Summary
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2 delivered a strong and consistent run of episodes, blending horror, humor, and high-concept storytelling.
Despite a few episodes falling short of the main idea, the season as a whole proved to be exceptionally powerful, highlighting the remarkable abilities of Captain Pike and the USS Enterprise crew. The inclusion of a musical episode and the captivating Lower Decks crossover added a fresh vitality to the Star Trek franchise, while also honoring the devoted fanbase.
WARNING: This article contains SPOILERS for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2.
Ranking every episode in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2 from worst to best is a difficult task considering the strong run of stories. The show has truly lived up to its name by exploring new and uncharted territories, such as introducing musical elements and seamlessly blending live-action with animation in a crossover episode. Building on the successes of season 1, Strange New Worlds season 2 has delivered a captivating mix of horror, humor, and high-concept storytelling, resulting in one of the most impressive and consistent runs of Star Trek episodes in recent memory.
Determining the "worst" episodes from such a strong selection is challenging. Some episodes in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2 may not have fully lived up to the potential of the central concept. Others may have attempted to connect too closely to the wider Star Trek canon, risking the possibility of a great episode feeling like a prequel to something better. Regardless of the order in which episodes are ranked, it must be acknowledged that this has been an incredibly strong season for Captain Christopher Pike (Anson Mount) and the crew of the USS Enterprise. The anticipation for Strange New Worlds season 3 is now at an all-time high, making the wait even more unbearable.
10 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 4, "Among The Lotus Eaters"
If "Among the Lotus Eaters" is its weakest episode, then it's a testament to how strong Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' season 2 really was. The episode, which returned to Star Trek: TOS' Rigel 7 had the makings of a fascinating character study of how Pike is impacted by the responsibilities of command. Confronting Pike with his embittered and tyrannical former Yeoman, Zac Nguyen (David Hyunh) was the perfect way to delve into the consequences of Pike's decisions on the lives of those under his command. However, the mind wipe plot in "Among the Lotus Eaters" robbed the storyline of this compelling character conflict, shifting the focus instead to Pike's struggle to regain his identity.
9 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 1, "The Broken Circle"
"The mind wipe plot's interference in 'Among the Lotus Eaters' resulted in a missed opportunity to explore the fascinating dynamic between Pike and his embittered former Yeoman, Zac Nguyen (David Hyunh). The episode initially showcased the impact of Pike's command responsibilities on his character growth, but the storyline veered off track, with Pike's fight to reclaim his identity taking precedence over the captivating exploration of his decision-making consequences."
"The Broken Circle" revitalized the presence of the iconic Klingons in a remarkable manner, as La'an Noonien-Singh (Christina Chong) unraveled a treacherous plot to reignite the Klingon War in Star Trek: Discovery. This season premiere was filled with gripping action sequences and showcased Ethan Peck's portrayal of Spock at its finest. However, upon retrospect, "The Broken Circle" proves to be a rather utilitarian episode that struggles to assert its individuality. While it successfully paves the way for the exceptional Klingon War episode later in season 2 and alludes to Spock's crucial role in the Klingon peace negotiations depicted in Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, it lacks substantial substance beyond these plot points.
8 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 10, "Hegemony"
7 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 3, "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow"
It's challenging to fairly evaluate the season 2 cliffhanger ending of Strange New Worlds without witnessing its resolution. Assessing "Hegemony" solely on its own merits, it stands as a thrilling piece of Star Trek survival horror that cheerfully navigates around established canon. However, this presents a problem given the significant implications of Pike's Gorn predicament within the wider canon, contrasting with the personal nature of Spock and Chapel's romance. While a stringent adherence to Star Trek canon should never hinder a compelling narrative, there is an uneasy sense that "Hegemony" may have cornered itself in relation to the established events of the classic TOS episode "Arena".
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds' latest installment, "Tomorrow and Tomorrow and Tomorrow," showcases the remarkable talents of Christina Chong as the dynamic Lt. La'an Noonien-Singh, and Paul Wesley as the charismatic alternate reality Captain James T. Kirk. The undeniable chemistry and blossoming romance between La'an and Kirk take center stage in this episode, offering a refreshing twist as Khan Noonien-Singh (Ricardo Montalban) assumes a lesser role in Kirk's timeline, granting La'an the freedom to embrace her true self. Alongside the captivating narrative involving Romulan time agent, Sera (Adelaide Kane), one could easily envision this as a timeless Star Trek classic, if not for the fact that Sera's pursuit of Khan Noonien-Singh inadvertently assumes an excessive level of interest that fans may only truly harbor for the character's iconic portrayal in Star Trek II: The Wrath of Khan.
6 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 5, "Charades"
Star Trek: Strange New Worlds once again displayed its mastery of the Vulcan comedy of manners in "Charades," demonstrating the show's ambitious storytelling. In previous versions, Spock's journey to become more Human would have been enough to carry an entire Star Trek episode. However, in SNW, it serves as the foundation for a captivating narrative centered around Vulcan wedding traditions, their prejudice against Humans, and Spock's relationships with his mother Amanda Grayson (Mia Kirshner) and Nurse Christine Chapel (Jess Bush). This episode also highlights the exceptional comedic talents of the ensemble cast that comprises Strange New Worlds' Enterprise crew.
5 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 8, "Under the Cloak of War"
In "Under the Cloak of War," episode 8 of Strange New Worlds season 2, the story progressed beyond "The Broken Circle" and delved deeper into the conspiracy surrounding the Klingons in Star Trek 6. One notable aspect was the development of Dr. Joseph M'Benga (played by Babs Olusanmokun). The episode skillfully interwove two timelines, allowing audiences to explore the impact of war on M'Benga through his experiences in the Klingon War and his present-day encounter with Ambassador Dak'Rah, also known as the Butcher of J'Gal (portrayed by Robert Wisdom). While the episode may not have been as overtly groundbreaking as a musical extravaganza, "Under the Cloak of War" remarkably showcased how Strange New Worlds, despite its lighter tone, can rival more mature Star Trek series like DS9.
4 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 6, "Lost in Translation"
"Lost in Translation" is worthy of praise as it successfully unites Star Trek icons James T. Kirk, Nyota Uhura (Celia Rose Gooding), and Spock in a subtly brilliant manner. The brilliance of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds lies in its deliberate focus on crafting an exceptional story centered around Uhura, allowing the pieces to seamlessly converge for this monumental encounter. "Lost in Translation" plays a pivotal role in defining Uhura's position as the communications officer of the Enterprise, as well as her ability to unite the entire crew. This sentiment is powerfully felt in the scene where she effortlessly extends an invitation to Spock and Kirk for a drink, following her successful unraveling of the mystery surrounding Bannon's Nebula.
3 Strange New Worlds Season 2, Episode 3, "Ad Astra per Aspera"
"Ad Astra per Aspera" not only kept up with the long-standing tradition of Star Trek civil rights analogies across its extensive 57-year history, but it also exceeded expectations. The trial involving Number One (Rebecca Romijn) rivaled some of the greatest courtroom dramas in the Star Trek universe. By subjecting Number One, Starfleet, and the Federation to a trial, Strange New Worlds shed light on the prejudice embedded within Gene Roddenberry's utopian vision. Commander Una Chin-Riley's ability to see the potential of Starfleet despite their prejudice against her serves as an inspiring message of forgiveness and hope for both the characters and the viewers.
2 Strange New Worlds' Musical Episode, "Subspace Rhapsody"
Star Trek's first-ever musical, "Subspace Rhapsody," was well worth the 57-year wait for it to materialize. While musical episodes have become a cliché in contemporary television, Strange New Worlds breathed new life into the genre. It was a jubilant musical tribute to the Star Trek franchise, complete with Klingons dancing, while also delving into the character development of its main cast. Like any exceptional musical, the songs in Strange New Worlds' musical provided a glimpse into the inner struggles of the beloved Star Trek characters. Taking the daring step of giving a Vulcan like Spock an emotional break-up song like "I'm the X" was a risk, but it ultimately paid off splendidly.
1 Strange New Worlds' Lower Decks Crossover, "Those Old Scientists"
The crossover episode of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds in which Ensign Brad Boimler (Jack Quaid) and Beckett Mariner (Tawny Newsome) from Star Trek: Lower Decks travel back to the 23rd century proved to be a heartfelt homage to fandom. While interacting with their Starfleet idols, they discover that even Captain Pike is a fan of Captain Archer played by Scott Bakula, highlighting the fact that each Star Trek series holds a special place in someone's heart. This brilliantly funny and emotionally resonant meta comedy explores the joys and pitfalls of meeting one's heroes, making it a standout episode in modern Star Trek. It is undoubtedly the finest offering from season 2 of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds.
All episodes of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds are streaming now on Paramount+.