Unveiling a Stellar Twist: Star Trek's Epic Journey Improves Janeway's Controversial Solution
Star Trek: Lower Decks’ tackles the controversial 'Tuvix' episode, offering a fresh perspective on Janeway's divisive decision Explore the moral complexities and enduring appeal of Janeway's character in this thought-provoking article
Summary
Captain Freeman's decision to follow Janeway's controversial "Tuvix" solution highlights the ethical dilemma and difficult choices faced by captains in the Star Trek universe.
T'Lyn's endorsement of Janeway's solution and her readiness to resort to drastic measures to ensure the ship's survival highlights the significance of logic and the welfare of the majority in the process of making decisions.
Although Janeway's choice to terminate Tuvix received criticism, her unwavering commitment to safeguarding her crew's safety and well-being is what endears her to fans.
WARNING: Spoilers ahead for Star Trek: Lower Decks Season 4, Episode 1, "Twovixed". In this episode, the crew of the USS Cerritos is tasked with escorting the USS Voyager to an Earth exhibition. However, they encounter a situation similar to the controversial "Tuvix" incident from Star Trek: Voyager. In that episode, Tuvix was created when Neelix and Tuvok were accidentally merged, along with some alien orchids. In "Twovixed," a stray petal from these same orchids attaches itself to Lt. Commander Andy Billups during transport, resulting in the creation of T'Illups.
Captain Carol Freeman initially decides to follow Captain Janeway's previous decision regarding Tuvix. However, after reading the file on the incident, she realizes that Janeway chose to split Tuvix into his original forms to bring back her friends. T'Illups, having read the same report, fights for their life by merging other members of the Cerritos crew in a similar fashion. Ensign D'Vana Tendi and Provisional Ensign T'Lyn, who is her Vulcan best friend, take it upon themselves to find a solution.
Ultimately, they opt for a course of action similar to Janeway's controversial Tuvix solution, but with a unique twist that is in line with the comedic nature of Star Trek: Lower Decks.
How Star Trek: Lower Decks’ “Tuvix” Solution Compares To Voyager
Once T'Illups comes into existence, T'Lyn distances herself, aware that she may eventually have to eliminate it. Having recently joined the Cerritos, T'Lyn does not consider T'Ana or Billups as friends like Janeway and her crew regarded Tuvok and Neelix. T'Lyn's support of Janeway's solution implies that Janeway was correct all along. When T'Illups starts causing unwanted conflicts among the crew, T'Lyn takes action to save the spaceship. The act of beaming everyone away simultaneously results in the formation of a shapeless mass composed of Freeman, T'Ana, Billups, and other members of the Cerritos.
When confronted with what she calls "a mindless mass of flesh," Tendi suddenly feels morally obligated to rescue her friends. T'Lyn's "Tuvix" solution surpasses that of Janeway and Voyager's EMH Doctor (Robert Picardo) because it pushes the issue to its extreme, proving that eliminating T'Illups is the right course of action. With a logical breakdown, T'Lyn perceives T'Illups as a biological abnormality that has forcefully taken control of the crew and the ship. Together with Tendi, they endeavor to separate this mass based on personality traits. However, since no distinctive T'Illups trait is identified, it suggests that a "Tuvix" is merely the combination of its individual components rather than a new life-form.
Why Janeway Was Wrong To Kill “Tuvix”
Captain Freeman's determination to find a humane solution that benefits all parties leads to the escalating situation involving "Tuvix" in Star Trek: Lower Decks season 4. Unlike Janeway in Star Trek: Voyager, who was focused on restoring her two friends, Freeman recognized the unique qualities of Tuvix, who combined the best traits of Tuvok and Neelix. However, despite Tuvix's pleas to live, Janeway made up her mind to separate him using a radioactive isotope. Mariner's claim that Janeway "straight up murdered Tuvix" in the Lower Decks sequel holds some truth. The situation becomes so dire in the sequel that killing T'Illups becomes the only option, as the Tuvixed army poses a greater threat than Tuvix ever did. While Tuvix always maintained a peaceful demeanor and never posed a violent threat to the crew, Janeway's decision to end his existence still feels hasty, even after the darker side of the problem is revealed in Lower Decks.
Why Janeway Is Beloved Despite Killing “Tuvix”
Lt. Shaxs (Fred Tatasciore) was correct when he stated that "Janeway didn't mess around" in Star Trek: Voyager. Captain Freeman emphasizes in Star Trek: Lower Decks that Janeway was stranded in the Delta Quadrant without access to Starfleet medical or scientific facilities. This forced her to make difficult decisions for the well-being of her crew, including the controversial choice to kill Tuvix. Without Tuvok's guidance, it's possible that Janeway and the USS Voyager would not have safely navigated through the Delta Quadrant.
The decision to kill Tuvix went beyond the desire to regain her friend; it was about restoring vital members of her crew for the benefit of Voyager.
Fans of Star Trek understand that being in command entails making tough choices. Captain Sisko also made questionable decisions in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, but always with the greater good in mind. Captain Janeway similarly made tough calls to ensure the safety of her crew and the Delta Quadrant, even if it meant taking Tuvix's life. This unwavering dedication to bringing her crew home, despite the moral and ethical dilemmas along the way, is why Janeway is beloved. It is also the reason why there is a new exhibition of the USS Voyager on Earth in season 4 of Star Trek: Lower Decks.
Star Trek: Lower Decks streams Thursdays on Paramount+.
