The Weeknd's HBO series, The Idol, has faced significant controversy, leaving viewers questioning whether a second season will be released. Premiering on June 4, 2023, the show follows the story of Jocelyn (played by Lily-Rose Depp), an aspiring pop star who becomes involved with Tedros (played by The Weeknd), a nightclub owner and self-help guru with a cult following. Co-created by Abel "The Weeknd" Tesfaye, Sam Levinson (creator of Euphoria), and Reza Fahim, The Idol premiered at the 76th Cannes Film Festival, receiving a largely negative reception. Critics heavily criticized the show's content and The Weeknd's acting abilities, although Depp's performance was praised. Despite production delays and negative reviews, The Idol has become a controversial spectacle that could potentially have a significant impact for HBO. Despite the cloud of controversy surrounding it, there is still a possibility of a second season for The Idol.
The Idol Season 2 Not Confirmed
With just a few episodes aired, HBO has yet to confirm the release of The Idol season 2. However, there is no confirmation of cancellation either, and HBO executives have made it clear that the reports of premature cancellation are false. The success of The Idol will ultimately depend on its viewership numbers rather than the critical reception it has received so far. It is important to note that many shows that have received negative reviews have managed to have long runs on television. Therefore, the fate of The Idol season 2 will be determined by the number of viewers tuning in.
The Idol's Controversies Explained
Before The Idol even premiered on HBO, it had already garnered a negative reputation due to numerous behind-the-scenes controversies that plagued its production. Even upon its release, the show faced further backlash for its mishandling of sensitive subject matter. The troubles began in 2022 when the original director, Amy Seimetz (She Dies Tomorrow), departed from the project, resulting in extensive reshoots and significant changes to both the storyline and cast. Those involved in the production described The Idol as chaotic, with many expressing their dissatisfaction with the new creative decisions.
The release of The Idol faced further issues as it received criticism for its explicit sexual content and its handling of sensitive subjects such as abuse. Despite The Weeknd's assertion that the show's sex scenes were satirical, many viewers were unconvinced by its supposed commentary on fame and its detrimental effects. When the highly anticipated show finally premiered on HBO, it appeared to validate previous claims that the reshoots had drastically altered the original female-focused storyline, instead glorifying toxic sexual relationships.
The Idol Season 2 Release Date Info
If The Idol is approved for a second season, the release date remains uncertain. While the production timeline is likely to be shorter than that of the first season, and ideally without the need for complete reshoots, speculating on the exact arrival date is futile. However, if The Idol were given the green light immediately after the conclusion of its first season, the earliest possible release would be in late 2024. Nevertheless, it is most probable that the show would return around the same time as its initial debut, in the early summer of 2025.
The Idol Season 2 Cast
Despite the negative publicity, one of the main attractions of The Idol's first season is its incredibly talented cast. The cast of The Idol not only consists of top-tier musicians, but also includes rising Hollywood stars like Depp, who are poised to become the next big names in the industry, regardless of the criticism the show has received. While nothing has been officially confirmed, it is highly possible that Depp will reprise her role as the troubled pop star Jocelyn in The Idol season 2, and she may be joined by her controversial co-star, The Weeknd, who would portray the enigmatic guru and cult leader, Tedros.
Other returns are much less certain, and would largely depend on the events of the second half of season 1. However, supporting actors such as Rachel Sennott (Leia) and Suzanna Son (Chloe) are likely to reprise their roles due to their significant contributions to the story. Moreover, Troye Sivan (Xander), Jane Adams (Nikki Katz), Jennie Ruby Jane (Dyanne), and Moses Sumney (Izaak) could also potentially make a comeback. It is uncertain whether bigger names like Eli Roth (Andrew Finkelstein) and Hank Azaria (Chaim) will return for The Idol season 2.
The Idol Season 2 Story Details
Considering the fact that The Idol has yet to complete its first season on air, any speculation about the potential story for season 2 would be purely speculative. However, based on the events aired so far, it is likely that the second season would delve deeper into Jocelyn's involvement in Tedros' cult and the resulting debauchery. If The Idol is renewed for a second season, the show has the opportunity to address criticisms and shift the focus away from Tedros, played by The Weeknd. To ensure the success of the second season, it is crucial to give Jocelyn's character more agency and development.