The Jaw-Dropping Transformations of the Sabrina the Teenage Witch Cast

Summary

Melissa Joan Hart, who played Sabrina on "Sabrina The Teenage Witch," continued acting in various films and TV shows, including "Melissa & Joey" with Joey Lawrence.

Returning to her character as Zelda Spellman, Beth Broderick came back in "Chilling Adventures of Sabrina." In addition, she took part in various Christmas movies as well as appearing in a range of TV shows and films. Joining her, Caroline Rhea reprised her role as Hilda Spellman in an Easter egg episode of "Chilling Adventures of Sabrina" and also showcased her talent in other TV shows and films, including Disney shows and "The Perfect Man."

Melissa Joan Hart gained fame for her role as Sabrina Spellman in the 1996 sitcom Sabrina The Teenage Witch. The show, based on the Archie Comics series, had a lighter and more comedic tone compared to the later adaptation, Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina. Alongside Hart, the series also featured Beth Broderick and Caroline Rhea, with appearances by celebrities like Britney Spears. Although a reboot of the show took place years later, Chilling Adventures of Sabrina season 5 will not be happening. Nevertheless, the character's legacy lives on in the comics.

Hart's portrayal of Sabrina helped her gain widespread recognition, leading to the creation of her own doll. While Hart continued to pursue acting, her co-stars also achieved notable success throughout the years. Let's take a look at what the cast of Sabrina The Teenage Witch has been up to since the series finale in 2003.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

Melissa Joan Hart

After starring in Sabrina The Teenage Witch, Melissa Joan Hart went on to appear in several other films and shows. She even did some voice acting in Justice League Unlimited and Disney Channel's Recess. From 2010 to 2015, Hart teamed up with another beloved 90s TV star, Joey Lawrence from Brotherly Love, in the sitcom Melissa & Joey. When Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina premiered on Netflix in 2018, with Kiernan Shipka taking over the role of Sabrina Spellman, Hart showed her support but admitted she didn't think she was in the show's target demographic. Both Hart and Lawrence made appearances on The Masked Singer during its ninth season earlier this year.

Beth Broderick

Caroline Rhea

Unlike Hart, Beth Broderick, who played Zelda Spellman in Sabrina The Teenage Witch, returned to her character in Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina but only for one episode in 2021, where Sabrina encountered a different reality. Broderick has also appeared in several Christmas films over the years, including Always and Forever Christmas and When I Think of Christmas. Most recently, she acted as Bertha Pomeroy in three episodes of MAX's Love & Death. Additionally, Broderick had a role as Kitty in Robin Givens' upcoming 2023 film, The Nana Project.

Caroline Rhea reprised her role as Hilda Spellman from Sabrina The Teenage Witch in an Easter egg episode of Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina season 4. Following the show, Rhea continued her career in television, making appearances on Disney shows such as The Suite Life of Zack & Cody and Phineas and Ferb. In 2005, she starred alongside Disney alum Hilary Duff in The Perfect Man and later made a return to the channel for Sydney to the Max. In recent years, the Sabrina The Teenage Witch actress has been seen in Chibiverse, Lopez vs. Lopez, and the 2023 short film Fanatic.

Nick Bakay

Nick Bakay has played a pivotal role behind the scenes on Sabrina The Teenage Witch. Although he never appeared on screen, his voice talents brought Salem, Sabrina's witty and sarcastic black cat, to life. Apart from his stint on Sabrina, Bakay took on the movie Zookeeper in 2011 but predominantly focused on voice acting. One notable example is his portrayal of Warlock in Cartoon Network's 2019 series OK K.O.! Let's Be Heroes. In addition to his voice work, Bakay has also made significant contributions as an executive producer on hit shows like Young Sheldon and Two and a Half Men.

Nate Richert

Harvey, Sabrina's boyfriend turned best friend, was an integral character in Sabrina The Teenage Witch, portrayed by Nate Richert. Following the conclusion of the show, Richert didn't pursue extensive acting opportunities but made notable appearances in projects like The Sure Hand of God (2004) and Home Work (2020). Nonetheless, he always finds joy in reuniting with his fellow Sabrina The Teenage Witch cast members, as evidenced by the delightful photos he shares on his Instagram page.

Jenna Leigh Green

Michelle Beaudoin

Jenna Leigh Green portrayed the mean girl character, Libby Chessler, in several sitcoms of the 90s and 2000s. Since then, she has secured various roles in different productions. Notably, Green played Heather in 2010's You Again and made an appearance in an episode of Bones in 2011. Recently, in 2021, she portrayed Nancy Vogel on the Gossip Girl reboot and also had a guest role in an episode of NCIS: Hawaiʻi. Green's most recent credited work can be seen in a 2022 episode of Blue Bloods.

Jennifer, played by Michelle Beaudoin, was another one of Sabrina's closest friends during their high school years. However, since 2006, Beaudoin has not pursued any further acting opportunities. Besides her memorable role in Sabrina The Witch, she also appeared in other TV shows such as Cold Squad and The Outer Limits.

Lindsay Sloane

Valerie, played by Lindsay Sloane, became Sabrina's new close friend, seemingly replacing Jennifer after season 1. Sloane, known for her roles in popular television shows like How I Met Your Mother and movies like 2011's Horrible Bosses, recently portrayed Judy Hitman in a 2023 episode of The Wonder Years.

Elisa Donovan

In addition to her iconic role as Amber in Clueless, Elisa Donovan also made appearances in later seasons of Sabrina The Teenage Witch. Within the show, Donovan portrayed the character Morgan Cavanaugh, one of Sabrina's college roommates. While she is primarily recognized for her contribution to Clueless, the actress also starred in several installments of "The Dog Who Saved" film series, including the 2015 release, The Dog Who Saved Summer. Active on TikTok, Donovan frequently shares content related to her Clueless experience, and her most recent acting endeavor was in the 2023 Clueless Superbowl Commercial.

Soleil Moon Frye

Soleil Moon Frye portrayed Sabrina's other college roommate, Roxie King, who had a strikingly different personality compared to Morgan. Like Nick Bakay, King has dedicated a significant amount of her time to working as a voice actor. Most recently, she lent her voice to the character Zoey in The Proud Family: Louder and Prouder, following her previous portrayal in the original Disney Channel series. King's talent in voice acting extends beyond this, as she has also contributed her voice to various animated Bratz films, specifically voicing the character Jade. In a heartwarming reunion, according to her Instagram, Katz reunited with Melissa Joan Hart in June on the Today Show. Beyond her successful career in entertainment, she is also a devoted mother and frequently shares photos of her and her family.

Martin Mull

Martin Mull, who played the character of Sabrina's principal, Mr. Kraft, has continued to have a successful acting career after the show's end. He has made appearances in popular shows such as Two and a Half Men, Community, and NCIS: Los Angeles. In 2016, Mull received an Emmy nomination for his portrayal of Bob Bradley in Veep. Additionally, he made a guest appearance in an episode of the short-lived series Maggie on Hulu and acted alongside Gina Rodriguez in Not Dead Yet. Mull's most recent role was in two episodes of Apple TV's The Afterparty in 2023.

Alimi Ballard

Albert Quizmaster played a significant role in Sabrina's development as a witch, greatly assisting her in mastering her powers. Alimi Ballard portrayed this character and has since maintained a successful acting career. Presently, he can be seen as Mayor Randall Taylor in the TV series Kings Of L.A. Following his time on Sabrina The Teenage Witch, Ballard made appearances in NCIS, Hollywood Heights, and even reunited with Melissa Joan Hart in an episode of Melissa & Joey.

Dylan Neal

In the final season of Sabrina The Teenage Witch, Sabrina encounters Aaron Jacobs and they enter into a romantic relationship. Despite nearly tying the knot, Sabrina ultimately realizes her true feelings for Harvey. In a bold move, she leaves her own wedding to confess her love to her longtime best friend from high school. Portrayed by Dylan Neal, Aaron's acting journey expanded beyond the show. Notably, Neal took on the role of Bob in the 2015 film Fifty Shades of Grey, as well as its sequel, Fifty Shades Freed, in 2018. The year 2023 witnessed his appearance as Daniel Booker in four captivating episodes of Ride, where he starred alongside Nancy Travis and Tiera Skovbye. Nonetheless, his portrayal of Aaron will always hold a special place, just like his fellow Sabrina The Teenage Witch cast members.