The Ultimate Guide to the Most Terrifying Horror Movies Exclusive to Shudder

Nowadays, there is a multitude of excellent streaming services available. Netflix and Amazon dominate the screens with their specialized offerings for movie enthusiasts, including their own unique selection of horror films. However, for those who truly live and breathe the horror genre, Shudder provides a superior offering. This specialized service solely focuses on horror and even offers its own exclusive films.

The platform already boasts a plethora of movies to choose from, but as with any service, there are some that stand out more than others. Streaming services constantly add and remove content, but Shudder has an abundance of exclusive and original horror content that is difficult to find elsewhere. If you're seeking the best horror movies of 2023, your search won't be long on Shudder.

To prevent an excessive inclusion of widely known films, this article will prioritize contemporary gems and cult favorites over established classics. Nevertheless, the following masterpieces are still highly recommended on Shudder:

Nosferatu (1922)

Carnival of Souls (1962)

Night of the Living Dead (1968)

The Texas Chain Saw Massacre (1974)

Halloween (1978)

Re-Animator (1985)

Hellraiser (1987)

Perfect Blue (1997)

Mayhem (2017)

Director	Joe Lynch
Rotten Tomatoes Score	84%

For those seeking thrilling entertainment, look no further than Mayhem, a 2017 masterpiece directed by Joe Lynch. Featuring the incredible talents of Steven Yeun and Samara Weaving, this film combines heart-pounding action, dark humor, and a touch of horror. With a concise runtime of just 83 minutes, it's the perfect choice for a fast-paced viewing experience during a busy evening. In this gripping tale, Steven Yeun portrays a recently dismissed corporate lawyer who becomes trapped inside his former colossal law office during a quarantine. Prepare yourself for an exhilarating and adrenaline-fueled journey.

Anything For Jackson (2020)

Director	Justin G. Dyck
Rotten Tomatoes Score	98%

Horror films tap into the captivating power of emotions like loss, sadness, grief, and despair. Through the portrayal of characters deeply affected by profound sorrow, audiences become more receptive to decisions and motivations that may appear irrational from a different standpoint.

Lucky (2021)

Anything For Jackson takes this concept to a chilling new level as an elderly couple delves into the depths of Satanism, desperately seeking to bring their deceased grandson back to life. However, their sinister plans take an unexpected twist, and they must face the devastating consequences that unfold. This captivating film exhibits a slow-burning intensity that is reminiscent of the sensational hit, Hereditary.

Director	Natasha Kermani
Rotten Tomatoes Score	93%

This film has received polarizing reviews on Shudder, leaving fans divided on its deserving of a higher rating. However, it's advisable to disregard these reviews and approach Lucky with an open mind.

While it may not appeal to everyone, Lucky has a strong presence in the realm of psychological horror. Those seeking a narrative focused on mental struggles rather than monstrous encounters will find much to appreciate about this film. Viewers should release any expectations and embrace the experience of this indie horror, as it offers considerable depth.

Await Further Instruction (2018)

Director	Johnny Kevorkian
Rotten Tomatoes Score	81%

For horror fans looking for a sci-fi twist, this 2018 film offers a great option that balances creativity with a sense of familiarity. Await Further Instruction follows a family as they find themselves confined to their own home, under the control of a terrifying entity that manifests through their television. As this eerie being pushes them to turn against one another, trust crumbles and their actions become increasingly twisted.

Better Watch Out (2016)

Await Further Instruction establishes a profoundly desolate ambiance that intensifies as the narrative unfolds, rendering it an unsatisfying experience. Despite its Christmas backdrop, this horror film cunningly prompts viewers to contemplate the cherished elements in their existence.

Director	Chris Peckover
Rotten Tomatoes Score	89%

For a touch of holiday cheer in your horror movie selection, consider giving 2016's Christmas classic, Better Watch Out, a chance. This thrilling psychological horror film offers a refreshing twist on the traditional Home Alone narrative that will keep you entertained. The ambiguous ending suggests the possibility of a sequel in the future, making it a great choice for anytime viewing. While it may be particularly enjoyable during December, Better Watch Out can provide a dose of twisted Christmas spirit year-round.

Henry: Portrait Of A Serial Killer (1990)

Director	John McNaughton
Rotten Tomatoes Score	89%

Henry: Portrait of a Serial Killer stands out among horror movies by offering a truly immersive experience that pushes the boundaries of fear. Unlike its more conventional counterparts, this film caters to an audience who can handle its intense and unsettling nature.

A Creepshow Holiday Special (2020)

John McNaughton's project revolves around a nomadic individual who commits unprovoked murders, drawing some inspiration from the infamous criminals Henry Lee Lucas and Ottis Toole. The film unflinchingly portrays the protagonist's brutal acts, intentionally avoiding any embellishments to maintain the raw horror of each scene. Henry exudes a raw, merciless, unsettling, and gripping aura, immersing audiences in a truly terrifying experience.

Director	Gregory Nicotero
Rotten Tomatoes Score	75%

Greg Nicotero has beautifully infused the holiday spirit into this remarkable Creepshow special. By expertly blending comedy and horror, he takes us on a captivating exploration of the folklore surrounding iconic "monsters" during the holiday season.

In this story, a man grappling with his suspicion of being a "werewolf" seeks assistance from a mysterious group. The resulting storyline not only unravels with humor and wit but also pays homage to various horror tropes. It's an ideal film for Halloween, Christmas, or any occasion in between.

Deep Red (1975)

Director	Dario Argento
Rotten Tomatoes Score	93%

Dario Argento, a prominent figure in the Giallo horror genre, has established himself as one of the most renowned names. Although some of Argento's projects may not live up to expectations, his greatest works – including Suspiria, Opera, Inferno, and Tenebrae – are undeniably some of the most chilling films in the horror genre. Amongst his terrifying masterpieces, it can be argued that Deep Red from 1975 stands as the pinnacle of Argento's exceptional filmmaking.

Scare Package (2020)

A masterfully crafted murder mystery, Deep Red captivates audiences with its suspenseful storytelling and unforgettable climax. Within the vast selection of Argento movies on Shudder, Deep Red undeniably stands out as the pinnacle of excellence.

Directors	Courtney Andujar, Aaron B. Koontz
Rotten Tomatoes Score	81%

Scare Package is a brilliantly crafted satire that injects comedy into the world of gore for horror fans. It cleverly mocks horror tropes and presents a collection of short stories that are undeniably hilarious.

Whether it's a murderous holiday tale or a narrative centered around a candy that alters the body, Scare Package caters to every horror aficionado. The characters are also immensely enjoyable, particularly the main protagonist whose exaggerated persona elicits hearty laughter.

Color Out Of Space (2019)

Director	Richard Stanley
Rotten Tomatoes Score	86%

The movie Color Out Of Space released in 2019 may not cater to all audiences. It is best suited for horror enthusiasts who have a taste for the unconventional aspects of the genre or possess an admiration for Lovecraftian horror. However, individuals who are willing to give this film a try will be rewarded with the presence of the consistently impressive actor, Nicholas Cage.

V/H/S/94 (2021)

This film is an adaptation of the short story with the same title, ensuring viewers anticipate nothing less than the utmost peculiar storyline. Fortunately, that is precisely what horror enthusiasts can expect as they witness the characters of this movie encounter the enigmatic Color.

Directors	Simon Barrett, Steven Kostanski, Chloe Okuno, Ryan Prows, Jennifer Reeder, Timo Tjahjanto
Rotten Tomatoes Score	91%

For those seeking a truly terrifying anthology series that blends in occasional bursts of humor, the latest installment from V/H/S is a must-see. With its gripping short stories, the V/H/S series has garnered widespread acclaim and achieved cult status. Building upon its predecessors, V/H/S/94 surpasses expectations and intensifies the experience, thanks in part to its affiliation with Shudder Original.

Within this collection, there are numerous chilling tales that converge under a unifying narrative, ensuring the series' continued momentum.

Jakob's Wife (2021)

Director	Travis Stevens
Rotten Tomatoes Score	85%

A fun and funny twist on the vampire sub-genre of horror, Jakob's Wife follows a woman who suddenly gains an agonizing appetite for blood.

Santa Sangre (1990)

Jakob's Wife provides a fascinating exploration of the concept of unexpectedly transforming into a vampire and the resulting aftermath. This film masterfully combines elements of comedy with skillful writing to depict the highs and lows of a troubled marriage, which is further strained by an abrupt supernatural transformation.

Director	Alejandro Jodorowsky
Rotten Tomatoes Score	86%

Alejandro Jodorowsky's Santa Sangre transcends conventional categorization, weaving a disturbing narrative of codependency between a mesmerizing circus trapeze artist named Concha and her troubled son, Fenix. Rooted in the realm of surreal horror, this tale delves deep into their unsettling relationship, only growing more unsettling as the story progresses.

For optimum effect, it is recommended to approach Santa Sangre with a blank slate, devoid of any prior knowledge. With its psychedelic undertones and intense bursts of violence, this film may not be ideal for a casual movie marathon gathering. Nevertheless, it stands as one of the finest offerings in the horror genre on Shudder, and those seeking an exploration of the experimental side of horror should not miss it.

Ringu (1998)

Director	Hideo Nakata
Rotten Tomatoes Score	98%

The Ring, released in 2002, is a well-regarded ghost movie in North America. However, despite its fame, audiences should not overlook the original Japanese version, Ringu, released in 1998.

Train To Busan (2016)

While both movies touch on similar themes, they offer distinct experiences, with the J-horror flick surpassing its counterpart in terms of fear factor. Ringu, with its deliberate pacing and suspenseful atmosphere, expertly creates a persistent sense of dread that saturates every moment of its duration.

Director	Yeon Sang-ho
Rotten Tomatoes Score	94%

Zombies have become overused, making it necessary for any new addition to the subgenre to be exceptional in order to make a lasting impact. Train to Busan certainly fits this description. This South Korean film tells the story of a father and daughter embarking on what should be a simple train journey, only for things to take a drastic turn when an apocalypse unfolds.

Train to Busan expertly combines action, horror, and drama, resulting in a thrilling film that captivates audiences from start to finish. While it may not be the scariest movie available on Shudder, this 2016 release is unquestionably one of the streaming service's finest offerings.

The Invitation (2015)

Director	Karyn Kusama
Rotten Tomatoes Score	89%

The Invitation, a gripping psychological thriller, will leave you on the edge of your seat as you try to unravel its mysteries. With unexpected twists and turns, this horror film showcases the genre's brilliance and yet, it remains undiscovered by many.

Caveat (2020)

Will finds himself in a peculiar gathering with his former acquaintances and his ex-spouse, enveloped in an aura of malevolence right from the outset. However, discerning whether this ominous atmosphere stems from an actual threat or the manifestation of Will's deteriorated psychological state proves to be a daunting task.

Director	Damian Mc Carthy
Rotten Tomatoes Score	82%

Viewers who appreciate the slow buildup and tension in horror films will be thrilled by Caveat, a creatively terrifying movie with captivating visuals. The story revolves around a man who is forced to accompany someone experiencing severe anxiety attacks on a deserted island. Initially appearing straightforward, the premise spirals into complete chaos, revealing unexpected layers and a gripping narrative.

Goodnight Mommy (2014)

Director	Veronika Franz, Severin Fiala
Rotten Tomatoes Score	85%

The original Austrian horror movie, available on Shudder, surpasses its recent American remake. Throughout most of the film, viewers are left uncertain about the events unfolding before their eyes, setting it apart from typical horror movies.

Those who enjoy unraveling the mysteries of what lies ahead will discover Goodnight Mommy to be an unequivocal success. Within the film, two young boys encounter a woman who claims to be their mother after undergoing facial surgery, but their skepticism leads them down a menacing path.

Boys From County Hell (2020)

Director	Chris Baugh
Rotten Tomatoes Score	83%

Unleashing a formidable vampire upon the countryside, this Irish horror film delves into an ancient malevolence, captivating audiences with its exploration of bickering father-and-son relationships and the collective struggle to conquer a sinister force. Infused with Irish humor and boasting an abundance of classic vampire tropes, this tense movie expertly weaves moments of comedy amidst its gripping narrative, earning its status as a highly regarded vampire flick.

Host (2020)

Director	Rob Savage
Rotten Tomatoes Score	99%

When the global pandemic struck, numerous studios faced a severe blow as theaters and productions were compelled to cease operations. This setback cast a shadow over the entertainment scene, which serves as an escapism for countless individuals. The inability of entertainment producers to bring joy to those confined indoors for months presented a dire situation. However, amidst the challenges, certain creators managed to find innovative ways to navigate through the obstacles.

Host is a remarkable film created by a skilled team of filmmakers who came together during the pandemic and worked remotely. With its chilling narrative and exploration of the occult, it stands out as one of the finest horror films to emerge from 2020.