The Crucial Character Reacher Season 2 Can't Afford to Forget (Even If They Don't Come Back)
Reacher Season 2 Must Address Roscoe's Absence: Discussing her impact would enhance the storyline more than featuring her in person
Summary
Reacher season 2 will introduce a new story, leaving behind many key characters from season 1, but it cannot ignore the impact of Jack Reacher's romantic ties with Roscoe.
Despite Jack and Roscoe not ending up together, it is crucial for Reacher season 2 to recognize their relationship and the influence that Roscoe had on Jack. Rather than reintroducing Roscoe in season 2, it would be more suitable to make a mention of her, ensuring that it does not undermine her choice to remain in Margrave and pursue her own aspirations.
Reacher season 2's storyline involves the absence of many key characters from season 1. However, the series cannot overlook its most significant absence. After dealing with the Kliners' mystery in Margrave, Georgia, Alan Ritchson's Jack Reacher embarks on a new case with personal connections. Instead of following a chronological order, Amazon Prime Video's adaptation of Lee Child's Jack Reacher books jumps ahead to the Bad Luck and Trouble-inspired season 2, after the events of the Killing Floor-based season 1.
In the season 1 finale of Reacher, Jack bids farewell to his newfound friends in Margrave. Despite the connections he formed and his romantic involvement with Roscoe Conklin from the Margrave PD, he chooses to continue his nomadic lifestyle, moving from place to place. While it would have been possible for him to stay and settle down in the rural town, Jack knows what he truly wants in life and leaves it behind. As a result, bringing back the supporting characters from season 1 becomes nearly impossible.
Reacher Season 2 Needs To Keep Roscoe Relevant (Despite Her Absence)
As Jack embarks on his continued journey and Roscoe remains rooted in Margrave during season 2, the season 1 finale distinctly conveys that their affair is destined to never extend beyond their time spent in Georgia. However, while Reacher proceeds to unravel another enigma in a different locale, it is crucial for season 2 to acknowledge his connection to Roscoe. This does not necessitate Fitzgerald's reappearance in the Amazon Prime Video series. Rather, the show can maintain her relevance by having Jack make references to her. This ensures that her influence on him remains significant in Reacher, even though they are no longer together.
If Reacher season 2 disregards Roscoe entirely, it diminishes the authenticity and sincerity of their heartfelt love affair. It would imply that she meant nothing to him, as if he forgot about her the instant he departed Margrave. The fact that they didn't ultimately end up together doesn't diminish the depth of their care for one another. They simply had divergent aspirations in life and couldn't find common ground, compelling them to go their separate ways. Jack and Roscoe's separation was painful, yet amicable, enabling them to reminisce about their time together with warmth and affection.
Reacher Talking About Roscoe Would Be Better Than An Actual Cameo
While Finlay may make a comeback in the second season of Reacher after leaving Margrave to return to Boston, Roscoe's future lies in the rural town of Georgia. After the defeat of the Kliners and their accomplices, Roscoe finds herself reconsidering her desire to reclaim Margrave, as her family were its original settlers. Since the second season of Reacher takes place in a different region, it would be more fitting for Roscoe to be referenced rather than make an actual appearance, as it suggests that she has moved on from her personal goal.
