonist of One Piece is undeniably Luffy, and although it has never been officially confirmed, Zoro has often played the role of the second-in-command, particularly prior to the time skip. Zoro has consistently exhibited unwavering loyalty to Luffy's cause and has even demonstrated his willingness to sacrifice his life for his captain's dream during the intense clash with Bartholomew Kuma in Thriller Bark.

However,

2) Law and Bepo

, it cannot be denied that Zoro and Luffy are individuals with starkly contrasting personalities, an aspect that has been consistently highlighted throughout the series. Luffy exudes extroversion and happiness, whereas Zoro remains stoic and reserved, only revealing glimpses of his true character during combat. This stark contrast between them adds depth to their dynamic, as they intricately complement one another.

Toei Animation presents an amusing duo of captain and vice-captain.

Few examples exhibit this category as effectively as the chemistry shared between Trafalgar Law and Bepo. While it's well-known that Law's crew lacks efficiency in their actions throughout the series, Bepo remains the sole member, aside from Trafalgar, who garners some notoriety. Moreover, Bepo stands in stark contrast to his captain.

Law is austere, solemn, and detached, whereas Bepo exudes exuberance, sociability, and occasional vulnerability. Bepo's humorous and witty nature effortlessly infuses levity and comedy into Law's persona, a delightful addition that is consistently embraced.

3) Kidd and Killer

Eiichiro Oda could have delved much deeper into the partnership between Kidd and Killer, a duo in One Piece (Image via Toei Animation). It is undeniable that Oda has masterfully created countless memorable characters in the series. However, this abundance of compelling individuals often results in other characters, like Kidd and Killer, being unjustly overlooked and sidelined for the majority of the story.

4) Jinbe and Arlong

However, although Kidd and Killer had the opportunity to receive more attention in the series, their interactions could emulate Luffy and Zoro's to a greater extent. Kidd is boisterous and outgoing, while Killer brings a sense of tranquility to the team, thereby enhancing their partnership's equilibrium.

After the demise of Fish Tiger, Jinbe assumed the role of captain for the Sun Pirates, while Arlong became his second-in-command. Consequently, their conflicting personalities often resulted in frequent clashes. This classification is justified by the fact that they represent one of the most contrasting duos on this list (with the ultimate contrast being reserved for the last duo).

Jinbe exhibits traits of calmness, reservation, and a desire to establish positive relationships with humans. In contrast, Arlong tends to be judgmental, violent, and inclined towards evil actions. These conflicting dispositions often led to confrontations between them during their time with the Sun Pirates. Eventually, their disagreements escalated to the point where they engaged in physical altercations. Jinbe's superior fighting abilities became evident, resulting in Arlong forming his own crew and relocating to the East Blue.

5) Doflamingo and Rosinante

Toei Animation presents the most contrasting captain and vice-captain duo in One Piece.

Undoubtedly, Doflamingo and Rosinante stand out as the diametrically opposite leaders in the history of One Piece. Despite sharing a familial bond, these two characters couldn't be more different, and their contrasting nature is clearly reflected in their profound influence on Trafalgar Law.

Final thoughts

The contrasting portrayal of Rosinante and Doflamingo is evident in Eiichiro Oda's deliberate decision to depict them as direct opposites. While Rosinante disguised himself as an impolite individual, his true benevolence surfaced in crucial moments, in stark contrast to Doflamingo's relentless malice and notorious reputation.

Final thoughts

One of the remarkable strengths of One Piece lies in the dynamic relationships between its numerous captains and vice-captains, regardless of their similarities or differences. This distinct aspect of Oda's storytelling has undeniably contributed to the enduring appeal of his manga throughout the years.