Highlights
The showrunner of The Witcher, Lauren Schmidt Hissrich, explains why Vilgefortz was portrayed as weak in a key scene, citing the character's need to hide his true power.
In the latest season of The Witcher, the true villainy of Vilgefortz is unveiled as he unveils his plot to capture Ciri, showcasing his immense power and allegiance to Nilfgaard. Despite certain criticisms, fans can acknowledge the justice done to the character of Vilgefortz, who exhibits depth, ruthlessness, and faithful adaptations from the source material.
The answer to the Vilgefortz (Mahesh Jadu) question, a major concern among The Witcher fans, has finally been provided by the show's showrunner. While the series often deviates from the source material, even altering important relationships like the one between Yennefer (Anya Chalotra) and Ciri (Freya Allan) in season 2, Vilgefortz's portrayal was particularly perplexing for fans. In the climactic scene at Sodden Hill, where a conflict ensues, Vilgefortz engages in a magical battle with Cahir (Eamon Farren), Emhyr's (Bart Edwards) top soldier. Despite his impressive magical prowess, Vilgefortz is defeated by Cahir and escapes capture.
This battle challenges the perception of Vilgefortz from the fantasy series, as he is portrayed as the most formidable mage on the Continent who even challenged Geralt of Rivia. However, the conclusion of The Witcher season 3 provides fans with the answers they have been eagerly awaiting. According to Redaninan Intelligence, showrunner Lauren Schmidt Hissrich provided specific explanations for Vilgefortz's apparent weakness. In The Witcher Netflix documentary, Hissrich recalled, "One of the most common questions we received about Season 1 was regarding Episode 8, where Vilgefortz is easily defeated by Cahir in their fight. Fans were in an uproar, stating that Vilgefortz, being the most powerful mage, should not have been defeated so easily." She further explained, "This season, Vilgefortz reveals that the most challenging aspect of his long game has been concealing his true abilities. The first time we witness his true power in action is when he confronts Geralt."
In The Witcher season 3 vol. 2, Geralt (played by Henry Cavill) engages in an intense battle with Vilgefortz, as depicted in the books. In this epic encounter, Vilgefortz's true malicious nature is revealed, along with his plan to capture Ciri. Surprisingly, even Tissaia (portrayed by MyAnna Buring) remains unaware of his allegiance to Nilfgaard due to his cunning deceit. Tissaia, devastated by this betrayal, is unable to cope and tragically takes her own life, highlighting the immense power and treachery of Vilgefortz. Although there are still unanswered questions about his motives, Vilgefortz hints at a history of deceit. His heart is devoid of love or humanity, and his capabilities extend far beyond intentionally losing battles. Furthermore, given his alliance with Nilfgaard, it seems fitting for him to bear the responsibility for the actions of their elite soldiers. Fans of The Witcher may have their grievances with certain aspects of the series, such as the complex timeline, the separation of the found family, or the alteration of Triss Merigold's appearance. However, they cannot deny that Vilgefortz is portrayed exceptionally well, showcasing both his immense power through his victory over Geralt and his ruthless nature through the abduction of elven mages at Aretuza. As viewers eagerly anticipate The Witcher season 4, with its casting changes and the looming question of whether Liam Hemsworth's Geralt will kill Vilgefortz, they can, at the very least, appreciate the adaptation of Time of Contempt in the Netflix series.
The Witcher seasons 1–3 are currently streaming on Netflix.
Source: Redanian Intelligence