Highlights
Enterprise, the Star Trek spin-off, remains the most divisive series, even for actor Jolene Blalock who played T'Pol.
The show's attempt to be original by delving into the early days of the Federation was hindered by problems with its execution and the inconsistent portrayal of T'Pol. T'Pol's character was reduced to a sexual object, overlooking her key Vulcan traits, which ultimately prevented the show from achieving the success of its predecessors.
Enterprise, the spin-off series from Star Trek, continues to be the subject of heated debate even for Jolene Blalock, the actress who portrayed T'Pol.
Diverging from the established conventions of the Star Trek universe, Enterprise sought to offer a unique perspective. The show took place in the 22nd century, during the formative years of the Federation, and delved into the complicated relationship between humans and Vulcans, before the widespread use of holodecks and teleportation technology. Despite its potential to be a commendable addition to the Star Trek canon, Enterprise encountered difficulties, particularly in its portrayal of the Vulcan character, T'Pol.
In the oral history of Star Trek: Enterprise, /Film reported that Blalock expressed her disapproval of her character's plotlines. "The concepts of the shows are not the problem; in fact, they are amazing," said Blalock. "My issue lies with the dialogue. I personally believed that T'Pol should have a more pronounced representation of her Vulcan culture. I don't think she should seem as desperate as everyone else."
As the series progressed, the actor observed mounting inconsistencies with the portrayal of T'Pol's character. Blalock, being a devoted fan of the original series and an expert on Vulcan behavior, noticed clashes between T'Pol's references to American and Earth culture and the Vulcan way of life. Furthermore, the actor pointed out evident errors, such as T'Pol eating with her hands, which contradicted the social etiquette of Vulcans and would be opposed by any Star Trek fan. Most distressing, however, was the continuous sexualization of the character.
Unfortunately, the creatives behind Enterprise failed to learn from Jeri Ryan's experience as Seven of Nine in Star Trek: Voyager and shamelessly used Blalock as a mere sex symbol. Her uniform was consistently different from others, serving to accentuate her sexuality without any clear justification. Blalock also expressed criticism towards storylines that involved T'Pol developing a drug addiction. Co-creator Brannon Braga acknowledged the actor's disagreement with the character's direction, but the conflict remained unresolved.
Blalock's concerns regarding her character were just a small factor contributing to the failure of Enterprise to gain popularity, despite a handful of underrated episodes. The show lasted for four seasons, but it never reached the same level of success as its predecessors. T'Pol, in particular, suffered from dropped plot lines and disregard for her Vulcan attributes. It is unfortunate that a series that aimed to be unique struggled in this regard. While Enterprise did possess the foundational elements, such as a commendable captain and a supportive crew, many aspects of the show suffered as they tried to prioritize character development. As a result, Enterprise lacked the longevity and iconic status of other series. The characters have largely faded from memory, and shortly after the show concluded, the Star Trek feature films underwent a complete reboot. Currently, seasons 1-4 of Star Trek: Enterprise can be streamed on Paramount Plus.
Source: The Fifty-Year Mission: The Next 25 Years: From The Next Generation to J. J. Abrams (via /Film)