Unusual Avian Discovery Challenges Evolutionary Norms
While toothed birds were prevalent in the era of dinosaurs, a recent find has reshaped scientists' perspectives on the evolution of birds.
Sign up for CNN’s Wonder Theory science newsletter to stay updated on fascinating discoveries, scientific advancements, and more. Explore the universe with us!
Scientists recently made a groundbreaking discovery with the help of a peculiar fossil. They found an unusual bird that coexisted with dinosaurs 120 million years ago. This finding is reshaping our understanding of avian evolution.
A new species, named Imparavis attenboroughi, has been discovered and named in honor of British naturalist Sir David Attenborough. The name means “Attenborough’s strange bird” in Latin.
All birds are descendants of dinosaurs, with some of the earliest birds resembling them. However, Imparavis belonged to a diverse bird group called enantiornithines and likely looked more similar to the birds we see today. This information comes from a recent study published in the journal Cretaceous Research.
Enantiornithines, also known as "opposite birds," had a unique shoulder joint that set them apart from modern birds.
Lead study author Alex Clark, a doctoral student at the University of Chicago and the Field Museum of Natural History, described Enantiornithines as very unusual creatures. Many of them had teeth and clawed digits, giving them a distinct appearance. If you were to travel back 120 million years to northeastern China, you might have mistaken an Enantiornithine for a typical bird like a robin or cardinal. However, upon closer inspection, you would notice their teeth-filled mouths and little fingers on their wings.
Imparavis was the first bird of its kind to be toothless among a landscape full of birds with teeth, as stated in the study.
According to Clark, toothlessness in this bird group was previously known to have occurred around 70 million years ago. However, with Imparavis, it was discovered to have happened nearly 48 million years earlier. Today, all birds do not have teeth. But in the Mesozoic era, birds with teeth were common. Therefore, a bird without teeth like Imparavis would have been considered unique and unusual.
A strange fossil was found by an amateur collector near northeastern China’s Toudaoyingzi village. It was then donated to the Shandong Pingyi Tianyu Natural Museum. When Jingmai O’Connor, the Field Museum’s associate curator of fossil reptiles, visited the museum’s collections a few years ago, the fossil immediately caught her attention.
"I was initially fascinated by the specimen not because of its lack of teeth, but because of its forelimbs," shared O'Connor, the study coauthor and Clark's adviser. "It had a large bicipital crest - a bony protrusion at the top of the upper arm bone where muscles attach. While I had observed similar crests in Late Cretaceous birds, finding it in an Early Cretaceous specimen like this one was unexpected. This led me to suspect that it could potentially be a new species."
Titanosaur
Titanosaur
Damien Boschetto
Related article
70 million-year-old giant dinosaur skeleton found connected from skull to tail
Clark, O’Connor, and their team started examining the fossil in early 2023. They were taken aback by the bird's absence of teeth and its unique forelimbs, which are also known as wing bones.
Imparavis had significant muscle attachment points on its wing bones. This indicates that it was capable of producing a great amount of power with its wings and had a forceful downward wing beat. Clark described it as resembling a massive aerial push-up.
"We could be seeing some really powerful wing movements. The bone structure is similar to modern birds such as puffins, murres, quails, and pheasants. These birds can flap their wings rapidly or launch vertically when they feel threatened," stated Clark.
Unlike modern birds that have fused forelimb digits, enantiornithines had the ability to move their "little fingers" independently on their wings.
The mysteries of avian evolution are still being unraveled. According to Clark, most of the 'hand' of early birds would have been encased in tissue to help form the wing. However, these birds also possessed little claws that could have served various purposes such as manipulating food, aiding in climbing, or potentially engaging in behaviors that have not yet been discovered.
Clark and his colleagues are unsure about the specific diet of Imparavis or the reason for its lack of teeth. However, based on the features of the bird's hind limbs, it is believed that it probably searched for food on the forest floor, possibly looking for fruits, seeds, or insects.
Unlike modern birds, the bird, similar to other enantiornithines, did not possess a gizzard, which is an organ that helps birds grind up their food for better digestion. According to Clark, this suggests that the reasons for toothlessness in other dinosaur groups may not be the same for enantiornithines like Imparavis.
As other birds lost their teeth over time, they would ingest stomach stones to create a gastric mill to help crush the food they ate. But Imparavis didn’t behave that way.
Until the scientists find more examples of Imparavis, the mystery of what the bird ate and how it digested food remains.
Cross section of stump
Cross section of stump
Neil Davies
Related article
Fossilized trees dating back 390 million years are world’s oldest
Imparavis, as noted by Clark, could often be observed hopping and walking on the ground similar to modern robins.
O'Connor pointed out that while most enantiornithines were mainly tree-dwelling, the distinct forelimb structure of Imparavis suggests that it may have come down to the ground to forage for food. This unique behavior could have led to a different diet compared to other enantiornithines, potentially explaining the loss of its teeth.
One of the key remaining questions among researchers about bird evolution is why the more diverse enantiornithines went extinct 66 million years ago along with the dinosaurs, while another group called ornithuromorphs survived and enabled modern birds to evolve.
According to Clark, some researchers have speculated that ornithuromorphs may have had a higher association with water or river systems, while others have proposed differences in metabolisms or nesting habits as possible reasons for their survival. More fossil specimens and statistical models are needed to further investigate these theories in the future. Stay tuned for updates!
Clark is currently studying new samples that highlight the interesting similarities and differences between ancient and modern birds. This helps us understand how these creatures can be both surprising and paradoxical.
Clark credits his interest in the natural sciences to watching Attenborough’s nature documentaries, hence the name of the new fossil.
The fossil is 240 million years old.
The fossil is 240 million years old.
National Museums Scotland
Related article
Scientists unveil 240 million-year-old ‘dragon’ fossil
Attenborough expressed his gratitude for having his name linked to such a remarkable and significant fossil. He mentioned that the discovery suggests that the history of birds is more intricate than previously thought.
The researchers highlighted that studying extinct animals not only provides insights into the past but also increases awareness for the future.
Studying enantiornithines like Imparavis attenboroughi can provide valuable insights into why they became extinct and why modern birds were able to survive. This knowledge is crucial in understanding the current sixth mass extinction that our planet is experiencing. According to O'Connor, paleontology is essential in helping us comprehend how organisms adapt to environmental changes and the impact of other species going extinct. The sixth mass extinction is considered the most significant crisis facing humanity, and the evidence provided by paleontology is vital in understanding these complex ecological dynamics.
Editor's P/S:
The discovery of Imparavis attenboroughi offers a fascinating glimpse into the intricate evolutionary history of birds. This unique bird, coexisting with dinosaurs 120 million years ago, challenges our understanding of avian evolution. Its toothless appearance, unusual wing bones, and distinct forelimb structure provide tantalizing clues to the diversity and adaptations of early birds.
The implications of this discovery extend beyond the realm of paleontology. By shedding light on the extinction of enantiornithines and the survival of modern birds, Imparavis prompts us to consider the factors that determine species survival and extinction. In an era marked by the sixth mass extinction, this knowledge becomes imperative for understanding the ecological dynamics shaping our planet's future. Imparavis attenboroughi serves as a testament to the power of scientific inquiry and the interconnectedness of life through time. their evolutionary outcomes. This knowledge is not only important for understanding the history of life on Earth but also has implications for our understanding of the current sixth mass extinction. By studying past extinctions, paleontologists can gain valuable insights into the potential consequences and challenges facing our planet today.
