WARNING: SPOILERS for Star Trek: Strange New Worlds season 2, episode 9, "Subspace Rhapsody."
Summary
In the musical episode of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, Nurse Chapel makes the difficult decision to prioritize her career, thus bringing an end to her relationship with Lt. Spock. This breakup is further exacerbated by Ensign Boimler, who inadvertently divulges excessive information about Spock's emotions to Nurse Chapel.
After their breakup, Chapel finds solace in a fellowship and develops romantic feelings for Dr. Roger Korby, while Spock fully embraces his Vulcan nature and makes a firm commitment to suppress his human emotions.
It seems like Nurse Christine Chapel (portrayed by Jess Bush) and Lt. Spock (played by Ethan Peck) had just formed a connection on Star Trek: Strange New Worlds. However, in the musical episode titled "Subspace Rhapsody," their relationship appears to come to an end. The seeds of their separation were actually sown a few episodes earlier, in the crossover episode "Those Old Scientists" on Lower Decks. Ensign Brad Boimler (played by Jack Quaid) finds himself on Captain Pike's Enterprise and becomes puzzled by Spock's behavior, which resembles that of a human. Boimler mistakenly confides in Nurse Chapel about this, only to realize that her influence is what prompted Spock to explore his own humanity.
Spock & Chapel’s Breakup Is Partially Jack Quaid’s Boimler’s Fault
The dissolution of the relationship between Spock and Chapel cannot be solely attributed to Boimler, as the couple faced challenges in "Under the Cloak of War." When a former Klingon War General pays a visit to the Enterprise, it triggers painful memories for Christine, who served on the front lines of the Klingon War. Spock is uncertain about how to support her, leading to additional tension in their relationship. In the musical episode of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, Chapel ends her relationship with Spock through a captivating song and dance routine, prioritizing her career over their partnership. While Ensign Boimler may not bear complete responsibility, his actions certainly did not contribute positively to the situation.
Unaware of Nurse Chapel's romantic involvement with Spock, Boimler stops her in the turbolift during the Star Trek: Lower Decks crossover to inquire about the enigmatic character. However, his ignorance leads him to unintentionally disclose crucial information. This conversation serves as a turning point for Chapel, as she realizes that while Spock may currently be exploring his human side, this phase is not permanent. She understands that the iconic Spock, whom Boimler is familiar with, has chosen to suppress his emotions and fully embrace his Vulcan identity. Christine comes to the realization that their relationship is bound to be fleeting, prompting her to initiate distance between herself and Spock.
When Chapel discovers that she has been accepted into Dr. Roger Korby's fellowship in "Subspace Rhapsody," she realizes how much she wants to seize that opportunity. She acknowledges that pursuing this path would entail leaving Spock behind on the Enterprise. After Boimler suggested that her relationship with Spock was destined to fail, Christine chooses to embrace her future instead of investing in a relationship that is unlikely to endure. Had Boimler refrained from sharing his thoughts, Spock and Chapel's relationship might have taken a different trajectory.
What Happens Next To Spock & Chapel In Strange New Worlds
Dr. Roger Korby, a familiar name to those who follow Star Trek: The Original Series, appears in the timeline of Strange New Worlds. In TOS, Nurse Chapel is engaged to Dr. Korby, and the events leading up to their engagement are rapidly approaching in Strange New Worlds. After the episode "Subspace Rhapsody," Christine shows signs of being ready to embrace the opportunity presented by Dr. Korby, and it seems she will develop romantic feelings for him. However, Spock also has his moment to shine, following Christine's grand musical performance in "Subspace Rhapsody." Regrettably, his song carries a much more sorrowful tone.
After discovering Christine's feelings, Spock confides in Ensign Uhura about his own emotions. Through a captivating musical performance, he displays his inclination to reject human emotions and fully embrace the Vulcan way of life. Spock grapples with the heartache of his separation from Chapel and makes a solemn promise to prioritize reason and logic. While the ultimate fate of Spock and Chapel remains uncertain in Star Trek: Strange New Worlds, it is evident that their journey is diverging, leading them towards separate destinies. Mark your calendars for the streaming of the season 2 finale of Star Trek: Strange New Worlds on August 10, exclusively on Paramount+.