The Top 10 Movies of 1958: A Definitive Ranking

One of the fascinating aspects of revisiting movies from previous decades is observing the evolution and progress of the film medium. In the 1920s, a significant portion of movies were silent, devoid of dialogue. In the 1930s, the use of color alongside black-and-white began to emerge. The 1940s witnessed filmmakers utilizing cinema to reflect on a world engulfed in a global war, offering perhaps a respite from the harsh realities. The 1950s marked the advent of wider aspect ratios, and the international film industry started to flourish.

As the 1950s drew to a close, it became evident that the revolutionary filmmaking of the 1960s was on the horizon. However, during this transitional period, the groundwork was being laid for the kind of movies that would thrive in the forthcoming decade. Consequently, it is unsurprising that 1958 yielded a plethora of exceptional titles that deserve attention from enthusiasts of classic cinema. The following list presents some of the finest films from that year, ranked in ascending order from good to exceptional.

10. 'The Big Country'

Image via TCM

The Big Country, clocking in at 166 minutes, may not hold the title for the longest Western ever made, but it certainly ranks among the lengthy ones. This epic production boasts an impressive cast, featuring Gregory Peck, Jean Simmons, and Charlton Heston, and immerses viewers in a captivating tale set in the Old West. While it may not win over those who are not fans of the Western genre, it offers a delightful treat for enthusiasts of classic stories from the Old West. The narrative unfolds gradually but ultimately proves gratifying, complemented by breathtaking visuals that harness the power of color and an expansive cinematic canvas, providing the audience with a wealth of stunning imagery.

9. 'Cat on a Hot Tin Roof'

Although not Paul Newman's first film, Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (1958) significantly boosted his visibility and earned him his first Oscar nomination. The film holds similar significance in Elizabeth Taylor's career, although it did not have the same impact as she had already established herself as a child actress.

Cat on a Hot Tin Roof is a film adaptation of Tennessee Williams' 1955 play. It delves into the struggles of an ex-football player grappling with personal challenges, a failing marriage, and a dying father. This emotionally intense and explosive drama is made exceptional by the brilliant screenplay and powerful performances by its leading actors.

8. 'The Music Room'

Image via Contemporary Films

The Music Room, a departure from Satyajit Ray's coming-of-age Apu Trilogy, focuses on an affluent elderly man consumed by his passion for music. This deliberate and visually captivating film adds depth and intricacy to a straightforward narrative through its evocative use of music. With its confident storytelling and impactful style, The Music Room stands as one of Satyajit Ray's finest and most revered works.

7. 'The Defiant Ones'

The Defiant Ones is an intriguing and captivating drama that deviates from the typical prison escape plot. Instead, it focuses on the aftermath of the escape and explores the unconventional alliance formed between two convicts of different races who are chained together. Starring Tony Curtis and Sidney Poitier, both deliver outstanding performances that showcase their esteemed talent. While the film has a strong social message, it may be perceived as slightly heavy-handed by contemporary standards. Nonetheless, when viewed within its historical context, the film's storyline, acting, and overall engagement are commendable.

6. 'Ashes and Diamonds'

Image via Janus Films

Ashes and Diamonds is a unique Polish film that offers a fresh perspective on the war genre. Set in the aftermath of World War II, the story revolves around the clash between the anti-Communist underground and the Polish Workers' Party in 1945.

The film delves into the protagonist's struggle with an assigned assassination mission, bringing forth gripping internal conflicts that drive the plot. With its captivating visuals and psychological intensity, Ashes and Diamonds leaves a lasting impression as a haunting and thought-provoking exploration of the lasting effects of war and the perpetuation of conflict.

5. 'A Night to Remember'

A Night to Remember may not have the same level of fame as James Cameron's iconic Titanic movie, but it can be argued that it is the superior film with a focus on the Titanic. While it may not have the same grand spectacle and romantic storyline that made Cameron's film popular, A Night to Remember offers a more direct and grounded portrayal.

The film aims to realistically depict the Titanic disaster, primarily focusing on the events leading up to it, the disaster itself, and its aftermath. It is a refined and respectful movie that was technically excellent for its time. Considering its quality, A Night to Remember should be more widely recognized as a noteworthy film about the Titanic.

4. 'The Hidden Fortress'

Image via Toho

When discussing Akira Kurosawa's renowned samurai epics, many people consider his 1954 film, Seven Samurai, to be his best work. However, it's important to also explore his other samurai movies. One film that successfully captures the same essence as Seven Samurai is The Hidden Fortress, released just four years later.

The Hidden Fortress follows the story of two peasants who unexpectedly join forces with two members of royalty, both in hiding. Together, they embark on a perilous and lengthy journey to find the fabled hidden fortress. This film is incredibly entertaining, beautifully shot, and skillfully combines elements of comedy, drama, action, and adventure. The seamless blend of these genres creates a captivating viewing experience.

3. 'Touch of Evil'

Image via Universal

Orson Welles, known for his iconic debut film Citizen Kane, continued to impress with his subsequent works. Among them, Touch of Evil stands out as one of his greatest accomplishments. This ambitious crime and thriller film is notable for being one of the last "true" film noir movies.

What truly captivates in Touch of Evil is its unforgettable opening shot – a continuous take that maintains suspense by avoiding cuts. However, the film remains captivating even after this remarkable moment. The plot revolves around a murder investigation involving several nefarious individuals, resulting in intrigue, suspense, and an unpredictable narrative that keeps viewers enthralled from start to finish.

2. 'Elevator to the Gallows'

Elevator to the Gallows is arguably the epitome of effortless cool in the crime movie genre. Its stylish and classy execution has allowed it to age gracefully over time. The film delves into the story of a man's attempt to execute a flawless crime, only to encounter natural complications. Elevator to the Gallows meticulously depicts the chain reaction of misfortunes that ensue.

Louis Malle, renowned for his impressive body of work, undoubtedly reached his peak with Elevator to the Gallows. As his first non-documentary feature film, it shines brightly. The film's visual aesthetics are impeccable, the pacing is flawless, and it is elevated by the unforgettable jazz score. The legendary musician, Miles Davis, improvised and performed this remarkable soundtrack.

1. 'Vertigo'

Image via Paramount Pictures

Vertigo, released in 1958, is often considered Alfred Hitchcock's greatest masterpiece among his extensive filmography. It offers an unsettling and thought-provoking narrative that delves into darker and more mature themes. It can also be seen as a deeply personal work for Hitchcock, shedding light on aspects of his own psyche.

The film revolves around a private detective who becomes entangled in a job for a friend, leading to an unhealthy obsession with a woman and unforeseen consequences. While Vertigo unfolds slowly, it captivates viewers with its breathtaking cinematography and an eerie allure that solidifies its reputation as one of the finest films of its time.