The Magnificent Evolution of Leonardo DiCaprio: From Heartthrob to Scumbag Era

The Big Picture

Critics laud Leonardo DiCaprio's portrayal of Ernest Burkhart in Killers of the Flower Moon, heralding it as a standout performance that demonstrates his knack for captivating audiences even when playing a distasteful and unsightly character.

DiCaprio's career progression has steered him towards portraying characters characterized by their murky morality and self-serving mindsets, straying from his initial portrayal as a flawless individual.

His commitment to realizing his full potential and avoiding complacency is apparent in his selection of intricate roles and his tireless pursuit to push himself as an actor.

How Did Leonardo DiCaprio Get His Start in Hollywood?

Leonardo DiCaprio's performance in Killers of the Flower Moon continues to garner exceptional reviews, solidifying his collaboration with director Martin Scorsese as yet another standout role. Critics have hailed DiCaprio's portrayal of the detestable and repugnant Ernest Burkhart as his finest work to date. Despite Ernest's unsympathetic and repulsive nature, DiCaprio's magnetic presence serves as the driving force behind the captivating narrative. Observing the trajectory of his career, one can discern that he has been steadily progressing towards a moment like this, showcasing his utmost brilliance in portraying characters defined by their ambiguous morals and self-centered mindsets. This stark departure from his earlier golden boy persona underscores his unwavering commitment to realizing his immense potential and never resting on his laurels.

Image via Warner Bros. 

Leonardo DiCaprio's early career as a child actor showcased his ability to portray a young boy with a rebellious nature while maintaining an underlying charm. His breakthrough role in This Boy's Life not only earned him widespread recognition but also marked his first on-screen collaboration with Robert De Niro. In the film, DiCaprio brilliantly portrays a teenager grappling with an abusive stepfather. His fearless portrayal of anguish, paired with his impressive ability to hold his own against seasoned performers like De Niro and Ellen Barkin, truly captivates viewers. DiCaprio effortlessly embodies the role of a "bad boy" who expresses his frustrations by challenging his abuser with a mix of composed restraint and occasional outbursts of rage. This Boy's Life showcases a level of emotional depth and versatility that was unexpected from a relatively unestablished actor like DiCaprio at the time.

Later that same year, Leonardo DiCaprio made his appearance in What's Eating Gilbert Grape, a film that further enhanced his emerging reputation as a remarkable new talent. In this movie, he takes on the role of Arnie, Gilbert's (played by Johnny Depp) younger brother, who has an intellectual disability. DiCaprio's portrayal of Arnie differs greatly from his performance in This Boy's Life. Arnie's endearing innocence and charm make him incredibly lovable, as DiCaprio effortlessly transitions from moments of pain and aggression to ones filled with tenderness and affection throughout the film. The wider audience took notice and recognized his talent, resulting in his first of six Academy Award nominations for his exceptional performance. With this newfound recognition, DiCaprio embarked on an extraordinary series of performances that firmly established his image.

How Did Leonardo DiCaprio Become a Romantic Icon?

Image via Paramount Pictures

The impact of Titanic and Romeo + Juliet cannot be underestimated. These two films were massive successes at the box office and solidified Leonardo DiCaprio's status as a romantic icon and a major male star of the future. Romeo + Juliet allowed DiCaprio to showcase his dramatic talent, amidst a film filled with extravagant and intense moments orchestrated by Baz Luhrmann. DiCaprio's performance was powerful and captivating, carrying on the tradition of doing justice to Shakespeare's work. On the other hand, Titanic presented DiCaprio in a matinée idol mode, as the perfect man who swept Rose (played by Kate Winslet) off her feet and made her believe that he was the only one worth obsessing over for a lifetime. Once again, we witness two extremes displayed with equal ease by DiCaprio, showcasing his ability to portray characters with exceptional effort and then seamlessly transitioning to seemingly effortless roles. However, the audience must also recognize that this charm-driven approach can only last for so long. Eventually, DiCaprio moved on from this phase to demonstrate his versatility by taking on characters with complex moral complexities.

What Was Leonardo DiCaprio and Martin Scorsese's First Movie Together?

Image via Miramax

Despite the disappointing film The Beach, DiCaprio found his footing when he teamed up with Martin Scorsese on Gangs of New York. While this film may not showcase either of their best work, it does demonstrate DiCaprio's newfound determination to take on challenging characters that may unsettle some viewers. Amsterdam Vallon is portrayed as a man haunted by his father's murder as an Irish immigrant in 1862 New York City, but he is also driven by a thirst for revenge against his father's killer (Daniel Day-Lewis). The movie goes to great lengths to highlight the stark transformation he undergoes from the innocent boy he once was. One could interpret this as an unintentional commentary on DiCaprio's own career trajectory, but he appears uneasy in the role, with a shaky Irish accent, perhaps reflecting his uncertainty in uncharted territory. Furthermore, DiCaprio is overshadowed in every scene he shares with Day-Lewis, who delivers one of his most intense performances. When considering the rest of DiCaprio's career, this serves as a rocky start to what would eventually become an incredible series of standout performances, where he becomes increasingly free to unleash his inner brilliance.

When Did Leonardo DiCaprio Start Playing More Complex Roles?

Warner Bros. presents this captivating image.

In "Catch Me If You Can," an underrated caper directed by Steven Spielberg, Leonardo DiCaprio masterfully portrays the charm-infused depravity that lies beneath his character's surface. Frank Abagnale, Jr. emerges as the ultimate fraudster, capable of effortlessly deceiving and captivating anyone he encounters. DiCaprio immerses himself in the role, gliding through every scene, his every move exuding an unspoken understanding with the audience. Even in the later scenes where he faces the consequences of his actions, there is a profound sense of pathos as Frank's once joyous world comes crashing down, leaving him humiliated and remorseful.

If Gangs of New York served as a test run, then the Scorsese double bill of The Aviator and The Departed proved to be the ultimate successes, showcasing two of DiCaprio's most exceptional performances. Portraying the iconic billionaire recluse Howard Hughes and the undercover cop Billy Costigan respectively, both roles shine brightly for the raw intensity that DiCaprio brings to them. Whether he finds himself trapped in a bathroom, unable to touch a doorknob, or sweating profusely while maintaining his cover amidst dangerous crime bosses, his ability to embody individuals entrapped by societal structures, both self-imposed and forced upon them, is unparalleled. In both portrayals, these men construct personas for themselves that they feel compelled to uphold, even when it inflicts immense suffering. DiCaprio fearlessly embraces ugliness, cowardice, and a disturbing quality to authentically convey the truth of the character.

Leonardo DiCaprio's at His Best Playing Truly Treacherous Villains

Image courtesy of The Weinstein Company

Leonardo DiCaprio attained unprecedented heights of debauchery in what are arguably his two most remarkable roles: portraying Calvin Candie in Quentin Tarantino's Django Unchained and Jordan Belfort in Scorsese's The Wolf of Wall Street. These characters could easily be regarded as the most abhorrent creatures he has ever portrayed on screen. As Candie, he embodied the persona of a monstrous slave owner, exhibiting an arrogant demeanor fused with a faux sense of sophistication. Meanwhile, as Belfort, he portrayed a deceitful stock trader who reveled in his opulence and unapologetically shared his insider knowledge with the audience. What makes these performances truly astonishing is how unflinchingly they challenge DiCaprio's well-established public image, pushing the boundaries of audience investment to their limits amidst decades of familiarity.

Tarantino brilliantly mocked DiCaprio's inherent tendencies, transforming his charm and confidence into a captivating display of unattractive repulsion; one need only observe the unforgettable zoom-in shot of Candie, wearing a smile that should have emitted a deafening foghorn noise. On the other hand, Scorsese amplified all aspects of DiCaprio's character to an extreme, encapsulating them within a polished yet detestable package. Jordan consistently portrays himself as sympathetic, even overtly dismissing the slightest introspective moments with a mocking gesture towards the audience, ridiculing us for assuming he would change. DiCaprio's conspiratorial breaking of the fourth wall and his frenzied commitment to Jordan's shamelessness truly reveal a unhinged side of him unrivaled in his entire career. It's truly astonishing to think he didn't receive an Oscar for this remarkable performance.

Why Does Leonardo DiCaprio's 'Killers of the Flower Moon' Stand Out?

Image via Apple Studios

Now, let's come back to the present. Leonardo DiCaprio's portrayal of Ernest Burkhart is the accumulation of a lifetime of mastering the art of playing the villain, reaching a point where he can no longer rely on his youthful charm or natural charisma. If one were to argue that this is his absolute best performance, it would be because it feels like a completely original creation, not completely reliant on his previous successes. While Ernest may possess a youthful charm and a familiar face as Leonardo DiCaprio, in all other aspects, he is an entirely new entity. He embodies the role of a thuggish, easily manipulated war veteran, plagued by a distorted perception of love and a sense of loyalty reminiscent of an abused puppy. Ernest's character serves as a promising indication that DiCaprio is more dedicated than ever to pushing himself to the edge, revealing the darkest depths of human nature for all to witness. Let's hope he gets the opportunity to portray Jim Jones someday, as he would undoubtedly deliver an astounding performance.

Killers of the Flower Moon is in theaters in the U.S. now.

Killers of the Flower Moon