The Hidden Gems: Unveiling 10 Lesser-Known True Crime Shows That Will Leave You Spellbound

For every renowned docuseries showcasing infamous serial killers and notorious crimes, there exist a multitude of captivating documentary series that delve into lesser-known true-crime cases. In fact, some of the finest true-crime shows are those that introduce us to unfamiliar narratives, offering unexpected twists and surprises. While many true-crime enthusiasts initially become enamored with well-known cases and popular podcasts, which later become adapted into documentary series, once they venture beyond the familiar, they discover an array of obscure yet equally intriguing crime stories that have been transformed into episodic entertainment.

The most mesmerizing true-crime documentary series are those that combine an extraordinary or exceptionally captivating narrative with compelling cinematic storytelling. While many revolve around gripping murder cases, an increasing number of remarkable true-crime docuseries delve into financial misconduct and scams orchestrated by con artists. Some of these tales are so incredible and the series so riveting that it’s easy to momentarily forget that they depict real cases where individuals have been killed or severely harmed. However, the very allure of true crime stems from its lack of relatability, and the more removed these stories are from our own reality, particularly the lesser-known cases, the more enthralling they become.

10 The Innocent Man (2018)

9 How I Caught My Killer (2023)

Renowned for his legal thrillers and their film adaptations, John Grisham ventured into a lesser-known genre with his nonfiction true-crime book, "The Innocent Man: Murder and Injustice in a Small Town." Nearly ten years after its release, Netflix unveiled a compelling adaptation of this work, skillfully directed by Clay Tweel (known for "Finders Keepers"). The series delves into not only the original case but also intertwines another related murder from the same time and place. Distinct from typical documentaries exposing the flaws of the justice system, "The Innocent Man" captures the essence of a gripping page-turner while still highlighting these systemic injustices.

In contention for a Critics Choice Award in the Best Crime/Justice category, How I Caught My Killer stands out as an anthology true-crime documentary series that delves into multiple lesser-known cases. Although the title may evoke a supernatural sensation, each episode focuses on murder victims who ingeniously aid in the posthumous discovery of their killer through their social media activity and personal documentation. The inclusion of these diverse yet interconnected stories not only captivates viewers but also serves as a valuable collection of cautionary tales, albeit under the bittersweet realization that the show could have been named "How I Caught My Would-be Killer" due to the evidence involved.

8 The Pharmacist (2020)

7 Love Fraud (2020)

This Netflix true-crime documentary series initially appears to be straight out of a Hollywood movie. It revolves around a father, Dan Schneider, who grows dissatisfied with the actions of law enforcement in his son's murder case, leading him to take matters into his own hands. Determined to uncover the truth behind his son's tragic fate, which occurred during a drug deal, Schneider tirelessly delves deeper into the investigation. His relentless pursuit ultimately uncovers not only the culprits behind his son's death, but also exposes the involvement of medical and corporate wrongdoers in the local Louisiana opioid crisis. Starting as a lesser-known case, The Pharmacist evolves into a gripping true-crime narrative that has far-reaching implications, affecting the lives of countless Americans.

Love Fraud, a documentary series by Oscar-nominated filmmakers Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady (known for Jesus Camp), delves into the heart-wrenching world of true crime. Focused on a lesser-known case, the four-part Showtime program features interviews with several women who have fallen victim to the manipulative schemes of con artist Richard Scott Smith. As the filmmakers uncover Smith's ongoing deception, their involvement in the case takes on an in-the-moment investigative journey, resulting in a confessional piece. The final episode of Love Fraud delivers a particularly cringe-worthy segment that leaves viewers utterly shocked.

6 The Confession Killer (2019)

The intriguing aspect of The Confession Killer's Henry Lee Lucas being a relatively unknown figure in the realm of true crime is captivating in itself. Lucas, who claimed to have committed over 600 murders, was once considered the most prolific serial killer in history. However, doubts regarding the veracity of his confessions arose. Nevertheless, the Texas Rangers, placing faith in the words of this criminal, closed numerous cases based on Lucas's testimony. This series presents a unique narrative, shedding light on a flawed justice system different from the prevalent innocent-man films. However, the ultimate conclusion remains damning: many within law enforcement are inclined to solve cases regardless of their rightful resolution or lack thereof.

5 Paul T. Goldman (2023)

Peacock's documentary series, Paul T. Goldman, revolves around a crime, but what sets it apart is the protagonist's unwavering belief in a much larger truth. This six-part show weaves a narrative that draws from Goldman's exaggerated suspicions about his ex-wife, a notorious con artist. The series also incorporates elements from Goldman's speculative books, which go beyond the already stretched "truth." Paul T. Goldman is unparalleled in the true-crime genre. Its willingness to dive into theoretical and scripted realms has divided the fanbase, but there's no denying the captivating nature of this outrageous tale involving an extraordinary individual.

4 Murder On Middle Beach (2020)

First-person documentaries can sometimes become overly self-indulgent and lose their focus. However, Murder on Middle Beach is a rare gem that defies this trend. Its intimate and introspective storytelling not only enhances the true-crime element at its core but also adds depth to the narrative. Director Madison Hamburg blends a personal investigation into his mother's death with a heartfelt family portrait and a powerful expression of grief. Given that most of the suspects in the murder of Barbara Hamburg are relatives and close acquaintances, approaching the story from an internal perspective feels appropriate. Unlike many true-crime documentary series that feel detached and exploitative, Murder on Middle Beach succeeds in making the audience genuinely care about the individuals involved as much as the story itself.

3 Don't F**k With Cats: Hunting An Internet Killer (2019)

This Netflix documentary series offers an intriguing blend of an unpredictable true-crime narrative and captivating plot development. Don't F**ck with Cats: Hunting an Internet Killer consists of three episodes that are so addictively watchable, it feels like a prolonged feature. Going into this series with minimal knowledge adds to its allure, as it delves into an amateur investigation of the purported death of some kittens, which escalates into a much larger case. While the true-crime genre has often been ridiculed for inspiring amateur detectives, Don't F**k with Cats demonstrates its potential for serious engagement.

2 The Keepers (2017)

1 Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Most Diabolical Bank Heist (2018)

A standout among the early Netflix documentary series in the current trend of long form true-crime content, The Keepers is not only one of the best, but also a captivating exploration of a small story that unveils a larger mystery. Unlike other true-crime narratives that stretch thin to fill time, Ryan White's seven-part documentary provides crucial details and compelling character moments. Its narrative is skillfully crafted, delving into both the micro and macro aspects of the unsolved murder of a nun in Baltimore in 1969. What initially appears to be a tale rooted in the past ultimately proves to be a highly relevant and contemporary account.

The mind-bending and tragic tale of Evil Genius: The True Story of America's Diabolical Bank Heist has already garnered attention as a potential Hollywood crime comedy (30 Minutes or Less, though the creators deny any connection). However, it is always said that truth surpasses fiction in its sheer strangeness. This captivating documentary series delves into the case of Brian Wells, a pizza delivery person coerced into robbing a bank with a bomb collar strapped to him. Given the intricate nature of this case, it is remarkable how the filmmakers managed to unravel and present it coherently within just four episodes.