Kelsey Grammer's explanation regarding Niles Crane's absence in the Frasier reboot hints at a darker direction for the character. Initially, NBC went back on their previous information about Niles being an only child in Cheers after recognizing the potential of David Hyde Pierce portraying Frasier's younger brother. The original Frasier series didn't emphasize this inconsistency in order to create a more intriguing storyline. While Grammer excels in his portrayal of the titular character, Pierce's Niles undeniably steals the spotlight. Therefore, the announcement of Paramount+ reviving the critically acclaimed series generated immediate excitement for the long-awaited reunion of Frasier and Niles on the small screen.
However, bringing the Frasier reboot to life was far from easy. Despite its critical success and dedicated fan base, Grammer had to work tirelessly for years to sell the idea to a platform. Even after Paramount+ officially greenlit the show, the writers struggled to establish its new premise. Matters worsened when none of the original Frasier cast members agreed to join the series, despite Grammer extending invitations. While Bebe Neuwirth and Peri Gilpin will make guest appearances, none of them committed to being regulars. This includes Pierce, leading to Niles' absence in the Frasier revival.
Frasier Keeping In Touch With Niles Shouldn’t Be Difficult In The Reboot
Pierce's decision not to return for Paramount+ shouldn't come as a surprise. The actor has been vocal about his opposition to bring back Frasier, knowing it could harm the show's legacy. Recently, he also expressed his desire not to reprise his role as Niles, leading Grammer's team to find an alternative for the fourth act of Frasier that doesn't involve his younger brother. Ultimately, they settled on bringing the character back to his old stomping grounds in Boston, effectively creating distance between him and Niles. Frasier and his brother rarely interacted during his time on Cheers, so the choice makes sense.
In a recent interview, Grammer stated that Niles won't be Frasier's go-to person in the revival. This means Frasier will have to form new relationships to fill that void. Despite the physical distance, staying in touch should be relatively easy given the numerous communication tools available. There is also no valid reason why Niles and Daphne can't visit Frasier in New England. While it made sense for Niles to never visit Boston during Cheers due to his troubled marriage with Maris, now that his son is grown-up and living there, there is no acceptable explanation for Niles' lack of involvement in the Frasier reboot.
Only A Falling Out Can Explain Frasier & Niles' Reboot Situation
In short, it is inexplicable that Frasier and Niles do not maintain regular communication in the upcoming revival. Throughout the series set in Seattle, the brothers were virtually inseparable, participating in numerous activities together. They frequented social events as a duo and would often enjoy their usual coffee at Cafe Nervosa. Their close bond was even a focal point of several storylines in the original Frasier series, highlighting their apparent codependency. Considering the recent passing of their father, Martin Crane, it would be expected for the brothers to check in on each other regularly.
Given this, it is hard to fathom that the brothers now have little to no communication, with Frasier unable to rely on Niles for advice - unless there has been a falling out between them. Despite their strong relationship, conflicts were not foreign to the Crane brothers. Whenever the Cheers spin-off required a change, it usually involved some form of issue between them. Their disputes ranged from serious to trivial, although the latter often resulted in comedic moments. However, as they age, it is not unlikely for them to encounter more significant disagreements.
What Frasier & Niles’ Conflict May Be About
In the upcoming revival, it is quite intriguing to consider why Frasier and Niles are currently not on speaking terms. Despite their close relationship, shared interests, and profession, it seems unlikely that they would run out of topics to discuss. However, their competitive nature is a recurring theme in the original Frasier show. Multiple instances demonstrated that despite their initial collaborations, they eventually realized they were incompatible as work partners.
Regrettably, in the original series, Frasier and Niles failed to grasp the harsh reality that they were unable to successfully collaborate on significant endeavors. If it weren't for their father, Marty, constantly intervening and forcing them to reconcile, their animosity would have persisted, given their stubborn pride. With the absence of their father, it is possible that this current conflict is lasting longer. This adds an additional layer of tragedy to the Frasier reboot, as it not only deals with the immense loss of their patriarch, but also the potential rift between Niles and Frasier.
The Frasier Reboot Is Essentially Replacing Niles With Alan
The Frasier revival appears to be attempting to recreate the dynamic between Frasier, Martin, and Niles by focusing on Freddy and David as adults. Despite their parents' influence, Freddy chooses to become a civil servant firefighter like his grandfather, while David resembles a younger version of his father. Although Daphne also played a role in raising their son, Niles would have likely been more involved in David's life compared to his brother with his own son. Hence, even though David shares many traits with Niles, he cannot fill the role of Frasier's companion like his father did. This is where Nicholas Lyndhurst's character, Alan Cornwall, comes in. Described as Frasier's college friend, Alan re-enters the snobby psychiatrist's life upon his return to Boston. Essentially, Alan will serve as Frasier's new intellectual discourse partner. Kelsey Grammer has expressed excitement about Lyndhurst's involvement in the Frasier revival series. While it is highly likely that he will excel in this role, there remains a desire to witness the firstborn Crane sitting down with his younger brother for the best conversations over coffee.