The Harry Potter movies severely neglected Dobby's character, but the upcoming HBO reboot has the opportunity to rectify this mistake. It was truly disappointing how little screen time the house-elf received in the Warner Bros films, especially considering his endearing presence in the books. Understandably, constraints of budget and time posed a challenge in properly showcasing Dobby on the big screen. However, with the extended format of a TV series, the Harry Potter reboot holds the potential to restore and enhance Dobby's role, transforming him into a more compelling character overall.
Initially introduced in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, Dobby was initially seen as a nuisance. His actions put Harry at risk of expulsion or injury multiple times, all in an attempt to prevent the Boy Who Lived from becoming entwined in Lucius Malfoy's sinister plot involving the diary. Nevertheless, by the end, it became evident that the small house-elf had pure intentions, and his efforts in the Chamber of Secrets resulting in his freedom were cause for celebration. However, in the cinematic adaptations, this was merely the tip of the iceberg for Dobby's journey, a fact that was sadly overlooked.
The Harry Potter Movies Cut Most Of Dobby The House-Elf’s Scenes
The Chamber of Secrets film accurately depicted Dobby's story, but the subsequent movies neglected to give him the important role he had in Harry's life. In the books, Dobby appears briefly in every installment except for Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. After being dismissed by the Malfoys, he goes on to work for Dumbledore at Hogwarts, allowing him to continue supporting his friend Harry Potter.
In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Dobby is the one who steals Gillyweed from Professor Snape's stores and gives it to Harry for the second Triwizard Tournament task, not Neville as portrayed in the movie. In Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Dobby provides Harry with the Room of Requirement as a meeting place for Dumbledore's Army, not Neville as shown in the film. Lastly, in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, Harry enlists the help of Dobby and Kreacher to monitor Draco Malfoy and report any suspicious behavior, a significant storyline that is completely omitted from the movies.
Dobby Being MIA In The Harry Potter Movies Diminished His Death Scene
Dobby made his next appearance in the Harry Potter series in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, where he bravely saved Harry and the others from Malfoy Manor. This marked the house-elf's final scene, as he tragically lost his life to Bellatrix Lestrange's knife. The impact of his sacrifice was deeply felt, considering Dobby's significant presence in Harry's life. Their friendship was profound, which made it fitting for Harry to be with Dobby during his last moments and personally bury him.
However, in the Harry Potter films, the portrayal of Dobby's character was not as emotionally connected. Although his death was still sad in Deathly Hallows, it was his first appearance on screen since Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. As a result, there was less development of his bond with Harry, as they had only conversed a few times. Nonetheless, his sacrifice remained necessary and tragic, and Harry's compassion and gratitude towards the elf still held great significance in his journey—it just lacked the same depth.
The Harry Potter Remake Can Restore (& Enhance) Dobby’s Full Story
Dobby being cut from most Harry Potter movies was frustrating, but it was likely unavoidable due to the expensive and time-consuming CGI work required to bring the house-elf to life. These scenes could have easily been filled by another character, typically Neville Longbottom. However, the upcoming HBO Harry Potter remake presents a different opportunity.
The Harry Potter reboot will dedicate a full season to each of J.K. Rowling's books, allowing for a deeper exploration of Dobby's character. The project will have a much larger budget and more time, making it easier to justify the necessary work. Moreover, advancements in technology and inspiration from other fantasy series like Game of Thrones make it easier to bring Dobby to life now compared to before. Warner Bros recognizes Dobby's status as a beloved character and understands that giving the house-elf the attention he deserves will be worthwhile for Harry Potter fans.