The Silent Suffering: Unveiling the Impact of Male Loneliness on Fatherhood

Several years ago, a fellow father contacted me upon coming across my writing on stay-at-home parenting. Married and with two young children, he was experiencing difficulties and lacked an outlet to confide in, aside from his immediate family.

When it comes to male loneliness, social isolation hits dads particularly hard, author Shannon Carpenter writes.

Shannon Carpenter:

Without explicitly stating it, fatherhood had started to impact his mental well-being and sense of self-worth. Although he had a good relationship with his significant other, he confessed to feeling isolated due to the lack of friends.

In today's society, there is a growing conversation about men struggling to find meaningful and supportive friendships like women often do. Personally, I have also felt the effects of what experts term as the "male loneliness epidemic," and it appears to extend into the realm of fatherhood as well. One father shared his perspective with me, saying, "I often feel there is nobody to talk to. Even in a crowded room, it feels as though I am invisible." This resonated deeply with my own experiences.

Fifteen years ago, as a new stay-at-home dad, I brought my children to the mall playground. While my toddler played on the germ-infested equipment, I sat on the floor with my newborn, a book in hand, with my arm casually draped over the end of a bench.

Before long, a group of moms arrived at the bench, placing their bags and parking their strollers nearby. Unaware of my presence, one of the moms unintentionally sat on my arm. Sensing the need to speak up, I politely said "Excuse me" to her, but to my surprise, she looked at me in disbelief and failed to offer an apology. It seemed that I had become invisible in her eyes.

What's happening here?

The most common query I receive from fathers is how to discover genuine bonds and companionship. Regardless of whether they are stay-at-home dads or not, the absence of significant connections creates a void in our lives.

Richard Reeves coined the term "friendship deficiency" to describe the struggle faced by the modern male, as highlighted in his book "Of Boys and Men: Why the Modern Male Is Struggling, Why It Matters, and What to Do About It."

In the United States, numerous men have experienced a disconnection from societal institutions that have traditionally served as a support system for fathers within our communities. Throughout history, men have formed enduring relationships through religious institutions, friendships in the workplace, and finding self-worth through their role as providers for their families.

Boundaries are natural and exist for both the people you love and those you don't, experts said.

Jorg Greuel/Digital Vision/Getty Images

What to do when your family just wont respect your boundaries, according to experts

Additionally, in today's society, men may perceive intimate relationships as lacking in masculinity, resulting in increased feelings of isolation. A survey conducted by the Survey Center on American Life in May 2021, as previously reported by CNN, revealed that only 48% of men expressed satisfaction with their friendships. Furthermore, only one in five men stated that they had received emotional support from a friend within the past week, compared to four in ten women.

Moreover, traditional institutions that have long embodied male dominance have been dismantled. It is important to note that this disruption is not necessarily negative, as these power structures often marginalized women. As parents and guardians, it is crucial for us to move forward rather than regress, and to envision a new and better normal.

Fathers face the challenge of establishing a new routine that addresses their own needs along with the needs of the women in their lives. Reeves, a nonresident senior fellow at the Brookings Institution, pointed out the lack of comprehensive support systems for fathers at various levels.

Loneliness in fatherhood extends beyond marital status. It stems from the fundamental need for a sense of community, particularly friendship. The invaluable ability to seek advice and be vulnerable without fear is often absent for fathers in today's society. Many new dads lack the guidance and support that comes from having mentors in their lives.

Reeves acknowledges the substantial strides women have made towards equality in the past 50 years. Progress has been relatively rapid, benefiting both men and women by providing greater choices and freedom. Financial restraints no longer bind women to their husbands. However, men have not kept pace with the changing world. As a result, our connections have weakened, leaving us feeling isolated amidst a sea of people.

That's why I frequently receive inquiries from fellow fathers who approach me individually, often feeling lost and desperately seeking someone who can empathize with their struggles. Despite being married, many of these men still experience profound loneliness.

This sense of isolation poses a significant issue for men. According to a study conducted in June, individuals who face social isolation are 32% more likely to experience premature death compared to those who have a robust social network. In his book, Reeves highlights that among men who have taken their lives, the term "worthless" frequently appears in their suicide notes.

Men need to find our worth again.

How we think about fathers and fatherhood

Too frequently, fathers are depicted as dispensable imbeciles who only serve to complicate the task of parenting, rather than contributing positively to the dynamics of the family. In movies, TV shows, and novels, it is often the mother's duty to rein in the father's actions. Instead of promoting active participation by men in the parenting process, popular culture tends to mock and belittle it. This messaging undoubtedly influences how fathers and others perceive their abilities as parents.

{{img_placeholder_2}}

Shutterstock

Dads need to make healthy behaviors a part of their lives as they age

"We need to redefine the concept of fatherhood," stated Reeves. "There is a crucial need for a more active and involved approach."

Moreover, the United States necessitates policy amendments that promote and endorse fatherhood right from the start. Presently, there is a lack of a nationwide policy on paternity leave. As fathers, our responsibility does not end the moment our child is born. It merely marks the beginning. Additionally, if fathers do decide to take parental leave upon their child's birth, they are frequently confronted with inquiries about their reasons. There exists a presumption that childcare is exclusively a woman's responsibility, disregarding the role fathers can play.

Next, it is essential to establish inclusive communities that effectively empower fathers to excel. Men require both emotional and physical support. At-home dads can conveniently seek such assistance from renowned organizations like The National At Home Dad Network and City Dads Group.

Nevertheless, it is crucial to highlight that both national organizations extend their resources beyond supporting at-home dads. Our focus is not limited to fathers who choose to stay at home with their children, but rather extends to working dads and divorced dads as well. We firmly believe that irrespective of the specific circumstances, every father deserves mentorship and a supportive network where they can cultivate enduring friendships.

However, achieving this will require a significant transformation in our societal mindset and behaviors regarding parenting and fatherhood.

Reeves promotes a concept he refers to as HEAL: health, education, administration, and literacy. In essence, he urges men to actively take up caregiver roles, such as becoming teachers, nurses, or paid childcare workers. I acknowledge that there are numerous obstacles that need to be overcome in order to achieve this vision. It demands that society begins to appreciate fathers for more than just their financial contributions and move beyond the stereotypes that depict them as inept fools.

Black fathers demonstrate a greater propensity to engage in playtime, assist with dressing, and partake in meals with their children, as indicated by data analysis. It is imperative to establish systems that not only inspire fathers to shoulder the emotional responsibilities of parenting, but also provide them with the necessary assistance to fulfill this role. The societal perception of fatherhood should not hinge solely on financial provisions and work hours. While financial caregiving remains essential, the connections we foster with our children, families, and communities are equally vital.

Content must be written in English:

Making friends as a man can be challenging, but it is essential to break free from our solitary existence and re-engage with our community. There are various ways to achieve this, such as volunteering for a local organization, participating in hobby groups with regular gatherings, or simply joining an online community like Fathering Together. It is crucial for us to put ourselves out there, on a personal level, and actively strive to establish friendships.

For men, building these connections is of utmost importance, as our very lives depend on it. The male loneliness epidemic highlights the urgency for fostering relationships. Currently, the bonds we form with others are what we need above all else.

Shannon Carpenter is a writer, author of the book "The Ultimate Stay-at-Home Dad" and married father of three.