The Ultimate Battle of Red-Haired Heroines: Unveiling the Epic Connection Between Edens Zero's Elsie Crimson and Fairy Tail's Fierce Erza Scarlet

Highlights

Edens Zero and Fairy Tail have numerous resemblances stemming from the fact that they were both crafted by Hiro Mashima, resulting in the recycling of character designs and traits.

Elsie Crimson from Edens Zero bears a striking resemblance to Fairy Tail's Erza Scarlet in terms of her appearance, design, and powers, although there are subtle differences in their roles within their respective series.

Despite distinct personalities displayed by Edens Zero characters such as Shiki and Rebecca, Elsie's character is often overshadowed by her Fairy Tail counterpart due to her limited screen time and shared traits, making it challenging to distinguish her from Erza.

The anime industry is filled with overused storylines and character designs, resulting in many series sharing similarities. Edens Zero and Fairy Tail, both created by Hiro Mashima, are two such series that exhibit an astonishing number of resemblances. This can be attributed to Mashima's tendency to recycle character designs and traits in his works.

While most characters in Edens Zero can be traced back to Fairy Tail, Elsie Crimson appears to be a direct replica of Erza Scarlet, with very few deviations. Their character designs and abilities are eerily similar, although their roles in the respective series may have slight differences. Although Mashima's intention of incorporating familiar designs to evoke nostalgia in Edens Zero may have been successful, Elsie's character remains overshadowed by her Fairy Tail counterpart.

Appearance and Design

The two series share a significant similarity in their character designs and appearances. Most viewers can easily recognize familiar faces, but Elsie stands out the most due to her almost identical resemblance to Erza Scarlet. From her iconic red hair to their indistinguishable facial structures, Elsie's design heavily mirrors Erza's distinct features.

Despite these apparent similarities, there are still a few distinguishing elements between the two characters. Instead of wearing a plain armor, Elsie opts for a skin-tight suit with a cape flowing from her back. Her right eye is also adorned with an eye-patch, further differentiating her from Erza. However, even with these alterations, viewers often struggle to perceive Elsie as a separate character.

Personality and Characterization

Both characters have similar personalities, characterized by their tenacity and intelligence in battle, as well as an unwavering determination. While Elsie's screen time is limited compared to other characters in Edens Zero, viewers have yet to fully discover her true self. However, the glimpses of her personality that have been revealed demonstrate clear similarities with Erza Scarlet. Both characters possess a tough exterior but also show a caring side towards those they hold dear. Elsie, however, exhibits a more laid-back and rebellious nature, which sets her apart from Erza's mature and responsible demeanor.

Hiro Mashima has put forth considerable effort in developing the characterizations of the Edens Zero characters. This is evident from the distinct personalities of Shiki and Rebecca, which set them apart from their counterparts in Fairy Tail. However, when it comes to Elsie, she has been given minimal screen time, making it challenging to accurately define her true character or identify the unique qualities that distinguish her from Erza.

Powers and Abilities

While the main characters of Edens Zero and Fairy Tail bear striking similarities in their looks and personalities, it is their unique and exceptional powers that truly set them apart. However, when it comes to Elsie, it appears that even her abilities are somewhat reminiscent of Erza's. With her Star Drain Ether Gear, Elsie possesses the ability to absorb the Ether of the planet she stands on and utilize it to summon awe-inspiring elemental armors.

An Adversary From the Past

Elsie's powers bear striking resemblance to Erza's Requip Magic, enabling her to instantaneously don magical armor and mythical weapons. Their similarities extend beyond their abilities, with the process of re-equipping remaining unchanged. However, Elsie's powers diverge in that she can harness the same Ether to unleash precise energy attacks. This ability mirrors the utilization of Heavenly Body Magic, a unique form of magical prowess demonstrated by Jellal Fernandes in the world of Fairy Tail.

Throughout Hiro Mashima's series, a common theme emerges - a male adversary with a deep connection to one of the protagonists from the past. Despite being on opposing sides, this history often gives rise to feelings of love that intertwine with the conflict. In the case of Erza, her longtime friend Jellal Fernandes fell into corruption and became a force of evil. However, he eventually finds redemption and once again allies with Erza. The series also delves into their complex emotions, implicitly suggesting the existence of a profound love between them.

In Edens Zero, Jellal's counterpart is Justice, who belongs to the Oracion Seis Interstellar and works for the Cosmic Government. Similar to Jellal in Fairy Tail, Justice seeks vengeance against Elsie and vows to eliminate her personally. However, it is apparent that the two have a shared history that has yet to be uncovered. A member of the Oracion Seis Interstellar playfully suggests that Justice still harbors feelings for Elsie, hinting at an emotional connection between them. Echoing the storyline of Erza and Jellal, Elsie and Justice are following a similar path in Edens Zero, showcasing Mashima's reuse of certain elements in the series.

The anime series Edens Zero can be streamed on Crunchyroll.