Unleashing the Fury: Silo Producer's Unapologetic Response to Plot Hole Backlash

Warning: This article contains spoilers for Silo, an Apple TV+ series. Hugh Howey, executive producer of Silo, responds thoughtfully to a question from a fan, addressing larger concerns about fan complaints. In the season 1 finale of Silo, viewers are treated to a surprising double twist in the closing moments. It is revealed that the supposedly desolate and toxic world displayed to the silo residents is indeed mostly true. However, the seemingly idyllic surroundings seen by the cleaners when they venture outside the silo are actually a simulation imposed on them through their helmets. This revelation has left audiences with even more questions about the captivating Apple TV+ series.

During an Ask Me Anything session on Reddit, Howey was asked about the temporary appearance of the false simulation image experienced by the silo residents during a blackout in the season 1 finale of Silo. Howey, who is not only the executive producer but also the author of the fiction books on which Silo is based, takes the time to carefully address the question. However, he also uses this opportunity to make a wider point about the obsession with so-called plot holes and its lack of usefulness. Read the question and Howey's response below:

Q: Has the writers provided an in-universe explanation for why the cleaning video played on the wallscreen during the blackout? Or was it simply meant to be an entertaining topic for viewers to speculate on?

A: I believe it was the latter. I can't think of any logical explanation for that scene to occur.

When it was presented to me, my initial vision was a vibrant flash of green, reminiscent of phosphorescence. A monitor's color changing abilities when subjected to excessive pressure or a sudden surge in power. However, the unexpected inclusion of the Carmody cleaning footage caught me off guard. In hindsight, I would have preferred a shorter duration, perhaps limited to 2-3 frames.

That being said, if an inventive explanation is desired, it can easily be devised. For instance, we can introduce a former IT hacker who had been assigned the task of cleaning (potentially Carmody herself). This individual had fervently attempted to project the footage onto the big screen years ago, similar to what Jules had done in episode 10. Despite her unsuccessful attempts, the video was still uploaded. In a momentary power surge, her previous hacking efforts resurfaced temporarily before the power abruptly shut off. It was the last breath of an expired cleaner who desperately sought to reveal the truth to the world.

(This is an example of how SIMPLE it is to clarify inconsistencies in a storyline, something that any viewer is capable of doing. However, it appears that individuals derive more satisfaction from expressing anger rather than engaging their imaginative faculties. The reason behind this preference remains unclear.)

Silo's Howey Is Right About Plot Hole Discussions

Howey's comments on plot holes, in response to a question about Silo, may indicate the rise in videos and narratives solely focused on uncovering alleged gaps in logic or mistakes in popular films and shows. The fact that this particular genre of pop culture analysis exists highlights a concerning trend where movies and series are seen as puzzles to be solved or opportunities for individuals to appear intellectually superior, rather than as mediums that evoke feelings and ignite meaningful discussions about themes and ideas.

Part of the appeal of a mystery show like Silo, currently in the filming of its second season, lies in unraveling its intriguing backstory. However, solely focusing on this aspect undermines the overall enjoyment of the show. It's a common complaint to find twists too predictable or lacking in logical consistency. These remarks detract from fully engaging with the story on a deeper level, emotionally and thematically.

Silo's first season offers ample substance in these regards, right from its opening moments, as it explores the challenges faced by a couple forbidden from conceiving due to societal expectations. This weighty theme possesses significant real-world relevance. The Apple TV+ adaptation also shines in this aspect, and it should not be overlooked or overshadowed by an exclusive fixation on solving the mysteries.

Source: Hugh Howey/Reddit