The Game-Changing Lost Regeneration Scene That Could Have Altered Doctor Who Forever

Summary

The regeneration scene of David Tennant in Doctor Who could have had a significantly different effect on the Doctor's character, but the final take managed to capture the perfect blend of sorrow and courage.

Tennant's Doctor stands out due to his two regenerations with the same face, and he holds the distinction of being the only Doctor to reappear in the 60th Anniversary Special. The proposed alternative regeneration scene would have undermined his established courage and resilience by making him excessively self-pitying and conflicted. On the other hand, the selected scene effectively conveyed his internal grief while also paying homage to his character's past.

David Tennant's regeneration scene in Doctor Who was nearly unrecognizable, potentially altering the Doctor's entire essence. Unlike other regenerations, Tennant's Doctor underwent the process twice, retaining the same face after the initial transformation in series 4, episode 13, "Journey's End." Notably, he is also the only Doctor to reappear, as seen in Jodie Whittaker's 13th Doctor regenerating back into Tennant, a development that will be explored in the Doctor Who 60th Anniversary Special preceding season 14.

While numerous Doctors have made comebacks throughout the series, Tennant's connection to the role is particularly significant. He regenerated twice before passing the torch to Matt Smith's 11th Doctor, and he additionally made a notable return for the 50th Anniversary Special. It is fitting that Tennant has returned on multiple occasions, given that he is the only Doctor to display overt sadness when transitioning into a new incarnation. Although each Doctor's regeneration has provoked some level of sorrow, they typically exude a sense of calmness and acceptance, as if recognizing the rightness of the moment. Tennant's portrayal, however, diverged from this pattern during his 10th Doctor regeneration.

Your browser does not support the video tag.

Doctor Who's Cut Tennant Regeneration Scene Changed The Doctor's Persona

Tennant's regeneration as Doctor Who stood apart from the rest, but his cut regeneration scene had the potential to alter the Doctor's entire persona. Renowned for his line "I don't want to go," Tennant's regeneration in the 2010 Christmas special "The End of Time: Part 2" has now been unveiled by the Doctor Who Confidential series, revealing four alternate takes for that scene, each escalating in emotional intensity. The fourth take portrays the Doctor in tears, on the brink of a breakdown, as he mutters "I don't want to go," a stark contrast to the version that was ultimately broadcasted.

The Doctor confessing his reluctance to depart was a significant departure from the norm, as no previous incarnation of the Doctor had ever exhibited such a sentiment. Regeneration has always been an integral part of the Doctor's existence. However, if he had succumbed to overwhelming grief, it would have fundamentally redefined his character. According to Tennant in the Doctor Who Confidential video, the fourth take was deemed inconsistent with the Doctor's core personality traits such as bravery and stoicism. The alternative regeneration scene would have rendered the Doctor excessively self-pitying, contradicting the resilience he had acquired throughout centuries of enduring challenging life moments.

Why Doctor Who's Aired David Tennant Regeneration Was The Right Take

Doctor Who made a significant impact by revealing that Tennant's Doctor did not want to regenerate. However, using the alternate take would have taken it too far. The third take perfectly balances the Doctor's strength and fear, making it even more heart-wrenching for the audience. Although visibly saddened by the need to regenerate, Tennant's Doctor maintains control of his emotions, displaying his signature bravery. The chosen take gives the impression that his confession of not wanting to leave slipped out unintentionally, as he tries to remain strong despite his emotions.

The Doctor never welcomes regeneration, as it alters their identity and personality. Yet, they always accept its necessity. This intensifies the emotional impact on the audience, as it is difficult to witness the Doctor being so courageous in such a challenging moment. This is why the selected take for Tennant's regeneration was the right decision. By containing Tennant's emotions, the portrayal in Doctor Who becomes more poignant and true to the Doctor's profound understanding of the necessity to regenerate and change.