Unveiling Captain Sisko's Epic Journey: 8 Fascinating Ways He Outshone Picard (Leading up to Confronting Q)

Summary

Sisko proves he's not like Picard by punching Q, solidifying the differences between Star Trek: DS9 and Star Trek: TNG.

Sisko values the help of the Ferengi, unlike Picard who had a negative view of them.

Sisko breaks rules for the greater good, while Picard follows the rules strictly.

Commander Benjamin Sisko, portrayed by Avery Brooks, had already established himself as distinct from Captain Jean-Luc Picard, played by Patrick Stewart, even before physically confronting Q, portrayed by John de Lancie, in the episode "Q-Less" of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine. In this episode, Q arrives at the titular space station in an attempt to win back Vash, Picard's former lover, portrayed by Jennifer Hetrick. Vash's reckless actions, organizing an auction of Gamma Quadrant artifacts, unintentionally jeopardize the safety of the station. Despite Q's refusal to intervene, Sisko and the crew of Deep Space Nine take matters into their own hands.

Sisko, uninterested in Q's manipulative tactics, engages in a confrontational encounter, delivering punches to Q's abdomen and face in a memorable scene. As Q struggles to process the events, Sisko firmly reiterates, "I'm NOT Picard," solidifying the stark contrast between Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and Star Trek: The Next Generation. In the preceding six episodes, Sisko had been meticulously demonstrating these differences to the audience. While the initial conflict between Sisko and Picard in DS9's premiere showcased their disparities, subsequent episodes further accentuated the vast divide between them.

8 Sisko Understands The Value Of The Ferengi

Picard's perceptions of the Ferengi were heavily influenced by his encounters with DaiMon Bok, a nemesis he had acquired. However, it is worth mentioning that the Ferengi were initially intended to be the primary adversaries in Star Trek: The Next Generation, a concept that did not ultimately materialize. In sharp contrast, when Sisko assumes command of Deep Space Nine, he quickly recognizes the importance of enlisting the aid of Quark to establish the station's commercial sector. Sisko even goes as far as to designate Quark as a prominent figure in the community and positions Quark's Bar at the core of the bustling Promenade—a role that one cannot easily imagine Picard entrusting to a Ferengi.

7 Picard Follows The Rules - Sisko Breaks Them

Sisko's actions in Star Trek: DS9 may appear questionable, but they consistently align with the best interests of Starfleet and the Federation. This becomes increasingly evident in later seasons of Deep Space Nine. However, right from the start, Sisko showcases his adaptability as a leader by imprisoning Nog (Aron Eisenberg) to compel Quark's cooperation. This incident exemplifies Sisko's willingness to navigate the unique cultural dynamics on DS9. As a not fully established Federation outpost nor a lawless frontier town, Sisko consistently demonstrated his willingness to explore comprehensive solutions that occasionally diverged from the Federation's strict guidelines and regulations.

6 Picard Liked Bajor But Bajor Worshiped Sisko

In the pilot episode of "Emissary" in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Sisko is briefed by Picard about his mission to prepare Bajor for Federation membership. While Picard strongly advocates for Bajor's entry into the Federation, Sisko holds a different opinion due to the political unrest and conflicting factions within the planet. Sisko's role as the Emissary to the Prophets gives him significant influence in Bajoran society, forcing him to balance his diplomatic mission for the Federation. While Picard unwaveringly supports the Federation, Sisko recognizes the broader implications and drawbacks of Bajor's integration into the Federation.

5 Sisko Is More Open With His Deep Space Nine Crew

Picard's story in Star Trek: The Next Generation revolved around his journey of embracing his crew as a true family, a sentiment that reached its pinnacle in the memorable poker scene in the series finale. On the other hand, Sisko quickly established an open and charismatic connection with his crew, primarily because he couldn't solely rely on his Starfleet credentials to establish his authority. Deep Space Nine, being a former Cardassian refinery, housed both Starfleet officers and Bajoran personnel, while also welcoming a constant influx of alien visitors. This environment demanded that Sisko develop a more personal approach, understanding different perspectives and working towards a shared objective. While Picard was always skilled at this during his diplomatic missions, he often struggled to form personal connections with his crew members and even potential romantic partners.

4 Picard's Beloved Prime Directive Didn't Always Fit Deep Space Nine

In "Captive Pursuit," Sisko assists Chief O'Brien in violating Starfleet's Prime Directive by making initial contact with the Tosk. During this encounter, Sisko learns that the Tosk are bred specifically for the purpose of being hunted by a group known as The Hunters. In a situation where Picard would typically face a moral dilemma before reluctantly permitting the Hunters to reclaim Tosk as their prize, O'Brien takes matters into his own hands and helps Tosk escape, intending to resuscitate the hunt. Unbeknownst to O'Brien, Sisko covertly aids in Tosk's getaway. While Sisko reprimands O'Brien as a formality, deep down he agrees with the Chief's actions. On the other hand, when Picard reprimands his crew, it is because he staunchly believes in adhering to Starfleet's regulations, rarely allowing himself a subtle smile afterward.

3 Sisko Was A Father First, A Starfleet Officer Second

Captain Jean-Luc Picard had always prioritized his career in Starfleet over starting a family. However, Commander Benjamin Sisko managed to successfully balance his role as a Starfleet officer with his responsibilities as a father. This contrast revealed that there was more to Picard's decision than initially perceived. In the second season of Star Trek: Picard, it is revealed that Jean-Luc's troubled childhood significantly impacted his apprehensions about embracing fatherhood. In the episode "Emissary," Picard struggled to comprehend Sisko's unwavering commitment to his son, Jake Sisko (Cirroc Lofton). Nonetheless, following the events of Picard season 3, it is likely that Picard now appreciates and comprehends Sisko's perspective much more deeply.

2 Picard's Number One Was Starfleet, Sisko Insisted His Wasn't

In "Emissary", Sisko informs Major Kira Nerys (Nana Visitor) that he specifically requested a Bajoran Number One. This allowed him to have a better understanding of Bajoran affairs and make well-informed decisions. It was crucial for Sisko to balance his roles as the Bajoran Emissary and Starfleet Commander, which made Kira's presence invaluable. Similar to Commander William T. Riker (Jonathan Frakes), Kira fearlessly stood up to Sisko and challenged him. However, Kira's challenges held more significance as they delved into Starfleet's intentions and offered a fresh perspective. This was precisely what Sisko required during his delicate diplomatic mission to prepare Bajor for Federation entry.

1 Sisko Hit Q, Picard NEVER Hit Q

In "Q-Less," Sisko is determined to expel the mischievous cosmic being from his station as quickly as possible. After attending a Starfleet conference on Q, Sisko likely believed that Picard had been too lenient towards the all-powerful entity and his games. While Picard and Q developed a complex friendship from the pilot of Star Trek: The Next Generation to season 2 of Star Trek: Picard, Sisko takes immediate action. He demands that Q return his missing crew and confronts the deity in a brief yet intense boxing match, sending a clear message that Q's antics are unwelcome in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine.