Unveiling the Jaw-Dropping Historical Blunder in Pirates of the Caribbean 3 That Will Leave You Speechless!
Pirates Of The Caribbean 3's Historical Inaccuracy: Expert Uncovers a Hanging Scene Error, Deviating from Reality
Summary
Iszi Lawrence, a pirate expert, examines the errors depicted in Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End, specifically addressing the inaccuracies in the movie's initial hanging scene. It is highlighted that pirates were not executed by hanging in the Caribbean during that time. Instead, they were transported to London for their execution.
The Pirate Council has some accurate aspects, but the idea of the Pirate Code as a Bible-like book is "utterly ridiculous".
The movie clearly places more importance on providing entertainment rather than being historically accurate by introducing creatures like the Kraken and fish-human hybrids. Ultimately, it is crucial for a fantastical franchise like Pirates of the Caribbean to follow its own universe's guidelines rather than adhering to real historical events.
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End is closely examined by a pirate expert who identifies various inaccuracies and anachronisms. This film, inspired by the renowned Disney World attraction, marks the beginning of the franchise created by Gore Verbinski in 2003. Since then, a total of five films have been released. In Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End (2007), Captain Jack Sparrow (played by Johnny Depp) and his crew confront Davy Jones (Bill Nighy).
Pirate expert Iszi Lawrence, in a recent video shared by History Hit, analyzes scenes from Pirates of the Caribbean: At World's End and identifies various inaccuracies. Although certain aspects of pirate culture, like the diplomacy exhibited during the pirate council, are depicted accurately, Lawrence criticizes the mass pirate hanging scene at the film's start and certain aspects of the Pirate Code. Refer to Lawrence's complete commentary below.
In the Caribbean, pirates were not hanged until later in the 18th century. Instead, they were transported back to Wapping, where they would face execution. After being tried in places like Port Royal, they would be taken to London as a deterrent for other pirates.
The positioning of the rope, with it being to the side of the neck, appears to be accurate. In the British fashion, the eyelet would have been just below the jaw. However, the noose depicted is distinctly American, which is inappropriate for this pre-American era.
"There weren't any mass hangings, to my knowledge, like this. Regular hangings used to take place in Wapping, attracting crowds as spectators. The intention behind these hangings was to discourage misconduct, but in reality, it served as mere entertainment for the people.
Similarly, pirate councils were held to facilitate agreements among pirate captains, exchange information, and even swap crew members."
Do Pirates Of The Caribbean 3's Inaccuracies Matter?
The portrayal of the pirate code as a sacred text is utterly foolish. Apologies to the filmmakers, but although it adds allure to the narrative, it deviates from the true nature of the pirate code. In reality, it was a straightforward agreement made when boarding a ship, signifying one's commitment to piracy.
Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World, released in the same year as the first Pirates of the Caribbean movie, strives to portray an authentic and realistic depiction of the life of a British Navy seaman in 1805. As the film doesn't take place in a fantastical or exaggerated world, any inaccuracies become more significant.
Pirates of the Caribbean, set approximately 70 years prior to Master and Commander, does not strive to provide a completely accurate portrayal of 18th century piracy. Instead, the movie aims to entertain audiences of all ages. The franchise offers a humorous tone, particularly through Jack Sparrow, and even incorporates mythical sea creatures like the Kraken. Davy Jones himself is depicted as part octopus, with a beard consisting of tentacles.
While it may be intriguing to examine the historical accuracy of Pirates of the Caribbean from an educational perspective, the success of the franchise suggests that mistakes do not deter most viewers. The films create a unique and highly fantastical version of reality, where entertainment value takes precedence over historical authenticity. By adhering to their own invented rules instead of reality's rules, Pirates of the Caribbean allows audiences to suspend their disbelief.
Source: History Hit/ YouTube
