Unraveling the Mysteries of Professor McGonagall in Fantastic Beasts - A Fascinating Insight!
Unraveling the Mystery: The Enigma of Professor McGonagall's Presence in Fantastic Beasts - A baffling time paradox or cleverly concealed backstory?
Result:
After the success of the Harry Potter movies, a sequel story called Fantastic Beasts was created. This new series explored the wizarding world before Harry's time and initially focused on Newt Scamander's quest to find his lost magical creatures. However, the storyline quickly shifted to center around Albus Dumbledore and his battle against Grindelwald. These changes didn't sit well with Harry Potter fans, as they included plot elements that contradicted the original events.
One particular inconsistency that stood out in the Fantastic Beasts movies was the appearance of Professor Minerva McGonagall. The head of Gryffindor appeared in two different scenes in Fantastic Beasts: Crime of Grindelwald and Fantastic Beasts: Secrets of Dumbledore. This plot hole was significant and raised questions among fans about how Professor McGonagall could be in the Fantastic Beasts movies before she was even born.
Who Is Professor McGonagall?
In addition to her role as the Gryffindor head, Professor Minerva McGonagall played a crucial role in Harry's development and his quest to defeat the Dark Lord. Although she was strict in her methods, Professor McGonagall offered consistent support to Harry and his friends throughout their years at Hogwarts.
One notable occasion where the professor stood up for Harry was in the movie "Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets," when he was falsely accused of attacking fellow students. Professor McGonagall defended Harry in this situation, showcasing her loyalty to him. Furthermore, she exhibited her caring nature for the first time during Harry's Triwizard tasks, demonstrating her unwavering support for him.
After Dumbledore's removal, the professor stepped up to assume the role of Headmistress at Hogwarts school. This decision was logical, considering her close relationship with Dumbledore and her exceptional qualifications to handle such a critical situation.
However, it was in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2 that the professor truly shined. Leading the students in the Battle of Hogwarts, she displayed remarkable dueling skills, successfully taking down numerous Death Eaters, and even confronting Severus Snape himself. Additionally, she cast a protective charm around the castle, preventing the Death Eaters from gaining entry. Although they eventually breached the charm, it is reasonable to assume that the battle's outcome would have been vastly different without Professor McGonagall's presence.
As a result of her actions during the Battle of Hogwarts and the defeat of the Dark Lord, Professor McGonagall was honored with the Order of Merlin and appointed as the Headmistress of Hogwarts.
Why Professor McGonagall's Appearance Doesn't Make Sense In Fantastic Beasts
Professor McGonagall young plothole in fantastic beasts
The events of Newt and his friends' story take place long before Professor McGonagall's birth, yet it is interesting to note that she made two appearances in the Fantastic Beasts movies. The first appearance occurs in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes Of Grindelwald during a flashback scene where Leta Lestrange recalls her time at Hogwarts. In this memory, she uses Oscausi, a dark charm that silences a student from Gryffindor who had been spreading gossip about her tragic past. This unfortunate incident serves as evidence that not all Gryffindor students are friendly. Following this, a scene shows a student calling for a young Professor McGonagall, played by Fiona Glascott, who then pursues Leta.
The second appearance of Professor McGonagall takes place in Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets Of Dumbledore. Dumbledore and Professor McGonagall are shown engaging in a conversation about his impending absence from Hogwarts for a period of time.
Newt and Leta Lestrange were classmates at Hogwarts, beginning their studies in 1908. However, the events depicted in the Fantastic Beasts movies take place between 1926 and 1945. This presents a contradiction with J.K. Rowling's previous writings, which established that Professor McGonagall, born in 1935, didn't begin teaching at Hogwarts until 1956 at the age of 21.
As a result, it is not possible for Professor McGonagall to appear in the Fantastic Beasts movies since she hadn't even been born during that time. Some fans have speculated that the character in the movies might be a relative of Minerva instead of the Gryffindor head herself. Nevertheless, there has been no official explanation for this inconsistency.
The failures of the Fantastic Beasts movie series extended beyond its numerous inconsistencies. The films faced numerous production problems and suffered from a poorly written story and underdeveloped ideas, among other issues. These factors, combined with others, ultimately led to the disappointment of the entire prequel series. As a result, Warner Bros. has reportedly chosen to shelve Fantastic Beasts, shifting their focus to a soft reboot of the Harry Potter franchise. Currently, a TV show is in development at Max.
