The Significance of Eliminating Lead from Water Pipes: Insights from a Medical Professional

The US Environmental Protection Agency has introduced a rule that mandates the replacement of millions of lead service pipes in water systems nationwide within the next 10 years. This proposal aligns with the Biden administration's objective to eliminate all lead pipes, regardless of lead levels in water samples, while acknowledging that under certain circumstances, an extension for system-wide line replacements may be allowed. This proposal has sparked inquiries about the health implications of lead, particularly for children, and the symptoms and available treatments for lead poisoning. Furthermore, there is interest in understanding the potential public health benefits of removing all lead pipes.

To help us answer these questions, I interviewed Dr. Leana Wen, CNN's medical expert on wellness. Dr. Wen is an emergency physician and a professor of health policy and management at the George Washington University Milken Institute School of Public Health. She has also served as Baltimore's health commissioner, where she was responsible for overseeing programs aimed at preventing childhood lead poisoning.

CNN: What makes high lead levels so hazardous, and why are children particularly vulnerable to lead poisoning?

Dr. Leana Wen emphasizes that pediatricians and public health experts agree: no level of lead exposure is safe for children. The harmful effects of lead on children's health, both immediate and long-term, are well-documented and include damage to the brain and nervous system, resulting in lower IQ, learning and behavior difficulties, hearing loss, speech problems, and impaired growth and development.

Nearly half of the tap water in the US is contaminated with forever chemicals, government study finds

Adverse effects are most severe in children under the age of 6 for two main reasons. Firstly, young children's developing organs are greatly affected by toxins due to their rapid growth and development. Secondly, young kids often put objects into their mouths, potentially ingesting lead dust from their environment without their caregivers' knowledge.

The issue is widespread, with approximately 4 million households in the US having children exposed to high levels of lead, according to the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

CNN: What are the signs of lead poisoning?

Wen: Detecting lead exposure is challenging because most children show no symptoms. This may result in parents and caregivers being unaware of their kids having a harmful level of lead in their system.

CNN: Is it possible for adults to develop lead poisoning?

Wen: Indeed. While lead poisoning in adults is rarer, it is typically linked to exposure in the workplace. The potential impacts are diverse and can include anemia, kidney issues, high blood pressure, and reproductive health complications such as low sperm count and miscarriage. Similarly to children, adults might not display obvious symptoms but can still experience negative health effects.

Cases of pneumonia in children have spiked in China this fall.

Kyodo News/Getty Images

What to know about Mycoplasma, the bacteria behind recent spikes in pneumonia cases in Ohio and overseas

CNN: How are elevated lead levels diagnosed?

Elevated lead levels can be detected through blood testing, typically done through a standard blood draw or finger-prick at a laboratory or doctor's office. Home testing is not recommended. In the United States, children are mandated to have their blood lead levels checked at 12 and 24 months, as lead poisoning can have serious consequences and may not show symptoms. Additional testing may be necessary if there are concerns about lead exposure or symptoms arise.

CNN: What happens if an elevated amount is found?

Wen: The CDC has recommended procedures based on how elevated the blood lead levels are.

Certain steps in this process involve conducting a thorough history and physical examination to evaluate the presence of any additional symptoms associated with lead exposure. The family might be recommended for an environmental evaluation of their home as well as participation in a lead hazard reduction initiative.

In cases where the blood levels are significantly elevated, further inquiry may be necessary, including an abdominal X-ray to determine whether the ingestion of a lead-containing substance has occurred. If there are worrisome indications of lead poisoning, hospital admission for the child may be considered.

Treatment for acute lead poisoning in children who have ingested a significant amount of lead includes administering laxatives to expel the lead and an intravenous infusion to reduce the lead levels in the bloodstream. However, much of the damage caused by lead poisoning, such as brain and nerve damage, may be irreversible and occurs over a longer period of time. This emphasizes the importance of prevention. Furthermore, the recent recall of lead-contaminated applesauce products by the US Food and Drug Administration raises concerns about the safety of feeding children applesauce.

Wen: Yes, but I would urge parents to follow FDA advice and stay away from the specific recalled products.

US Department of Agriculture

Tyson recalls 30,000 pounds of chicken nuggets

Consumers should always take heed of advisories like these, but it's important to remember that most lead exposure doesn't come from one-off events that get a lot of media attention.

One major source of lead exposure is lead paint. According to the CDC, homes built before 1978 "probably contain lead-based paint," as lead paint was only banned in 1978. Children can accidentally ingest paint chips, and when paint peels or cracks, it releases dust containing lead. This dust can be ingested or inhaled by kids, leading to elevated lead levels.

Removal of all lead pipes would have a significant public health impact.

Lead in drinking water is a significant problem, particularly in some communities, due to various factors such as the type and condition of service lines, the amount of water in contact with the pipes, and the water's acidity or alkalinity.

While replacing lead service pipes can reduce children's exposure, it is not the sole preventative measure necessary. Parents and caregivers must remain vigilant about potential lead exposure from sources such as paint, soil, and other sources. Lead poisoning is a preventable tragedy, and we all have a role to play in minimizing its impact.