The Definitive Ranking of Dustin Hoffman's Oscar-Nominated Performances

Dustin Hoffman, a highly acclaimed actor, has made a name for himself with his outstanding performances in some of the greatest films of all time. Emerging as a leading figure during the New Hollywood Era, Hoffman gained recognition for his role in Mike Nichols' 1967 romantic comedy-drama, "The Graduate," earning his first Oscar nomination and establishing himself as a prominent actor in the industry. From there, he embarked on a successful career spanning decades, showcasing his versatility in a variety of genres, ranging from hilarious comedies to gripping dramas.

Although Hoffman may not be as active in recent years as his peers such as Robert De Niro and Harrison Ford, his contribution to the film industry cannot be denied. Consistently ranked among the all-time best actors, he has received seven Oscar nominations, a testament to his exceptional talent. Furthermore, Hoffman has secured the Best Actor award twice, placing him in an esteemed group of performers. While all of his Oscar-nominated performances are exceptional, some have undeniably become iconic in cinema history.

7. 'Tootsie' - (1982)

Image via Columbia Pictures

Tootsie, the 1982 comedy blockbuster, remains a must-see despite some outdated jokes. Starring Hoffman as struggling actor Michael Dorsey, the film follows his successful transformation into the woman Dorothy Michaels to advance his career. However, the film's portrayal of gender has not aged well. The notion that a man would fare better by posing as a woman, particularly in a showbusiness industry that is sexist and exploitative, is implausible by today's standards. Nevertheless, Hoffman's performance is commendable. Despite the film's shortcomings, his portrayal of Dorothy is both hilarious and endearing, allowing viewers to momentarily overlook the problematic elements of the plot.

6. 'Wag the Dog' - (1997)

Image via New Line Cinema

Despite now being viewed as a commentary on the scandals during the Bill Clinton administration, Wag the Dog actually came out before news of the Monica Lewinsky scandal broke. This political satire by Barry Levinson explores the aftermath of a similar Presidential scandal, leading the President's office to hire Hollywood spin doctor Conrad Brean (played by Robert De Niro) and Hollywood producer Stanley Motss (played by Hoffman) to come up with a plan to deceive the public. Their solution? Fabricate a war to divert attention from the sex scandal.

Wag the Dog's biting commentary remains incredibly relevant, and its cynical tone and approach are likely to provoke strong reactions from politically engaged viewers. Hoffman delves into the role with his signature lighthearted charm and embraces the eccentricities of the story. However, De Niro's scene-stealing performance is so remarkable that it's surprising only Hoffman received a nomination.

5. 'Lenny' - (1974)

Image via United Artists

Lenny Bruce, a pioneering comedian, transformed the stand-up craft with his groundbreaking routines. In the 1974 biopic Lenny, directed by Bob Fosse, we delve into how Bruce's desire for political change influenced his career. Bruce's intense passion for the country's direction manifested in each of his shows, even amidst his humor.

Hoffman brilliantly portrays the instability of Bruce's lifestyle. The lewd and hateful persona Bruce crafted on stage differed from his personal life. Hoffman's magnetic performance, coupled with Fosse's stylized approach, creates a sense of detachment from Bruce, while also injecting the character with dynamic restlessness. Lenny stands out as one of the top movies of 1974, and although Hoffman's portrayal deserved an Oscar, he lost to Art Carney in Harry and Tonto, leaving many baffled by the Academy's decision.

4. 'Kramer vs. Kramer' (1979)

Image via Columbia Pictures

Kramer vs. Kramer was a groundbreaking film in 1979 for its fair portrayal of both spouses in a divorce. While some parts may not hold up well today, the movie makes a sincere effort to understand the challenges faced by single fathers and struggling mothers. The story revolves around a custody battle for young Bill (Justin Henry) between his father, Ted (Hoffman), and mother, Joanna (Meryl Streep).

Interestingly, Ted is not depicted as a perfect person from the start, and Hoffman skillfully embraces his character's flaws. The actor beautifully showcases Ted's transformation as he navigates parenthood, becoming more compassionate and revealing a softer side to a previously unlikable protagonist. While the courtroom scenes allow Hoffman to showcase his talent, it is his early moments with Henry that truly highlight his award-winning performance at the 1980 Academy Awards.

3. 'Midnight Cowboy' (1969)

Image via United Artists

Content

Considered one of the most controversial films ever released, Midnight Cowboy, which premiered in 1969, holds the distinction of being the only X-rated film to have won the prestigious Best Picture award. The movie centers around Joe Buck, a naïve male prostitute from Texas played by Jon Voight, and "Ratso," a sickly conman portrayed by Hoffman, as they navigate through the crime-infested streets of New York City in a attempt to survive.

Despite the passage of time, Midnight Cowboy maintains a distinctly modern quality in its unflinching portrayal of poverty. The genuine and unexpected bond between Buck and Ratso is incredibly impactful, making the film's heartrending conclusion even more powerful. While it could be argued that Voight's performance outshines Hoffman's, it is Hoffman who truly embodies the emotional essence of the film, leaving a lasting impression on audiences even after the credits roll.

2. 'Rain Man' (1988)

Image via MGM/UA Communications Co.

Rain Man, which earned Hoffman a second Oscar, is primarily remembered as a captivating two-person show. The award-winning Best Picture of 1988 tells the story of Charlie Babbitt (Tom Cruise), a conceited sports agent who discovers that his father had secretly left his entire fortune to his previously unknown brother. Determined to connect with Raymond (Hoffman), his older sibling, Charlie embarks on a road trip to Las Vegas alongside his girlfriend Susanna (Valeria Golino).

The film's strength lies in the exceptional on-screen chemistry between Cruise and Hoffman, as they skillfully bring their characters to life and create a heartwarming dynamic. Although Hoffman's portrayal of Raymond is commendable, the movie's depiction of him as a savant now faces criticism for perpetuating harmful stereotypes about autism. Rain Man, hailed as an iconic 80s film, may not have aged well overall, but Hoffman's performance remains remarkable from a technical perspective.

1. 'The Graduate' (1967)

Image via Embassy Pictures

Mike Nichols initially had a different cast in mind for The Graduate, but fortunately for Hoffman, he secured the role. The story revolves around Benjamin Braddock, a young man who feels lost after completing his bachelor's degree. While contemplating his future, Benjamin finds himself drawn to both an older married woman, Mrs. Robinson (Anne Bancroft), and her shy daughter, Elaine (Katharine Ross).

Although The Graduate has influenced numerous "sex comedies" since its initial release, only a few can match its brilliance. The film skillfully delves into the challenges of transitioning from youth to adulthood. Hoffman's performance is a perfect blend of humor and tragedy, capturing Benjamin's insecurities and creating a timeless portrayal of uncertainty and confusion that resonates even today, just as it did in 1967.