Top 9 Gender-Swap Recasts That Outshone Their Originals
A comprehensive look at the top nine gender-swap recasts in movies and TV shows that not only made a mark but also surpassed their original versions.
9. The Innovative Heist: Ocean's 8
Starting off the list at number nine is the all-female crew in 'Ocean's 8', a daring spin-off from the traditionally male-dominated 'Ocean's' series. With a star-studded ensemble including Sandra Bullock, Cate Blanchett, and Rihanna, the film brought a fresh perspective to heist movies. The chemistry and dynamism of the cast provided a different kind of camaraderie, one that celebrated female solidarity and strategic genius. By successfully executing a high-stakes robbery at the Met Gala, 'Ocean's 8' not only entertained audiences but also challenged the norms of the heist genre.
The cast of Ocean's 8.looking at a computer
8. The Re-imagined Pinhead: Hellraiser (2022)
Eighth on the list is the re-imagined Pinhead from the 2022 reboot of 'Hellraiser'. Jamie Clayton's portrayal of the iconic Cenobite leader offered a more nightmarish and disturbing version of the character. Fans of the series were intrigued by the new design and Clayton's unique take on the role, which managed to pay homage to Doug Bradley's original performance while also carving out a terrifying identity of its own. The gender-swapped Pinhead stood out for its chilling presence, even in a film with limited screen time for the character, proving that a fresh take can breathe new life into a classic horror figure.
Jamie Clayton as Pinhead in Hellraiser 2022
7. The Legal Powerhouse: Jeri Hogarth in Jessica Jones
At number seven is Jeri Hogarth, a character from Marvel's 'Jessica Jones' who brought depth and complexity to the role of a gender-swapped attorney. Originally a male character in the comics, Hogarth's portrayal by Carrie-Ann Moss was a standout in the Netflix series. The character's personal and professional struggles added layers to the narrative, making Hogarth a fascinating and unpredictable figure. Whether functioning as an ally or adversary to Jessica, Hogarth's presence on the show was magnetic, and Moss's performance received widespread acclaim for its nuance and strength.
Jessica Jones Carrie Ann Moss as Jeri Hogarth looking worried
6. The Racing Prodigy: Maggie Peyton in Herbie: Fully Loaded
Coming in at number six is Maggie Peyton, the charismatic protagonist of 'Herbie: Fully Loaded'. Lindsay Lohan's portrayal of Maggie, taking over from the original Jim Douglas, injected a dose of youthful energy into the sixth installment of the Herbie series. Lohan's charm and her character's racing prowess rejuvenated the franchise and captured the hearts of a new generation. Despite receiving mixed reviews, 'Herbie: Fully Loaded' showcased Lohan's ability to lead a family-friendly sports comedy while steering clear of genre clichés.
Lindsay Lohan wears sunglasses inside of a stock car in Herbie Fully Loaded
5. The Role Reversal Romance: Overboard (2018)
Halfway through the list at number five is the gender-swapped romantic comedy 'Overboard'. The 2018 remake flipped the script on the original, with Eugenio Derbez and Anna Faris stepping into the roles of Leonardo and Kate, respectively. This fresh take on the rom-com formula not only offered laughs but also touched on themes of family and class. Derbez's portrayal of a spoiled playboy who learns humility and Faris's role as a determined single mother brought a new dimension to the story, making 'Overboard' a noteworthy example of a gender-swap remake done right.
Anna Farris and Eugenio Derbez in Overboard
4. The Comedic Duo: Jo & Penn in The Hustle
At number four, 'The Hustle' brings together Anne Hathaway and Rebel Wilson as Jo and Penn, the female counterparts to the original 'Dirty Rotten Scoundrels'. While the film itself did not impress critics, the lead actresses' comedic timing and rapport elevated the material. Their portrayal of two con artists with a mission to take down the men who wronged them was both empowering and entertaining. Despite the lukewarm reception, Hathaway and Wilson's dynamic performances added a layer of hilarity and wit to the gender-swapped comedy.
The Hustle Rebel Wilson as Pen talking to Anne Hathaway as Jo
3. The Maverick Pilot: Starbuck in Battlestar Galactica (2004)
Landing at number three is Kara 'Starbuck' Thrace from the 2004 series 'Battlestar Galactica'. Katee Sackhoff's interpretation of Starbuck offered a complex and flawed character that became a standout in the re-imagined series. Breaking away from the cliché of the original rogue pilot, the gender-swap provided a deeper exploration of Starbuck's inner turmoil and strength. Sackhoff's performance was hailed for its raw intensity and depth, making her version of Starbuck a fan favorite and a symbol of powerful female characters in science fiction.
Starbuck raises a shot glass into the air while sitting at a bar.
2. The Mind-Reading Powerhouse: Ali Davis in What Men Want
Just shy of the top spot at number two is Ali Davis from 'What Men Want'. Taraji P. Henson's portrayal of a woman in a male-dominated industry, gifted with the ability to hear men's thoughts, was a fresh and powerful twist on the original 'What Women Want'. Henson's performance as Ali was layered, blending humor with a portrayal of the challenges faced by women in the workplace. The film's modern take on gender dynamics and Ali's growth as a character resulted in a version that resonated more with contemporary audiences than its predecessor.
Taraji P Henson as Ali pointing and smiling in What Men Want
1. The Commanding M: Judi Dench in the Bond Franchise
Topping the list at number one is Judi Dench's portrayal of M in the James Bond franchise. Taking over from the traditionally male predecessors, Dench brought a formidable presence and emotional depth to the role of the head of MI6. Her M was not only a superior but also a maternal figure to Bond, adding layers to their dynamic and the series overall. Dench's performance spanned both the Brosnan and Craig eras of Bond films, leaving an indelible mark on the franchise. Her M's on-screen death in 'Skyfall' was a poignant and unprecedented moment for the character, cementing her status as the definitive M.
Judi Dench as M in James Bond's Skyfall
