Unveiling the Shocking Truth: The Real Serial Killer in this True Story Will Leave You Speechless!

An intriguing theory has emerged suggesting that Matt may not be the true killer in Peacock's Based on a True Story. In this comedy thriller, Nathan and Ava Bartlett plan to create a hit podcast where they interview the serial killer known as the West Side Ripper. Mysterious plumber Matt Pierce, who is the suspected killer, joins them in creating the podcast. However, as the story progresses, doubts arise regarding the true identity of the notorious killer. There is a compelling theory that proposes the West Side Ripper might not be Matt Pierce, but rather another unexpected character from Based on a True Story.

Inconsistencies in the unfolding story raise doubts about Matt's guilt. Firstly, there is no concrete evidence linking only Matt to the West Side Ripper killings. The blue shoe covers worn by the Ripper are easily accessible at various hardware or big box stores, which raises the possibility that someone else could have used them. Furthermore, the show does not present flashback scenes depicting Matt committing any crimes. Instead, it utilizes fantasy flashbacks and daydreams, making it unclear whether the sequences involving Matt's supposed crimes are real or merely his dark desires.

Theory: Nathan Is The Real Westside Ripper In Based On A True Story

Nathan Bartlett's portrayal in Based on a True Story bears an uncanny resemblance to the characteristics often found in real-life murderers. Hidden beneath his outwardly grumpy demeanor lies a deep-rooted animosity, particularly towards the club members and his wife's affluent acquaintances, notably Simon and Ruby. This intense aversion towards specific individuals raises doubts about the extent of his resentment and whether it could potentially serve as a motive for murder. Adding to the suspicion is the incomplete information regarding Nathan's whereabouts during the first season's string of murders, including those of Ruby and Dahlia.

Furthermore, Nathan's vehement opposition to collaborating with Matt on the podcast can also be viewed as suspicious, especially his adamant insistence on keeping Ava away from the investigation. While he claims it is for her safety, there may be an ulterior motive at play. This is particularly perplexing considering Nathan's apparent lack of concern for her safety in other situations, such as when she meets strangers alone during property viewings. To complicate matters further, every piece of evidence implicating Matt as the killer also seems to point directly at Nathan. His demeanor, motives, and absence of alibis intertwine to form a compelling case suggesting that Nathan could potentially be the true killer, providing a gripping twist for the yet unconfirmed Based on a True Story season 2.

Why Matt Could Be Lying About Being A Serial Killer

Nathan becomes a viable alternative candidate for the role of the serial killer, considering the uncertainty surrounding Matt's involvement in Ruby's death.

Why Nathan Being Based On A True Story's Real Killer Makes Sense

In "Based on a True Story," Nathan's character is motivated by an intense desire to prove himself following a career-ending injury in professional tennis. He is now on a quest to reconnect with his wife, overcome financial difficulties, and find a new direction in life. The podcast presents itself as an opportunity for Nathan to achieve all of these goals simultaneously. If Nathan is secretly the West Side Ripper, the podcast project becomes a tool for him to exert control and potentially gain the money and recognition he desperately craves. This suggests that Nathan may be the mastermind behind manipulating the attention-seeking Matt.

Furthermore, there is the possibility that Nathan is a copycat, mimicking the crimes he claims to be investigating. Subtle hints, such as his aversion to true crime podcasts and concerns about safety while working on the podcast with Matt, raise suspicions about his true motives and involvement in the disturbing events that unfold. As the story unfolds, the line between truth and deception becomes increasingly blurred, leaving troubling doubts about the authenticity of both Matt's and Nathan's claims. "Based on a True Story" immerses the audience in a realm of uncertainty, where the true identities of the characters and their roles in the chilling narrative remain enigmatic.