The Shocking Truth About How I Met Your Father's Mysterious New Ted

WARNING! This article contains SPOILERS for seasons 1 and 2 of How I Met Your Father!

Summary

Sophie in

How I Met Your Father

is compared to

How I Met Your Mother's

Ted

due to their similar storytelling styles and hopeless romantic nature.

However, Sid from

How I Met Your Father

Sid, one of the characters in How I Met Your Father, actually bears more resemblance to Ted, both in terms of personality and storylines. While Sophie is the central character in this Hulu sitcom, Sid exhibits traits and experiences that align closely with Ted from How I Met Your Mother. In How I Met Your Father, an older Sophie recounts her journey of meeting her son's father, while introducing her friend group consisting of Valentina, Charlie, Jesse, Ellen, Sid, and Hannah. These characters, all in their early 30s, navigate the challenges of life and relationships. As a spinoff of the popular show How I Met Your Mother, How I Met Your Father showcases an outstanding cast.

Since these shows are interconnected, viewers have embraced the identification of the "new" versions of beloved characters from How I Met Your Mother. The most commonly used comparison is Sophie, who is often referred to as the new Ted. After all, both characters are hopeless romantics narrating their stories to their future children. Additionally, Sid and Hannah are commonly regarded as the new Marshall and Lily due to their engagement in the series premiere and their portrayal as the most stable couple. However, it should be noted that Sid from How I Met Your Father bears a closer resemblance to Ted in terms of personality traits and storylines.

8 Both Characters Are Hopeless Romantic

Both Ted and Sid are passionate romantics, devoting considerable effort and attention to their relationships. They firmly believe that love has the power to endure distance, despite their initial concerns. When confronted with relationship challenges, Ted and Sid lean towards the belief that love will conquer all. In fact, they are willing to go to great extremes to ensure the success of their relationships. For instance, when Ted begins a relationship with Stella, he willingly relocates to a despised state in order to make her happy. Similarly, Sid from How I Met Your Father contemplates the idea of moving to Los Angeles for Hannah, showcasing his dedication to making their relationship thrive.

7 Sid And Ted Cheat On Their Partners During Long-Distance Relationships

In How I Met Your Mother, Ted engages in infidelity by pursuing a romantic relationship with Robin while he is in a committed long-distance relationship with Victoria. Despite being in a relationship, Ted makes attempts to initiate a physical connection with Robin, but his plans are thwarted when Victoria unexpectedly calls and Robin answers the phone. On the other hand, Sid in How I Met Your Father engages in an emotional affair with Taylor. This unfolds when Sid meets Taylor while traveling to visit Hannah during their own long-distance relationship. The two of them indulge in constant texting, discussing intimate and personal matters. Sid only ceases this inappropriate communication with Taylor when Jesse confronts him about his misconduct with someone other than his wife.

6 Sid Keeps Secrets To Protect Friends Like Ted

Both Ted and Sid demonstrate a protective nature throughout both series, going to great lengths to keep secrets that would spare their best friends from emotional devastation. In the case of How I Met Your Mother, Ted chooses to withhold the fact that Lily has applied to an art program on the other side of the country from Marshall. His motivation for this secrecy stems from his realization that such knowledge would shatter Marshall emotionally. Similarly, despite his own frustrations, Sid keeps Meredith's secret of skipping out on Jesse's performance in How I Met Your Father. Sid understands the profound heartbreak Jesse would experience upon discovering that Meredith disparaged his work. Ultimately, it becomes evident that Ted and Sid possess a deep understanding of their friends, as both Marshall and Jesse end up hurt by their respective partners' actions.

5 Ted And Sid Are Both Willing To Spontaneously Get Married

Ted and Sid are no strangers to spontaneity when it comes to major commitments. In the show "How I Met Your Mother," Ted steps up and takes charge of Stella's sister's wedding with only a few days' notice. He doesn't even question whether the wedding is a perfect fit for them. In a similar vein, Sid from "How I Met Your Father" also dives into a sudden commitment without much forethought by eloping with Hannah. While eloping is not necessarily a bad thing, Sid ends up sacrificing important aspects that matter to him. His family from India is not present to witness the wedding, and they miss out on incorporating his own cultural traditions into the ceremony, which was something Sid had expressed a desire for.

4 Both Characters Engage In Hijinks With Friends

Both Ted and Sid, although not typically the instigators, often find themselves caught up in mischievous adventures with their friends. In How I Met Your Mother season 1, for instance, Ted and Barney have a peculiar encounter where Ted licks the liberty bell. As the series progresses, Ted unwillingly becomes the instructor for Barney's Robin 101 class. In a similar fashion, Sid partakes in ludicrous antics with his companions in How I Met Your Father. On one occasion, Sid aids Sophie in organizing a pop-up event to strengthen her bond with her father. Moreover, he collaborates with Ellen to deceive Jesse and Charlie into participating in a bonding board game, with the intention of them becoming roommates.

3 Both Ted and Sid Move In With Their Best Friend After College

How I Met Your Mother and How I Met Your Father revolve around the theme of friendships, where Ted and Sid share a strong bond with their closest companions and choose to live with them even after graduating from college. Similarly, Sid, Jesse, and Hannah, just like Ted, Marshall, and Lily, attend Wesleyan together. Following their time at Wesleyan, Sid and Jesse decide to become roommates, just like Ted and Marshall previously did in Marshall and Lily's former apartment. When they are not at their respective bars, a significant amount of their time is spent bonding and hanging out in the apartment.

2 Ted And Sid Like To Perform Grand Gestures

Despite their potential for overwhelming and annoying behavior, both Ted and Sid are inclined to make extravagant displays of affection for their loved ones. In How I Met Your Mother, Ted engages in actions such as stealing a blue French horn for Robin, hoping to impress her and win a second chance. Later on, he goes as far as jeopardizing his job at the Arcadia for Zoey's sake. Meanwhile, in How I Met Your Father, Sid puts effort into learning how to use a lighting ring, positioning himself advantageously, and exuding sex appeal as a means to impress Hannah. Eventually, he even goes on a cross-country flight to surprise her. Although Sid's grand gestures may hold less magnitude than those of Ted, they still serve as a significant parallel.

1 Sid Changes His Career Path Like Ted

In the show How I Met Your Father, Sid chooses to abandon his career path in medicine and instead purchases Pemberton's bar, dedicating all his efforts to ensure its success. Similarly, Ted, initially working as an architect in How I Met Your Mother, later transitions to becoming a professor, a decision that brings him great joy. This parallel demonstrates the adaptability of both characters in their professional endeavors.